"just noticed this thread and wanted to ask you about what your DCs do during English lessons. I assume they still have to take part, even though their English is probably better than the teachers. Do they get bored?
Our DD will start school next year and here in NRW there has been talk about English lessons starting in 1. Klasse."
MacMama if you have those Europa-schools near you, I would suggest trying one of those, get in early and have her apply for the English stream then you avoid the problem. They will test her to judge whether they think English is really her stronger language. Those schools teach maths and German in German, everything else initially in English for the English speakers with an English native speaker.
Otherwise I would look for a school which has French as first foreign language.
My dd just did year 1 so no English thank goodness but I was told they could not make any kind of exception. So from year 3 that would mean participating in the beginners English class. I was told she might like having a subject she finds easy.
She is very unhappy about the way the school teaches English pronunciation (songs and the odd thing which crops up) which she says is totally wrong, i.e. not just not British but not any recognisable native pronunciation. The vowels are a bit odd and the stress is wrong. I wondered about this a lot. Why is it being taught this way?
No way is she going in English classes year 3 at a German school. I think it's a waste of time for English native speakers, of course they'll be bored, they may have to play teachers' helper or they may just have to keep quiet. It will be irritating too that they have to say everything incorrectly in lessons, unnatural IYSWIM. The idea is I think to make the pronunciation a bit easier for young German learners. Perhaps it is refined a bit in secondary school to closer approximate correct pronunciation, I don't know.
Just imagine your own foreign language lessons in Scotland. Could you imagine how a fluent native speaker of French would feel going through a year of those French courses (if you did school French)?
I would investigate the possibilities of avoiding the situation if you can.