Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Sad because son prefers daddy

19 replies

Enidcat5 · 13/10/2019 05:11

I have a 4 year old DS who means the world to me. He was a very much longed for child and when he finally arrived I did all care for first 3 years. My dh worked nights and I breastfed so I did all bedtimes, feeds etc. Plus I was the one who took him to all doctor appointments, stayed off work when he was ill, etc. We were extremely close and I was always the one he wanted first. I carried him in sling for 3 years and he always felt like an extension of me, sitting on my knee to read books and cuddling in front of the TV. We had no family support and he went everywhere with me. My dh was a good dad but wasn't there as much due to work and childcare just fell naturally on my shoulders which I didn't mind.

Dh has always been 'fun daddy'. He's naturally better than I am at rough and tumble play, and would do all the physical carrying on shoulders etc if we went to the park. In the house he would be better than me at building forts or train sets. I never minded because I was happy with my place in my son's life as primary carer.

Somewhere around my son's 3rd birthday it switched. Suddenly my son wanted daddy to do things for him and it was daddy he wanted at night if he woke, or if he hurt himself. At the time I didn't think anything of it, I just felt perhaps this is normal development and a phase like everything else. Also I'd gone through miscarriage and was tired and quite anxious so sometimes it was beneficial to have someone else take the responsibility. But over a year on I'm still not the one he wants first, I'm often told that 'I love daddy not you'. It does not help that I recently had a baby after a very difficult few years of recurrent miscarriage and then pregnancy. Naturally in my pregnancy I found it tough towards the end to get down on floor with my son and play, or to carry him as much. Now that my baby is here I often have to leave DS playing to feed or to get baby to sleep. So I'm worried this is making it worse as I can't be there for him as readily as I was before.

Has anyone been through this please and is it a phase? I'm so desperately sad. My son cries out for daddy now at night and gets upset if I go instead, where I used to be the one to cuddle him and make the fear or pain go away. I miss my son and I miss the bond we had. I poured my heart and soul into him and I can't bear to think that that's it and he will never want me first ever again. My husband is a good dad and now is home more often due to job change, however I get very resentful of his status as the 'fun one' as I'm on maternity and here all the time, doing all the less fun bits. He is a novelty who arrives home and plays. I'm also the more firm parent as my husband is not great at maintaining boundaries and dealing with bad behaviour.

I've been working hard at making time to play with my son and handing baby yo my husband when he is home so that I can be free to give my son attention, but he is still fixated on daddy.

Will my son ever want me again? I can't bear to think that that's it.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Rainbowqueeen · 13/10/2019 05:20

Yes he absolutely will
My DH was always the fun one. All my kids prefer me because I am the consistent one, the one who does the appointments, the one who is there for them and who knows the details of their lives.
That stuff is so important. You sound like a lovely mum who values your DS. He sounds like he had a lovely bond with both of you.

Enidcat5 · 13/10/2019 05:29

Not sure if it's the hormones but your response made me cry with relief, thank you. I miss him. I have my days when I'm tired or impatient and don't feel like I'm being a particularly good mum, but I try really hard. I can't help but feel resentful of my husband who, whilst lovely, never did/does the dull stuff and didn't do the really gruelling newborn and first few years stages.

OP posts:
FoodWoes · 13/10/2019 05:35

He's a toddler. He's fickle and oblivious.

It's all very dramatic. Of course he loves you, he's just going through a Daddy phase.
They take it in turns. All very normal

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

whiteroseredrose · 13/10/2019 07:03

As PP says children go through phases. Like you I was the main carer when DC were young. I was more intuitive and 'got' what they needed. I used to have to 'big up' daddy as I was always first choice and it was sad for him.

As they grew older and they could talk it became more equal which is as it should be.

He still loves you and needs you just as much.

Enidcat5 · 13/10/2019 07:13

@FoodWoes it's not really dramatic when as I say I've patiently waited this out for over a year expecting it to be a phase but nothing has improved. I also have a new baby as I say and therefore am adjusting to not being able to focus so much on DS as I could. Hormones are probably not helping.

I haven't posted before about this as I understand children have phases but this has been a really long one and I wondered if anyone else had had this happen.

I know he loves me, he's looking for a reaction when he tells me he doesn't and I'm very careful not to give him one. I just ignore it. But I do miss being the one he wants when he hurts himself or has a bad dream.

OP posts:
Enidcat5 · 13/10/2019 07:15

@whiteroseredrose yes same here, I used to have to encourage my son to go to my husband and I'd deliberately leave them together to give them time to bond. My husband and son have a lovely relationship and I wouldn't want to change that.

OP posts:
Enidcat5 · 13/10/2019 07:18

I'm also extremely tired as my baby has a cold and hasn't been able to sleep on her back so I've been awake all night holding her. Tiredness plus hormones mean I'm probably feeling more fed up about it than normal.

OP posts:
eyeoresancerre · 13/10/2019 07:19

I think that boys recognise the more boisterous/fun/laughing with daddy sort of love more easily than the constant, quieter and gentler love that you are giving. That's a subtler love that my son doesn't really pick up on either.
I've learnt to be ok with it over the years as I know deep down that the love I give him in terms of stability, nourishment, care etc is just as important as the fun love. My son doesn't recognise it yet but I know this and I feel content just recognising the importance of what I give him. I think how great that he gets to experience both types of care/love.
I think I read the book "Raising Boys" which said this is sort of normal development. However I have enormous empathy for you - it does tug a your heartstrings when they're little.

