Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

the wrong type of love.......................very long one, sorry.

62 replies

zumarud · 16/11/2005 16:16

hello, I've read threads about this topic before, but i desperately need some new insights.

My 6,5 year old dd is i think extremely immature - in a very specific way. she needs to play being very very young - 2 or 3 - a lot. This comprises talking in a baby voice and generally behaving in a silly way. And her play is generally at the same level as her 4 year old sister's - ie she will always go down to her sister's level rather than making her sister come up to hers. This is the same even with her sister's friends. I find the extent of her need slightly worrying and I'm also concerned that she is only mixing at school with the rather immature, babyish kind of girls.
Clearly she has a need to relieve stress or to behave in a babyish way, but can I teach her to pick her moments, or help her outgrow this need, or do I need to swallow my discomfort and just love and accept that this is where she's at? I've had several incidents recently where I've picked her up from a friend's house and the mother has said - oh, xxx (my dd) only wanted to play babies and my daughter doesn't really do this any more. And I've notied that the more sophisticated, dynamic girls have stopped inviting her over.
The background is that we have had an unsettled few years, moving about a lot. Also post my dd2 I had postpartum psychosis and severe pnd, and I couldn't cope with my dd1s need to be babied when I had a new baby. I think I was overly harsh with her and that this has probably not helped her, but I really think she is "stuck" in this age, emotionally, and I want her to move on, not least because she's a very clever, imaginative girl who is selling herself short on the friends front, but also because little girls are very cruel to each other and obviously I want her to be a winner.

wow that was long. Sorry. Any ideas?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
HappyMumof2 · 17/11/2005 18:32

Message withdrawn

HappyMumof2 · 17/11/2005 18:38

Message withdrawn

CarolinaMoon · 17/11/2005 18:39

jeez, everyone lay off zumarud would you???

she's explained what she meant by the title, she knows her PND etc is an issue and she's had some helpful advice which she is now going to put into practice. End of!

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

HappyMumof2 · 17/11/2005 18:40

Message withdrawn

CarolinaMoon · 17/11/2005 18:43

some posters on this thread have just been downright mean and bullying, Happymumof2. That's the worrying thing about this thread.

nooka · 17/11/2005 20:29

I think it's really hard when you have worries about your children, and I think it is brave of zumarud to post here at all, about what is clearly a difficult thing for her. There is a huge difference between a child playing with dolls and always wanting to play baby games. I get the impression that zumarud's dd is wanting to be the baby, rather than playing mummies with her dolls. I think that I would worry about that too (and it would certainly drive me around the bend!). Having said that I wonder if their are some unresolved issues for her too (sorry zumarud, I seem to have got the third tense going her!) and I hope that she has good support with her dh away. I hope some of the things suggested here will help.

taniabyron · 17/11/2005 20:30

I would tend to agree with Carolina. How helpful is it for someone with a history of mental health issues to be told that her thread is "strange" or to react in such a hysterical way, using year 7-style analytical skills to dissect her language? I thought she was pretty self-aware actually, just honest about what is obviously a big deal for her. The whole point of the thread was to get some help. And those of you who have had pnd should mebbe be a bit more sensitive.Have you forgotten the guilt yourselves? or are you in denial?

fennel · 17/11/2005 20:31

zumarad please don't stop posting.

sometimes people can really overreact to posts.

I also worry sometimes that my 5yo dd1 is a bit immature, though for slightly different reasons to Zumarad. I don't want her to be sophisticated like a teenager, of course not, but I wouldn't mind if she would focus a bit more at school instead of messing around with the other more babyish children not actually learning to read etc. I worry she is selling herself a bit short sometimes, her teachers don't really see a very good side of her.

melissasmummy · 17/11/2005 23:31

Something tells me that those "sophisticated, dynamic girls" of 6 are actually probably too old for their age, rather than the other way around.

I don't remember ever feeling loved by my mum & every now & then (at 30yrs old & a mother of 1) I will do what I can to make my DH show his love for me. I am not ashamed, it's me & I need that reassurance. I think your DD is just finding it easier being younger at the moment, maybe it makes her feel more secure.

melissasmummy · 17/11/2005 23:37

We all have, at some point had our "crushes" on celebs etc. This is just excapism, no more than what your DD is doing. Being 6 obviously isn't where she wants to be right now, so she is excaping into a younger world, her sister gets alot of attention for being a baby & to your DD1, maybe that is just what she craves now.

SackAche · 18/11/2005 09:09

Sorry folks! But I have suffered badly from PND..... and I KNOW that some of my behaviour was strange!

Zubarud - You can't actually be surprised that your post shocked..... you may have meant it as a joke, but this thread has not been funny in the slightest....and we're not mind readers! I can only comment on what I read. And that can often be misconstrued on when its just text rather than conversation.

I don't see any bullying at all!

Haven't you all noticed the pattern on MN yet? Someone posts looking for help.
They get lots of great advice from posters desperately trying to stay completely neutral and walking on eggshells

Then there a few people posting straight to the point "this is worrying..... you have more of a problem than your dd.... perhaps you should try to solve your own problems 1st before dealing with dd" IT'S TRUE BTW!

Then you get someone coming on saying "Oooooo don't be so nasty!"

Well I don't see any nastiness on this thread.

I'm not obsessed with the thread title.... but......ahem..... the TITLE of a thread tends to be quite important and I just couldn't understand from your posts what was the wrong type of love!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Nothing wrong with asking!

Anyway... sorry you feel like that.....and I do hope you get your problems sorted out. I was only trying to help you, as when I had PND I couldn't see that most of the problems were my own and I wish someone had been honest with me.

Nightynight · 18/11/2005 09:13

zamarud - hope you enjoy playing babyish games with your 6 year old! She sounds perfectly normal to me
one day, when she's getting brilliant A level results, you'll look back at now and laugh. Someone once posted on Mumsnet about some girls that were weeing behind the sofa when they were five years old, and are now studying at Oxford...I have often remembered this, when cleaning up after my children.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page