Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

1 or 2 DC?

22 replies

Dasher789 · 04/04/2021 12:08

I am in my early 30s and DH and I are ready to start TTC. We hope to have our first child between early 2022 - early summer 2022.

We are trying to think beyond that and plan how many children we would like generally because of my age but also - both our families are a bit dysfunctional.

I have 2 siblings. There is nearly 3 years between S2 and me. Between S2 and 3 there is 17 months. Growing up S2 and 3 got on very well. I was kind of excluded from their strong friendship but still got on well with S3. S2 and I have always fought a lot. Sadly this has continued into adulthood. We got through phases of getting on v well then phases of falling out and almost NC periods which have lasted up to 2 years. Currently no issues and speak every few months on phone (S2 lives 400 miles away due to work). S3 moved to other side of the world around 7 years ago. Has visited home 2x since moving due to cost and lack of interest. S3 previously suffered depression and made some very odd life choices which strained relationship with S2 and I. Moving so far away meant this has never been resolved and S2 and I have v limited contact with S3 (text at xmas and bdays).

DH has 1 sibling. 3 year age gap. Got on growing up but limited contact since moving out in early 20's and doing their own thing. Live 45 mins apart. Visit every 3-4 months pre covid.

Both sets of parents also have contact issues with siblings for a variety of reasons mainly due to all living very far apart but relationships do have issues too.

In an ideal world DH and I would have 2 children with shared interests who get on. Due to my age and the idea of pregnancy worrying me, I would hope to TTC DC2 6 months after DC1 to get that part of my life out of the way.

However, we are aware the ideal world may not work out and are torn between having 1 DC and being able to offer that DC a good life in terms of clubs and experiences with our finances or having 2 DC and life being a bit more of a financial struggle but offering a playmate who may or may not get on.

One of each of our parents were only children. Both say they pinned for a sibling and in later life, the burden of caring for parents was tough. That being said, both were sent to boarding school from a young age and struggled with that and both were divorced at point of caring of elderly parents so did not have a partner to assist. Family with siblings still found care fell to one person but had a partner to help.

I think the question I am really asking is, for those with 1 DC, how hard is it to keep DC entertained? Do you think they are missing out not having siblings? For anyone with 2x DC. Do you ever feel it would have been easier with 1 or would you still have 2 every time?

Thanks for reading this appreciate it is v long! Any thoughts are greatly appreciated. I fully appreciate many factors are beyond our control but even trying is a huge decision.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
RedGoldAndGreene · 04/04/2021 13:22

Do you have extended family and close friends living nearby with similar aged kids? If you have one child and can offer them playmates in that way then that's obviously great.

I think that having a second child for a playmate is a lot of pressure on the kids. I am a mum of 3 and I think that sibling relationships go through different phases. Dc1 did not really bother with dc3 for most of his teens but they are really close now and he offers advice on topics like fashion and girls.

Dasher789 · 04/04/2021 17:50

We have friends close by with children who are babies and toddlers now. We are likely to have to move with DH work at some point in next few years but I am sure we would make new friends through groups and clubs. I think you are right and we can't assume two children would be best friends 24/7. Perhaps we would be better with one.

OP posts:
RedGoldAndGreene · 04/04/2021 17:57

If the best friends aspect is important then you could end up being disappointed if they are different sexes, have different interests or different personalities. In some ways you'd think that 2 sport mad boys would be good but they might like different sports, spend lots of time arguing about their favourite teams or who scores the beat goals or resent having to watch their sibling play unlike a child who might be content playing with other kids along the sidelines. Sometimes opposites get along - for example a quiet child might be annoyed less by their chatty sibling compared to 2 chatty siblings. I personally think that there's a massive amount of luck involved.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

ivfbeenbusy · 04/04/2021 18:07

I personally would never have an only child and spent every last penny on IVF to ensure that didn't happen. Appreciate that you can't predict sibling relationships as they get older but My DH is an only child and....quite frankly it shows!

by the way whilst I love the planning of exactly when you want a child but best will in the world conception very rarely works out that way

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 04/04/2021 19:38

I always thought id have 2 until I had a baby. Now im convinced im only having 1. Im not sure you can plan much when it comes to babies/conception tbh.

user1493413286 · 04/04/2021 19:41

I have two young DC (4 and 1) and it is hard; sometimes it’s harder than I imagined but I always wanted two as I wanted my DC to have a sibling they grew up with and to have as a support as an adult. I am very close with my sister which I hope my DC will have and one of my motivating factors was that my mum is an only child and when her parents both died relatively young she was very much left on her own.
I can also see/hope that in the future having 2 will be easier than 1 as they will play together whereas with one you have to structure things around them a lot

BillyIsMyBunny · 04/04/2021 19:48

At this point it’s all hypothetical. You haven’t even started ttc baby #1 yet so I wouldn’t overthink every hypothetical situation in deciding whether you would want a second child. The decision might be taken out of your hands (Eg: you could conceive twins first time or find you’re not able to conceive naturally) or you might find that after having DC1 the decision suddenly seems very clear one way or another. Of course it’s reasonable to have the discussion with your DP about how many children you both think you might want at this stage but it’s way too early to make any actual decisions regardless of what anyone on here says about life with 1 or 2 children.

Ihaveoflate · 04/04/2021 19:52

I really don't think you can know the answer to this before you've had one. You're experience of TTC, birth and looking after a baby will partially determine how keen/able you are to have another.