Judgybitch · 13/10/2019 07:23

My toddler already prefers daddy and i haven't even had his sister yet :).

Don't forget that because he gets 1 on1 time with you but not daddy. Your oh will get to do all the fun stuff and not the boring stuff from your sons perspective. Having mine all day means that I need to prioritise other things occasionally so he will only have my split attention sometimes. When daddy is home however. I still do the same stuff which allows daddys time to be 100% fun even if he sees him less overall.

Also your presence is a constant whereas daddys is 'special' as he isn't around as much. I honestly try to look at it as a boon. When our second arrives they can toddle off together and I can have undivided time with the new baby who needs me more.

whiteroseredrose · 13/10/2019 07:27

Honestly honestly @enidcat5 it really does work out. It sounds like you're both great parents and you are both really important to your little boy.

He's also readjusting to your new baby. New baby needs you more than daddy at the moment so the seesaw will swing in daddy's favour for a while.

It sounds like you're still giving him plenty of time and attention so it will even up again.

StarlingsInSummer · 13/10/2019 07:32

He absolutely will! They can play us like a violin, even at this age. And if Daddy has been responding to more of his needs because you have been heavily pregnant and have a newborn, it’s natural that he’ll want him. I have a nearly five year old who goes through phases of wanting me more or his father more, and if he’s hurt himself, consistently cries for whichever one of us ISN’T available. And often if we’re both around, he says he wants Nanny and Grandad!

Congratulations on your baby as well.

Enidcat5 · 13/10/2019 07:36

Thank you for replies, it makes sense reading what you've said about me being the constant in his life and providing stability. Definitely true. Also about me having to do jobs as SAHP just now whereas when dh comes home he's 100% fun daddy.

You're right also about focusing on the baby and actually I am really enjoying getting the time to sit and cuddle her while she sleeps, whilst dh takes our son out or plays. When she's older I can hand her over more easily to free me up to play with DS.

Thanks for the replies, I will keep doing what I'm doing and be here when he needs me.

OP posts:
Enidcat5 · 13/10/2019 07:39

@StarlingsinSummer thank you, she's pretty cute :) DS is besotted with her which is lovely.

OP posts:
doxxed · 13/10/2019 07:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for privacy reasons.

midsummabreak · 13/10/2019 07:47

Yes i had this, with DD. I found it helped to take the focus off our bond and make her feel special within the family. Tends to happen when you are vulnerable and/or overwhelmed.

If you are doing most of the hard work at home as well as with baby, can you get support? Can you leave baby with Dh and get out for a walk or other activity regularly ?

Do you have a photo of Ds with/holding baby saying "Brother " on the frame that he can keep in his room ? His role within the family has changed, and he needs to feel special as a brother who helps with the busy time of caring for baby. Praise him for playing an important helper role bringing a nappy or item when asked , or soothing baby, for example singing or chanting nursery ryhmes to baby, whatever works.

Enidcat5 · 13/10/2019 07:53

@doxxed I actually have Fridays with him as he's not at nursery so I'm going to start planning a fun thing every week. I'll try delegating a bit more. Dh does do a lot at weekends around the house but I should make him do more if the dull stuff as he tends to pick the things he likes to do.

OP posts:
Enidcat5 · 13/10/2019 07:58

@midsummabreak we do a lot to make sure DS feels included. He loves helping with baby and their bond is lovely, she smiles instantly when she sees him. I'm trying to make a point of putting DD down and saying 'you need to go into your bouncer whilst I play with ds' or similar, plus I give him lots of praise if he helps or us quiet to let her sleep.

We have my mum nearby now and she's brilliant as support. I can't leave DD long enough yet to do any of my hobbies because she's bf and still feeding a lot. But I'm getting a running buggy to start running again from 6 months as I used to love that before I was pregnant.

OP posts:
midsummabreak · 13/10/2019 11:23

Sorry EnidCat5 , much of what im saying you have all sorted so it is irrelevant to your situation You sound a thoughtful kind Mum and as others say, this too shall pass. Flowers

Enidcat5 · 31/01/2020 22:06

In case anyone ever comes across this thread in the future I thought I'd update, 3 months on from writing. I have made loads of effort to spend time with my son. We do Friday funday when he doesn't go to nursery and I have both kids all day, we choose a different activity every week whether it's a play date or museum trip or just the park. He gets excited about Friday funday every week and it's our time together.

Baby is easier than she was now that she's 8 months so I can now get her down to sleep at bedtime whilst my husband starts bedtime with my son, then I go upstairs and finish his stories, songs and cuddle him.

It's made such a huge difference to our relationship. He now calls for me more and the constant 'I want daddy' whinge has gone. My dh has been better with boundaries and discipline so there is no longer a clear good cop bad cop game going on with my son choosing the parent he knows won't tell him off.

Tonight my son hurt himself and called for me which is amazing. He also asked could I read his bedtime story, not daddy.

Slowly but surely it's getting better. Thank you everyone

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page