Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Yearning for an impossible second

10 replies

solania · 20/10/2021 19:42

How do I manage or deal with this?

DH is older and already has 2 DC. When we married I had no desire to have children - never have. It was about half a year into marriage and I realised I absolutely wanted a child with him, and after discussion he agreed, and we now have a much loved DS who has vastly improved our lives! (Even though they didn’t need improving, but he’s just a wonderful addition)

Because DH feels he’s too old for another, we are sticking at one, and it’s breaking my heart! I can’t work out what it is that makes me want a second. Initially I was anxious that DS would be effectively an only child (because of the age gap) and that he’d be lonely - I’m over that anxiety now and I do know that siblings aren’t the be all and end all.

But now it seems like every friend is onto their second or even third. My antenatal group are almost all pregnant with #2, my good friend has not long given birth and my close colleague is off to have her third in a few weeks.

I don’t know how to handle the emotions. I’m so envious of friends who are able to have 2 or 3, which is one really difficult emotion. I’m absolutely aching to have another baby and also to have another child - I know they’re different feelings, and yes I want the snuggly baby feeling again which is totally unrealistic I’m sure with a toddler! But I also want a sibling for DS and another gorgeous little person to love. I feel like I’m missing out somehow, which also sounds stupid 🤷‍♀️ but having had a pandemic baby, I sort of want to do it again "properly" (which is also stupid because we're still in a pandemic!!)

I’m feeling especially down atm as my AF has just started and it has reminded me of what I will never have. I can’t disentangle the hostile sort of emotions (like envy) from the innate ones (like maternal instinct) and it’s pulling me apart as I can’t talk to DH about it because we’ve been there, talked it through, and I completely understand and respect his opinion and feelings.

Where does this even come from? I didn’t even want a baby until I married him, and now I want another! Is the longing ever going to end? If I were to have a second will I start pining after a third?? It all seems so ridiculous and yet it's eating away at me that DS will never have a sibling and I will never get to cuddle another tiny human I’ve made.

So how do I get myself to understand that DH and DS are enough? Because they are, it's just this stupid longing inside me that is trying to convince me I need more. How can I learn to be satisfied with my lot?

Please be gentle because I know MN can be quite rough and ready, and it’s too emotional for me to face that atm. Practical methods for learning to be happy with what I have would be very welcome! I’ve learned CBT for anxiety so I wonder if I can use something like that to help?

OP posts:
KILNAMATRA · 20/10/2021 21:11

Will you resent DH for his decision in the future? Surely you could explain it to him how badly you would like another ? 💐 I’ve no answers for you.. just I empathise it’s must be painful.. maybe it’s like that for all moms who want another, no 1 no 2 or no 3, the early loss in pregnancy of our much wanted third was very painful.. and also knowing I couldn’t have anymore..

Mc3209 · 20/10/2021 22:04

OP, if you find the answer to that let me know. Sending solidarity and empathy, I am in a similar situation. I wasn't bothered much about having children until I married my DH, I realized I wanted a baby once we were married, we agreed on one (DH would have been perfectly happy childless). We have a gorgeous almost 1 year old boy now, and I'm longing for a second. DH has closed the shop though and doesn't want anymore.
I am just trying to ignore that feeling hoping it will go away.

Stopsnowing · 20/10/2021 22:09

I didn’t realise how much I would want another until after I had my first. It sounds to me like you are putting your Dh feelings before your own. However if you really feel you cannot try for another then I can say that having another is no guarantee that the siblings will be close. Also two children is more than twice the work of one. All the only children I know are well adjusted and importantly their parents have more time for them and each other.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Eastridingclub · 22/11/2021 12:01

I think your DH should recognise that your feelings are there for a reason. Perhaps he needs to have faith that you wouldn't feel this way unless it were a genuine maternal instinct that would be wrong for him to suppress for his own convenience. You probably support him in many ways and live a life centered around the family and community. He should recognise that it would be particularly difficult for you to play a supporting role while yearning for another child.

Whathefisgoingon · 22/11/2021 12:09

I have a 21 month old and it feels like everyone around me that was pregnant at the same time is now pregnant with their second!

I would like another for the same reasons as you do, but DP not so keen.

Honestly though, with the way the world is going I sometimes feel bad that I’ve brought my toddler in to it. I do think of that when I start yearning for another.

Multicolouredsequins · 22/11/2021 12:31

My MIL was desperate for a third, FIL didn't want another. Third child born in any case and much loved, marriage absolutely fine. She now says with a wink "he didn't want one but in the end it wasn't up to him." No doubt I'll get grief for this story, but I expect this happens all the time....

solania · 23/11/2021 21:29

Thank you all for responding. I was feeling particularly down when I posted, away on holiday and period had just started (and there was a slight chance we might have conceived that month, but no!)

It comes and goes. Sometimes I feel bad for DS being an only child (I’m an only child and I know how lonely it can be) and sometimes I’m glad that we can lavish attention on him and on each other, and have down time and money for things. Right now I think I could be happy either way, whether we had another or not. I know DH would be delighted if we had another as deep down he also wants more than one, but he is worried about finances, housing (we don’t own though we do have a deposit stashed away) and other practical things, quite apart from him being an older guy.

I dunno 🤷‍♀️ it all seems overly complicated, practically and emotionally. I don’t know how it will go, or if I’m reconciled to it all yet, but we shall see.

OP posts:
GreyhoundG1rl · 23/11/2021 22:30

Sometimes I feel bad for DS being an only child
Is he an only child, though? How old are his half siblings?

newname445 · 23/11/2021 23:09

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Mrsmch123 · 25/11/2021 22:49

We had fertility treatment so obviously wanted a child. Now that he's here the want for another is imence. It's like now I truly understand the joy that children bring and the thought of just one is heartbreaking. But I'm not sure I can do ivf again. Both mentally and financially. I still cling to the hope that it may just happen as there is still a chance...I mean it's a smallish chance but a chance none the less.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page