Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

MIL problems - need reassurance

12 replies

Melyn · 12/06/2019 20:48

Hey, bit of a long post, so I need a bit of reassurance that I'm not alone.. Does anyone else have unwanted opinions constantly about how to raise their child from their family? I have a 2 year old son, and for the 2 years he's been on the planet my MIL makes sly comments about the way I parent my child. I wanted my son to drink water with meals when he was first being weaned, we tried for months to get him to drink water to mo avail so we added the smallest amount of juice to his water and scaled it back until there was nothing but water, my MIL told us to just give up and give him juice and that our efforts were pointless, she just gave her kids juice and that it didn't matter if he didn't drink water. He now loves water and asks for water over juice or milk. When my son turned 18 months old my son picked up slapping as a bad habit, it was usually centred on me and his Dad and the only way I could somewhat control this behaviour is using timeouts. I know some people hate the idea of putting their child in a timeout but he was hitting multiple times in an hour every day and I got to my wits end with it and it's the only thing that worked after trying everything.. When my MIL found out that that was how we were dealing with the behaviour every time we went over there for the 4 weeks following all I got was "I never did timeouts, it's cruel, look how sad he looks, I think it's wrong" etc. Well she understood a bit what it was like for me when she babysat for the day and he had a meltdown and was hitting her repeatedly and all of the techniques she told me to use on my son instead of timeout, surprise surprise, they didn't work! She actually had to resort to putting him into timeout, and the behaviour stopped and he didn't hit again while he was there. He has thankfully outgrown that behaviour. Then he moved onto food fussiness with vegetables which happens with all kids at some point. My approach was to continue to put the vegetables on the plate, offer them to him, if he refuses I tell him there's nothing else to eat and if he decides to continue with not eating he'll go without. My parents raised me and my brother this way and we like most things and we'll both try anything once. Whereas my partner (when I first met him, he's since been converted to trying more food by me refusing to cook him anything else if he turned his food away) and his sister are so picky, my partner's sister will only each starch and meat, no vegetables or anything. So I hardly think my MIL should have an opinion on how I feed my son given that both of her kids (my partner was 26 when I met him) wouldn't eat any vegetables. But she does, she says "just let him eat what he wants, why are you forcing vegetables on him, I never did that with my kids" but she never says it nicely it's always as a sly remark and I know she feeds my son rubbish without me knowing which makes him constipated and ratty. He's now got out of this weird food habit and has eaten everything on his plate without hesitation for the last 3 weeks, all because we were persistent with our chosen technique. And it might not be something that every parent wants to do, and it was a daily struggle but we've come out the other end with a little boy who will eat all of his food, which to me is a huge win.. These are 2 examples of lots of at least 40 different times where she has questionned my parenting in front of my son I'm tired of fighting all the time to "prove" myself, which is what I feel like I have to do all the time. Anyone else have something similar? I just can't seem to do right by her when it comes to my son, and I know it doesn't matter because he is my son and her opinion doesn't matter but we're over their house a lot and it's frustrating listening to the same old bit about how I should be doing it her way.. Ugh. Sorry for the long post, it's been a really long week and I needed to vent

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Aw12345 · 12/06/2019 21:35

Oh my gosh the sly comments from the mil drive me absolutely mad.

Different generation, different child, different parent so yes you do things differently to her... And that's ok!!!

Totally know how you feel. Grrr!!

Melyn · 12/06/2019 22:34

It drives me nuts honestly, I can't stand it sometimes.. she thinks she knows best but every child is different and that's what she fails to see when it comes to my son is that he is different to her 2 children.

OP posts:
hormonesorDHbeingadick · 13/06/2019 08:08

I would go for the broken record approach of picking one or two phrases and keeping repeating them everything she criticises you. Something like ‘You have had your turn to decide how best to parent and now it’s our turn to do what we think is best for our child’. Just keeping saying the same thing everything time she criticises you and hopefully it will sink in.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Walkamileinmyshoesbeforeujudge · 13/06/2019 08:16

No law says you have to visit....

S1naidSucks · 13/06/2019 08:18

Actually, I think Aw12345s comment, Different generation, different child, different parent, would be the perfect response to her nonsense. You can always do it with a great big smile. So she can’t complain that you’re picking on her. WinkGrin

FionasWineShow · 13/06/2019 08:25

100 to 1 says she would've loathed this from her own MIL. Wink

Where's your Mum - is she on the scene?

