Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Sibling continually oversteps boundaries

11 replies

Mamabearmamadragon · 25/07/2022 02:24

Hello everyone,

I am a parent of a 2.5 year old. I have a sister, with whom things were extremely tense before I became pregnant with my child. My sister and I are completely opposite with regards to Personality. She is very opinionated, brash, and can be very bossy/controlling, while I avoid confrontation and am generally accepting of everyone. We had seemingly gone our separate ways as young adults, as I was just tired of the constant fighting and feeling belittled and abused. Fast forward to three years ago, I had reconnected with my sister at a family event where I shared my pregnancy news. After this, my sister made an effort to call me and make plans. She wasn’t unkind and had even seemed like a completely different person (in a very pleasant way).

This all slowly seemed to change after my child was born. She often made the comment “you only know so much about him because you spend the most time with him. WE are his people.” I did kindly ask her what she meant by this and why she said this, but she never really qualified it. I had to explain that as my child’s mother, I know so much about him because we have a very special and unique bond. These types of comments gave way to my sister doing things in public, such as shoving me out of the way when a group of people would walk by and then taking over pushing my son’s pram, whilst making comments such as “He sure is allergic to sleep.” Or “He sure keeps us busy.” Each time I asked her about her behaviour, she acted like I was from mars and she had no idea what I was talking about.

Most recently, now that my son is a toddler, she met up with us at a local playground. My son was playing in the sandbox with another little girl, whilst the mother of the girl and I were having a conversation about parenting. My sister chimes in, while picking my son up, out of the sand and into her lap, and began speaking overtop of me, answering the questions about my son that the mother had asked of me. This made the other mother quite visibly uncomfortable, so she collected her child and left us. I was embarrassed, angry, and even a little weirded out. I simply said to her that when a mother asks a question about MY son, I don’t need her to answer for me. She just sort of scoffed and decided my son was done playing in the sand, so she picked him up, rushed away from me, and attempted to take him to the slide which was beside the sandbox. He was quite unhappy that his aunt was forcing him out of the sand, and he ran back to me, sobbing and yelling “No, no! Mummy!”. I comforted him, let him play in the sand (despite my sisters’ insistence that he needed to play on the slide and not in the sand). I firmly stated that my son will play where he wishes, and me, his mother, will decided when it’s time to leave. After this, I made a point to bring my son home, without his aunt. I am furious and have not had any contact with my sister in 3 weeks. I feel as though it is time for me to cut her off and out of our life, as I am fearful that this controlling behaviour will only escalate as my son gets older.

Am I being too rash, or would any of you do the same? Any insight would be helpful.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Fraaahnces · 25/07/2022 03:23

It's clear that she's fantasising that he is her baby. I would avoid.

Doggydarling · 25/07/2022 03:44

Sounds like your sister is imagining life as a mother with your son as a prop. Don't give her the opportunity, you don't need to fall out, just don't invite her over, make plans to meet or let her know your plans so she can't just show up.

starrynight21 · 25/07/2022 04:01

I wouldn't go as far as going no contact, but I'd simply not arrange to meet her / not tell her what I'm planning on doing. She obviously wants to pretend that your son is "her people" which is crazy. Don't let her do it.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Irridescantshimmmer · 25/07/2022 04:38

Your sister is immature, your little boy is unhappy with the way she is treating him and I don't blame him.

She just has not learnt that your child is a sentient being and not an inanimate object she can use to get attention from others.

I think you are a great mum and your intincts are right.

Penfelyn · 25/07/2022 05:02

Really weird. I wouldn't necessarily go NC just yet but I would only meet her when your son is at nursery ot with his dad. The rest of the time I would be unavailable (but that doesn't preclude messaging if she's able to interact normally through this medium, and assuming you want to).

Or you could go Nc, it depends on how keen you are to maintain a relationship.

Does your sister have fertility issues ? Or maybe she wants a family but is single and doesn't want to do it alone ? Because as pp suggested it sounds like she wants to pretend your son is her son. Very weird and sad.

Mamabearmamadragon · 25/07/2022 13:20

Thank you for sharing your insights everyone. The thought has very often crossed my mind that she wants the outside to believe that my child is hers. I do know she would probably like to have a family of her own but is currently single (as far as I know). There have been numerous occasions where she has overstepped in a big way (but didn’t list them all here), including feeding my son food from HER plate (it was a mush) with HER spoon when he was just 6 months old. I had told her I was uncomfortable with that due to germs and also because she didn’t ask my permission to do so (as she didn’t know his feeding schedule, etc) I asked her to not do that again . Her response was that he “wanted it” and she will not stop responding to his hunger cues. It just always feels that when I put up a boundary she pushes back and makes small digs at my parenting. She drastically changes her behaviour when my husband is around, but he’s often away for business, so it’s almost impossible to have him around every time she wants to visit.

I do feel a little sorry for her which is the reason why I am so torn up about whether or not to go NC. The fact that she changes her behaviour and backs off when my husband is around makes me feel as though she knows exactly what she is doing, but then again, I don’t want to assume and be unfair to someone who might just be suffering from extreme loneliness.

OP posts:
Georgeskitchen · 25/07/2022 13:27

She sounds mentally unwell tbh

FictionalCharacter · 25/07/2022 13:54

There’s something quite badly wrong with her. The “we’re his people” comment is highly abnormal and so is her behaviour. Put a stop to it now before it escalates. Don’t worry about being unfair to her, your child’s welfare comes first and she’s already upset him badly at least once when she pulled him out of the sandpit. The way he ran to you sobbing like that shows that he’s getting bad vibes from her.
You could either go full NC or only see her when DS isn’t there, but if he was mine she’d never be allowed to touch him again.

Ilikecheeseontoast · 25/07/2022 14:04

Is your sister my Mother in law??

mrskatebob · 25/07/2022 14:21

I'd stop seeing her with your child tbh. How do you benefit from this relationship with her?

Mamabearmamadragon · 25/07/2022 16:35

You do have a point. I’m not sure we would have anything to do with one another if I didn’t have a child.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread