Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

7 yo DD refusing to tidy her room

6 replies

LucyLastik · 13/11/2011 14:54

7 yo DD1 was asked today to tidy her room. She does share it with 3yo DS so I have taken that into consideration, and told them both they have to tidy their own stuff up.

DS goes into the bedroom, and duly picks up all his stuff. No threats needed, no shouting, no moaning.

DD1 goes into the bedroom and immediately begins protesting as to the unfairness of it all. The bedroom floor was swimming in hama beads, teddies, books, school uniform and fairy paraphernalia. DD1 shoves all of this, including the school uniform under the bed.

I go in to check how she is getting on. She is sitting on the now empty floor, writing in a magazine. I uncover all the uniform under the bed and I'll admit, I can feel my blood pressure rising. All DC know where their dirty clothes go and they also know I won't wash it if it's not in the wash basket. I mention to DD1 that she will go to school tomorrow in dirty uniform if it doesn't end up in the wash basket. Cue massive tantrum.

I studiously ignore her, and go into tend to DD2 who is requesting lunch in that way that 18 month olds do. DD1 is still tantrumming like a 2yo.

I go back into the bedroom, she is writing in the magazine again. I ask her if she has put all the junk away from on her bed. She says no, she doesn't want to do it and thinks it is unfair that she has to tidy up after herself. I climb up onto her bed (no mean feat!) and lob it all on the floor. I tell her it's fine if she doesn't want to put her stuff away. I'll come in and do it for her, but I will put it away permanently in a bin liner outside.

Cue more tantrums, screaming, crying. I'm terribly unfair apparently. She doesn't see why she should have to clear up after "everybody". It's her mess. I tell her that is how I feel every weekend and actually, if her 3yo brother can cope with tidying his stuff up, there really is no excuse for her not to do it.

DD1 announces she wants to go the park. DS is quite keen on this idea too. I tell them we will go once DD1 has done her room. She continues to refuse. I continue to ignore and go back to sorting DD2 out.

By now, I am ready to lose my rag with her. I don't think it is unreasonable for a 7yo to take responsibility for their belongings and put them away once she has finished using them. DD1 disagrees. Apparently, it is my job to tidy up after them all. It is my job to tidy their room, make their beds and put their clothes in the wash basket. Apparently, according to DD1, that is what I had children for Hmm.

Needless to say, DD1 is not going to the park now. I have, by some heroic feat managed to keep my voice at the same level throughout her tantrum. The bedroom is now done but it took nearly 3 hours of tantrums to get there.

Did I do the right thing?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
GiganticusBottomus · 13/11/2011 15:05

I'm not sure what you did? It seems a bit like your other Dc have come off worse as they missed their treat.

I am quite mean and would have given her one warning, if I come back and your stuff is everywhere, I would have set a timer (that she could see) and say you have this amount of time. If it wasn't done I would have cleared out her toys and said she wouldn't get them back unless she earned them (slowly).

All easy with hindsight though! The main thing is you didn't tidy for her so that's great. I think a lot of children have a massive sense of entitlement (not aimed at your dd, I'm a teacher so I see it all the time) and expect to be 'waited on'. The sooner they realise this isn't the case, the better.

LucyLastik · 13/11/2011 15:23

She is absolutely like that! Thinks everyone should be running around after her and if it were just her and no other DCs then possibly I would be guilty of that Blush.

Yes DS and DD2 missed out on the park which is a shame. Not sure how I would deal with that in future.

OP posts:
MCos · 13/11/2011 22:41

If my DDs had their way, they wouldn't tidy either.

I give them 30 mins from time of request, and remind them that whatever isn't tidy in 30 mins goes into a big plastic sack and will go up into the attic until they earn it back.

I mostly get 'its not fair' and attitude, but 2-3 years into this tactic they have not yet risked the consequence. If they make a good effort, I'll give them longer time or give them a hand to complete it. But I am prepared to follow through if needed.

I have a cleaner come twice a month, and if kids don't tidy up beforehand, the cleaner will just move all toys into the toy boxes and the kids can't find anything. It has happened twice, and caused DDs sufficient inconvenience that they just get stuck in and don't even bother to give me attitude on those evenings!

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

YourCallIsImportant · 13/11/2011 22:48

Lucy I had almost the same experience with my DD, 8, today - bin bags, Hama beads, books, school uniform, underwear etc.

I can get her to help me do it, after much wailing and gnashing of teeth (mine usually) but not do it herself.

It's driving me mad, it didn't get done today and I'm tempted to do it tomorrow when she's at school, but the same problem will occur next weekend. sigh...

tigerlillyd02 · 14/11/2011 01:04

Christmas is coming up - perhaps she can wake up to no presents because Santa doesn't think she knows how to keep the toys she already has tidy? :D

I am kidding!! Mean but not quite that mean... although sometimes I really do think it'd be a fantastic lesson for them lol

Anyway, in the same situation I think I'd give a time limit on it. Tell her that if it's not done in that time they'll all be going. Should it not be completed properly at the end of that time, I'd then get a bin liner / box or something and remove everything that lies on the floor. I'm assuming there will be other toys around that she'd then play with over the course of the following week. Should she manage to clean these toys up the following weekend, I'd give her the others back. If not, the same will occur again until she gets the message that she's going to be extremely bored with no toys until she learns to keep them tidy.

Then if she screams about it, let her. Don't enter into a debate or argument over it.

mumeeee · 14/11/2011 10:55

You did the right thing about nor tidying up for her. But one thing I don't understand is why did you climb up on the bed and throw all the stuff on the floor?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page