Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Will DS pick up German or will he be confused?

6 replies

Hummahummamumma · 15/11/2007 12:41

Apologies in advance - this is long and perhaps not terribly well explained!

We have lived in Germany now for a year and are due to be here for one more (although this may perhaps be extended due to DH's work). Both DH and myself are English (we are learning German but progress is quite slow!). DS is 16 months now, so has lived here since he was 6 months old. We attend a local weekly Krabbelgruppe and after going for many months we are now accepted and are starting to be asked around to play etc! DS also spends a couple of hours a week in a kinderbetreuung at the gym while I get some 'Me' time and try to get fit! My concern is that because DS is only exposed to German when we are out he will not really pick it up and moreover, he will become confused? Is it a problem for him to be left alone with only German speakers - i.e does he feel like an older child or adult would plunged into a room with everyone speaking in a foreign lanugage? Or does he accept it as he really knows no different?

I would obviously love him to learn even a little of the language (I am assuming we will not be here long enough for him to become truly bilingual but who knows what the future holds). My own German is by no means good enough to try to speak with him all the time so we cannot try that approach. I try my best to speak my few words of German to show willing to the people we meet and improve my own ability but am not sure what he must make of that, so find myself saying everything I can say twice to him while we are out - in English and Deutsch! At the end of the day I just want to do what is best for DS in the long term but don't really know what I should be doing for the best!

All advice and opinion gratefully received!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
emkana · 15/11/2007 12:43

Sorry not much time, but I would say you and your dh should speak English and your ds will pick up German from his environment - no need for you to try and introduce German.

castille · 15/11/2007 16:18

What emkana said. Don't try to speak German with him - that really will confuse him. He will accept whatever he is exposed to, and will gradually learn that Mummy and Daddy say water, other people say Wasser, but the meaning is the same.

My DS is the same age as yours and understands lots of English and very little French despite us living in France (DH is French but he's not at home much!). He goes to a local creche occasionally too and the language isn't a problem. Everything is "normal" to a toddler

LIZS · 15/11/2007 16:26

It will be more confusing if you try to speak German with him than if he just associates it with particular circumstances like the Krippe. Some children absorb it easier than others though.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

moondog · 15/11/2007 17:47

Emkana is right.
(I'm a bilingual speech and lang. therapist if it helps to know this)

franke · 15/11/2007 17:56

What everyone else has said. We live in Germany and speak only English at home, and for the kids, everything outside the home is German. My two didn't really get to grips with German until they were immersed in it i.e. when they started Kindergarten.

Hummahummamumma · 15/11/2007 18:43

That is great everyone - thanks for all the sound advice!

I hadn't really thought about it at all up until now as I had just assumed he would perhaps pick up the odd word (he already waves when he hears Tschuss, for example)and becoming fluent would just be a natural plus side for him if we were to stay long term as he went through the school system.

However, because I have now started to leave him for a while in the fitness centre kinderbetreuung it has made me think twice because the woman running it asked me if DS spoke German or English (er....well, he mainly speaks baby at the moment actually!) as she was concerned that he would not understand her. That got me thinking as I would obviously hate for him to feel strange because he doesn't know what is being said to him when he is alone there. Up until that point I had only viewed his 'exposure' to another language as positive. But, as you say, everything is normal to toddlers! Thanks again

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page