I have one child and although she's still young, I have no regrets. She goes to nursery and is incredibly social, she plays well independently and has cousins nearby. Even if none of that were the case, I still wouldn't have another child. Sibling relationships in my family are fraught and I just wanted to avoid all that with my own child. I would be a terrible parent to siblings, but I think I'm doing a decent job do far with just the one.

Odile13 · 04/04/2021 19:59

My answer might not be very helpful but I really think you just have to start with ttc #1 and see how it goes. There are so many variables that wracking your brains to plan something is pointless and not very useful. Once you’ve had a baby you can see how you feel based on what your pregnancy is like, what giving birth was like for you, how difficult you find looking after a baby etc.

Dasher789 · 04/04/2021 21:45

Thanks everyone. Really appreciate the feedback. Fully aware we may find we cannot have any DC or that we have triplets the first time (heaven forbid Grin). Lots of food for thought and fingers crossed for a happy and healthy first Smile

OP posts:
Chelyanne · 04/04/2021 23:32

You're overthinking it. Get having one done then see how you feel about another or more. You have no idea how long you'll be ttc or if you'll have issues with pregnancy.
You shouldn't let your experience with siblings sway you on how many dc you would like.

DramaAlpaca · 04/04/2021 23:35

I totally agree with what @Chelyanne just said. Have one, then see how you feel. No need to overthink it.

SparrowNest · 05/04/2021 10:43

Be aware that if you are planning to breastfeed, conceiving 6 months after your first is born might be out of the question. I’m currently pregnant with my second and still nursing my first (so can’t answer your question about what’s ideal, though we strongly feel two is better for our family) but I didn’t get my periods back until she was 15 months.

Dasher789 · 05/04/2021 13:52

@sparrownest thanks. I didn't realise that was a thing! I have so much to learn!!! Can I ask why it was important for you to have two?

OP posts:
77777g · 05/04/2021 14:47

I always thought id have 2 until I had a baby. Now im convinced im only having 1.

Me too.

SparrowNest · 05/04/2021 21:05

@Dasher789

I think we both knew we wanted multiple children from the start tbh, but seeing her interact with her cousin and kids at the playground has only confirmed that we think it would be great for her to have a sibling.

Honestly though, it just feels right to me for us to have more than one. As much as my first’s sociability has felt like confirmation it’s the right choice, I can’t imagine feeling different whatever her personality was.

Dasher789 · 06/04/2021 23:04

Thanks everyone. Hopefully exciting times soon...

OP posts:
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/04/2021 05:08

I would never (by choice) have just 1- everyone I know in real life is close to their sibling/s (only on mn is this not the case). It’s priceless to see your first born with your second- also, unless you are lucky enough to have your friends have kids at the exact same time or cousins etc- then they will always have someone around to interact with their own age. Play dates are the stuff of pure hell so if I had to fill my days with those to entertain DD1 then I’d hate it.
I couldn’t however have had 2 under 2- planning everything in such minute detail OP can be worrying- babies/ toddlers are a shock to the system- a 3 year age gap is working out well for us (touch wood). So I would say when you have your first don’t assume you only want 1 if you find the first months/ year hard.

daffodilsandprimroses · 07/04/2021 05:13

It sounds very ... prescribed. Shared interests and so on is more to do with personalities than age gaps.

To be totally honest I think you’d be missing out in your first child’s babyhood by getting pregnant so soon afterwards. It’s hard work sure but it also is enjoyable.

riddles26 · 07/04/2021 10:03

Completely agree with @OnlyFoolsnMothers. We and all our friends are extremely close to siblings - we all have different types of sibling relationships, mine is more like a very close friend who I would go to for everything. Our DC (although still preschool and toddlers) adore each other and consider each other as siblings rather than cousins. DH and his will undoubtedly look out for each other but it is a very different close. They still can't imagine life without each other

Having 1 was never really an option (unless it happened due to fertility issues). Saying that, we struggled to TTC our first so the 'ideal age gap' decision was taken away from us because we feared we would have similar struggles when trying for our second. We ended up with 2 under 2 and the first year is tough, I don't know how people manage it without family help. But the love they have for each other (despite the bickering and fighting) is indescribable. They look out for each other no matter what, especially in my absence

Go for the first then see how you feel. Agree with not having any preconceived ideas of how the sibling relationship will be.

Dasher789 · 10/04/2021 14:28

Thanks. I'm just a bit worried about leaving too big a gap and struggling tc the 2nd if I left it too long. Two close friends are 36 and really struggling ttc dc2. Not sure if its 100% their age as I know many successfully conceive later but it seems to be a factor for them. As you say, we can't make any firm decisions until we see how it goes but thanks for the input. I definitely think that even one dc will be a shock to the system for us both Grin

OP posts:
MrsTiffin · 10/04/2021 20:18

We had 2 under 2. I won't lie at times at the start it was really tough but 6 months in its definitely a lot more manageable now. It completely depends on your circumstances, we ideally would like one or two more for a couple of reasons.

DP and I both have 1 sister each, I have a small age gap, his is much bigger. Neither of us particularly get on with them, very limited contact as we started having a family. As a child though I had a great relationship and loved having a sister to play with. As I've got older I always wished I had another sibling and maybe I would have got on better with them as an adult! DP feels the same way but I think the big age gap doesn't help.

Secondly given our relationships being crap with siblings, neither of them are looking likely to start a family so we won't have any cousins for our DC. It's such a shame I grew up with a lot of cousins so for us it's important to have a few siblings to make up for it!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page