Makes me thankful for my own lovely MIL who wouldn't dream of questioning us, and instead shows a real interest in our way of doing things.

Mylittlepony374 · 13/06/2019 08:39

No MIL here but sister in law who behaved like that....wearing my baby in a sling was spoiling her, not giving her chocolate at 6 months was cruel, etc etc. I dealt with it for about 18months. I tried all the repetitive 'you do things your way, I'll do them mine', made no difference.
We don't see her much now.

Tonightstheteriyakichicken · 13/06/2019 08:54

we're over their house a lot
That's your mistake right there, (though she probably doesn't hold back when she's round your place).
She has an opinion and isn't afraid to share it. You don't have to pay attention to it. Just rise above it! Water off a duck's back.

Out of interest how well did the two of you get along before pregnancy?

Melyn · 13/06/2019 10:04

It's my partner who wants to go over a lot, I don't want to limit how much my partner's sister and step-dad see my son though as he loves them both a lot, he always asks about his Grandad and NeeNee (his name for my partner's sister) I moved away from my family from Wales to England and we're about a 3 hour drive away so we only see them once a month. We got on okay, there were a few moments where it was like "wtf?" but I was living with them at the time and I'm not confrontational at all. For example, she got in an arguement with her SIL and she was pregnant at the time, she was reading the messages to me and she started one message and quickly skipped to the next one but I caught it with my eye "I don't have to deal with your pregnant hormones bt I deal with enough of that at home" (meaning me) when I haven't done anything, I only lived there for 5 months before we moved out. Another time she announced that we were having twins and their gender on Facebook before we told my side of the family, and she made a comment when I said I wanted to rest in hospital meaning no visitors she said "I'm not there to see you I'm there to see the babies". (I was expecting twins but the eldest was stillborn), not just that but she got us a scrabble frame as a gift for my first Mother's Day which said Family, my name, my partner's name and my youngest son's name but left off my eldest son, it's poisoned that day for me, I cried after she left and my partner had to go over and say that it upset me and it instead of offering to fix it or that she should have added his name she just blamed my partner and said "You never answer your phone, how am I meant to know" etc.. All she had to do was ask and she didn't.. And she moaned about her Mother's Day card that it didn't say Nanna on it because my partner couldn't find one with it on.. I still carry a lot of resentment for those nemories in particular, I haven't mentioned it to her or brought it up because she's impossible to talk to and I'm not confrontational at all.

OP posts:
Walkamileinmyshoesbeforeujudge · 13/06/2019 10:31

If you are comfortable doing so, send dp over without you sometimes. Best chapter with ils was when I stopped visiting!
Like a huge weight had been lifted.

Tonightstheteriyakichicken · 13/06/2019 11:18

I'm glad you do get on with your partner's stepdad and sister.

I'll make a prediction here and say as soon as her daughter gets pregnant, she won't have time to nag you, she'll be dominating aunty NeeNee.

When you were living under her roof it made sense to bite your tongue but now you're not you can make the occasional retort without every visit turning into a battle. But as walkamile says, sometimes you can find something 'important' to do that keeps you at home when he takes DS round.

Melyn · 13/06/2019 11:45

That won't be for a long time! She's only 12 now, there's a huge age gap of 16 years between my partner and his sister. I love his sister to bits though, I go over there to see her really and we play board games and we chat about mortgages when I'm there lol. Well me and MIL did get into a bit of an arguement recently when she commented about my son's soft poo and blamed it on the ice cream he had (it was actually a soft poo because we've all had a bug) but according to her it was definitely because of the ice cream, so I turned from the table where me, dh extended family and SIL were playing cluedo and say "actually ds is okay with ice cream he's just not been well" and she went quiet for a bit then said "You're so funny Melyn" to which I replied "Why? What do you mean?" Then she went on a long rant about how she's had 2 kids and she knows a thing about kids (bare in mind this is infront of dh, SIL, dh's 2 Aunties and infront of my son), it took me by surprise and she honestly talks to me like a child a lot.. she's worse when there's company around.. I simply replied "All children are different, no 2 kids are the same just because dh and SIL had issues with ice cream doesn't mean ds does" I won the game of cluedo and asked dh to take me home. She speaks to me so rudely sometimes and I guarantee if her MIL spoke to her the same way she spoke to me she'd be up in arms.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page