Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

DD prefers boys' clothes

22 replies

Coffeeessential · 24/01/2014 09:38

Hi everyone,
I would be grateful for any advice/support people have on my thread, if possible...

Basically, our only daughter is nine and a half, and is what you would class as a 'tomboy' - her best friend is a boy the same age, and she likes nothing better than getting filthy (she has recently joined the school football team so I am waiting for even MORE mud....) She loves climbing, scootering and being active, although she hates discos and anything to do with pop music. She likes her hair in a short bob, although she would happily leave the house in the morning without even putting a brush through it.

As she is getting older and more conscious of her likes and dislikes, she has got more 'boyish' in her choice of clothes (much to my mother's horror.) She would rather do two hours of fractions than wear skirts or dresses, and now is happy in jeans or jogging bottoms. In the last year or so, she has started preferring clothes in the boys' section of clothes shops, and this is where my husband and I think we are doing the right thing but my mum does not agree - If she prefers an item in a 'boys' colour or style and would be more comfortable in that than something more girly, we think it's okay. My mum seems to think that by not sticking to 'girls' clothes' we are going to confuse or disturb her in some way. (My brother is gay, and my cousin is transgender and currently undergoing treatment to change from female to male, so I think that these things are on her mind somewhere too.) She also worries about DD being teased for being different, and although this DOES happen sometimes, she is still happier feeling comfortable in her own skin and being teased occasionally than she would be wearing 'girly' clothes and not feeling comfortable.
She does often look very androgenous - her class had a supply teacher this week who mistook her for a boy, and the same has happened before, but DD just thinks it's funny.

I'll be honest - I often see pretty clothes and think how lovely DD would look in them, but I would never dream of forcing her to wear something which made her uncomfortable. DH and I just want her to be herself, and if that means dressing like a boy, surely that's okay? My mum, as I said, thinks differently - she doesn't say much but I can often feel an air of disapproval.

I was just wondering whether anyone else had gone, or is going, through anything similar with their daughter and whether people think we are doing things 'right.'
I never want my daughter to turn round when she is older and tell us that we stopped her from being herself, and I never want to feel that she has to conform just to please other people. My mother doesn't seem to understand this and although I shouldn't let it bother me, it does.

Thankyou for reading!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Rockchick1984 · 24/01/2014 09:52

I was similar at her age - by 16 I was a typical Barbie-doll type with bleached (long!) hair and lots of pink! My parents never made a big deal out of what I was wearing, or my insistence regarding having short hair, so when I decided that I wanted to grow my hair it wasn't treated as a big deal. Similarly when I decided going up to high school that, actually, I wanted a skirt rather than trousers, my mum just said "whatever you want" and I just gradually outgrew the tomboy phase.

AbouttoCrack · 24/01/2014 09:53

She sounds fab. Leave her too it!!!!

paneer · 24/01/2014 09:57

Your DD sounds wonderful. So confident, I love her don't care attitude, and well done for supporting her!

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Fifyfomum · 24/01/2014 09:59

I think generally boys clothes are more comfortable.

PatriciaHolm · 24/01/2014 10:02

Tell your mother it's nothing to do with her! Grin

I was just like this, in fact my mum used to get told she had two lovely sons quite a lot Wink I flipped at about 16-18 and decided to grow my hair, wear more dresses etc. TBH I will never be a girly girl, and I had a small amount of teasing as a young teen but nothing major and everyone gets teased about something at some point. She's happy, let her get on with it and make her own decisions.

Fayrazzled · 24/01/2014 10:03

My daughter is the same, although she is only 6. She started expressing a preference regarding her clothes before she was two. I can distinctly remember her crying and trying to get out of a lovely Boden pinafore dress I had bought her when she was about 20 months. She wears trousers for school as part of her uniform and joggers for preference at home because they are comfy. She dislikes dresses (can't remember the last time she wore one) skirts and leggings. She will wear trousers and jeans as long as they are comfy and not too skinny cut. She would choose boys clothes too and dislikes anything sparkly or that she perceives to be girly.

My H and I have just let her get on with it. I have had a few snidy comments over the years along the lines of "I wouldn't let my child dictate to me" but honestly, what is the alternative- a child who is distressed and uncomfortable in her clothes, why would you want that? My MiL seemed to find it difficult at first (she longed for a granddaughter to buy for after only having sons herself) but even she has accepted it. There are times I'd love to see my daughter in a nice dress or skirt that I like but she's her own person. I wouldn't take too kindly to someone dictating to me what I could and couldn't wear! I think part of being a parent is accepting your child are their own person and you don't get to mould every aspect of them; your child is to support the person they are as best you can.

HavantGuard · 24/01/2014 10:03

Ask her if she dressed your brother in girl's clothes or if your cousin was dressed in boys clothes. I'm guessing not.

Fayrazzled · 24/01/2014 10:04

your job, not child.

Theoldhag · 24/01/2014 10:07

I am of the mind that a child should be free to express themselves as they see fit (as long as the clothing is not child sexualising styles eg padded bra for children under teen years or things for 10 year olds).

My dd is 11 (5ft and 4in bean-pole) and I cut her hair into a style that she likes, think floppy fringe public school boy look. She wears boys clothes (even boxer short pants), new rock biker boots and 'gothic' shirts. Her choice! I have to say I do not worry about her as much as I would if she was outside wearing short skirts and crop tops! She does look like a boy. She is very secure in her gender (as a fiesty feminist girl) and her identity, just wants to wear what she likes, I did have a private cry though when about 4 years ago she asked me to cut her beautiful waist length hair off (I have kept her plait along with her baby teeth).

UriGeller · 24/01/2014 10:10

Your daughter sounds great! There are plenty of little girls that age trying to keep up with being liked, troubled by self-esteem, worrying about their weight or appearance and unhappy.

She sounds like she is having an amazing trouble free happy childhood.

Tell your mum "she is what she is" nothing can "turn her" into anything she doesn't want to be.

pist · 24/01/2014 10:19

That description could have been my dd at the same age. She is now 13
and wears some gorgeous dresses and even make up some times. She still lives a large part of her life in trackies as she is very sporty (still plays traditional 'boys' sports) -but she is into her fashion and spends ages doing her hair.

I'd leave your dd to get on with it, except for instance when social norm would be to wear something pretty to a 'do' rather than eg trackies (by something pretty, I think trousers are fine)

HauntedNoddyCar · 24/01/2014 10:34

I'm in my 40s and still haven't outgrown my tomboy phase.

It hasn't been indicative of anything. She'll either change or she won't.

waterrat · 24/01/2014 12:19

I was exactly the same - although I think the whole boy girl divide is more extreme than it was hen I was 9 - in the late 80's - anyway I had hair like a bit, wore boys style clothes was often confused for a boy by adults - I really didn't care

I started wearing skirts when I had to wear a uniform for secondary - I then became a hormonal teen and started dressing like every other girl around

Leave her to do what she wants it will have no bearing on her future dress style probably - she is reacting against the pink fixation of modern life - it shows independence of spirit !

SkipandTink · 24/01/2014 12:27

Sounds so like my dd who is also 9, and will only wear boys clothes. It started around the age of six when she would express a preference for jeans rather than skirts and so on, and gradually she began to refuse to wear girls clothes altogether. She even wears boxer shorts I bought for her brother who didn't want them. she wears boys school shoes (far more comfy and practical than the girly alternatives anyway!) and has also just started playing football. She is the only girl in the team and wouldn't have it any other way. her hair is too thick and wiry to have too short, so we compromise with a slightly below the shoulder style that she wears in a ponytail. Her school coat is a boys one, her pjs, and so on. It does not bother me at all. She has a lovely group of friends, two of whom are quite girly, and one who is less so, and they all just accept and love her how she is!
I am so proud of her. She is extremely funny and clever, can kill us all with one dead pan look or comment, and is the most loving older sister to her brother. I do get comments from family members that as she gets older she might get teased, but I don't think this is reason to stop her being her. She has told me many times that she would rather be a boy because they clothes and toys are cooler and I couldn't agree more! She would like to be a mummy when she grows up though. She is so scathing about adverts on tv for clothes or hair or perfume, she sees it all as fake and a waste of time! I'm not particularly girly myself, but I do have long hair and wear the occasional skirt or dress, but I am not into hair/nails/clothes/handbags etc so I guess she gets some of it from me!

Miggsie · 24/01/2014 12:32

Clothing in the boys section is better made, more practical and lasts longer.

DD is 10 and wears mostly boys stuff especially for sport, she always has boys sandals in the summer as they are for active children.

Also, DD has no shape at all and is dead skinny so boy's stuff fits a treat. The M&S posh suits range is perfect for formal occasions and really reasonably priced too.

She does wear girl pants though!

nobutreally · 24/01/2014 12:35

Good on your dd, I'd say - she's found an identity she's happy with & is confident in it. My dd goes through phases - from girly to tom boy - every year/18mths or so. She is currently - in a phase when she'll wear a bit of both, but we've certainly had times when we've shopped exclusively in the boys sections for her. She's 8, btw.

I'd carry on doing what you're doing & ignore your mum!

BackforGood · 24/01/2014 12:44

She sounds great - 'comfortable in her own skin' as they say. Tell your Mum to butt out.
My dd - who is 15 now - would always choose jeans / combats and hoodies over anything more girlie. She's lovely. not at all biased

pointythings · 24/01/2014 13:27

You're doing the right thing, your mum is wrong. My DD1 is 13 and she lives in jeans, joggers and the odd pair of leggings. She likes dressing up for a special occasion and has a nice skirt and one good dress, but even that isn't girly - no flower prints, bling or anything swirly, she wouldn't be seen dead in anything like that. Her favourite 'uniform' is her skinny jeans, her fake Doc Martens (she isn't getting real ones until her feet stop growing) and a lumberjack shirt over a vest. And she looks great.

Dd2 is a little bit more feminine, but also on the quirky side. Tell your mum your DD is a person, not a doll to be dressed up.

KatyN · 24/01/2014 14:24

Could you talk to you mother about what is her concern? what is the worst case senario that she's warning you against? Is it that your daugher might be gay, or transgender, or something else?

Once she's had a chance to think about these options (which may not be the case at all, or may be but I suspect 9 is too early to make a decision) she might find it's not actually that bad.

It reminded me of a post I read a while ago from this lady.
nerdyapple.com/my-son-is-gay/ just the 'so what' ness

k

Coffeeessential · 24/01/2014 18:02

Thankyou, KatyN, for that great link (I read it, and it actually made me cry.)
Thankyou also to everyone else who has read and taken the time to reply to my post - I feel easier in my mind now about the way we are doing things, and so will ignore my mum! The support here has been great, and I really appreciate it.

OP posts:
exexpat · 24/01/2014 18:11

You might like this blog post too: Blurred gender lines.

My DD was also wearing a lot of her brother's hand-me-downs (by choice) and shopping in the boys' section at age 9 or so.

Pizdets · 24/01/2014 19:16

You sound like a great mum! My sister was just like this in the 80s and loved being mistaken for a boy. She's in a same-sex relationship now (happily married) but much more girly and I find myself quite jealous of her style.

I think it takes a lot of courage to support your child in being themselves, well done!

Ps - sure Angelina Jolie has a daughter who it very much a tomboy who she supports in that which I thought was lovely.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page