Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Other subjects

A wedding thread - Mumsnet advice needed on how to cause the least amount of upset (no upset at all is not an option)

37 replies

BroccoliSpears · 04/06/2008 20:17

DP and I have never wanted to get married. In fact, we have actively not wanted to get married. Reasons not terribly relevant to this thread. We're perfectly happy as we are.

My family: Would be delighted if we changed out minds, but quite understand that it's our decision alone, and they're sensible enough to realise that the most important bit is that we're stable and happy and, in their eyes, "as good as married".

DP's family: Don't understand at all why we won't do it. Forever bringing the subject up. Feel that the reason we're not married is because we're not committed to each other, in which case we should split up. The fact that we're not married causes them unhappiness.

So. It is looking increasingly likely that by the end of the year we're going to be living in a country in which it is illegal for unmarried couples to co-habit. As far as we're concerned no biggie, we'll pop down to the registry office and get married. It is just a document. It's not like we weren't planning on being together forever anyway, and it won't have any bearing on our relationship.

My family: we'll phone and tell them that we're getting married so we can move to this place. Explain that it's a legal document, not a wedding. They'll understand.

DP's family: Urg! What do we do? They're very pushy and will almost certainly want to come along. I don't really want that because as soon as we mark the occasion in any way it would be unfair to my family who won't be there. And as soon as we have both families it's a wedding which we don't want. Bluntly put, we don't want DP's family there. We don;t want anyone there. How do we tell them this without upsetting them too much?

(Fait accompli not a goer).

PS - We are quite happy to have a bit of a celebration in a few years time.

PPS - I'm such a sap - this evening DP said "Broccoli, will you marry me?" and I said yes and felt all romantic and absurdly pleased! Arf. I'm such a fake .

OP posts:
NormaStanleyFletcher · 04/06/2008 22:54

or do as MorningPaper did (I think), invite everyone to a summer party and surprise them by being in a wedding dress, having got hitched in the morning.

jesuswhatnext · 05/06/2008 12:22

i think one point to make here is, are the family more concerned that you have a marriage certificate to show your commitment to each other, in which case they should just be pleased you are finally married, however you do it! or a 'big do' - if it is more important to them to have a party then sod them! do what you think is right for you

MinkyBorage · 05/06/2008 12:26

If you tell them before hand they could ruin your day, if you tell them afterwards they can't.

bohemianbint · 05/06/2008 12:29

Hello. Having been in this situation a month ago, I can tell you that I wish, in a way, we hadn't said anything about getting married. We should have just gone to the office and signed the paper and kept it to ourselves. We are having a party/handfasting next year (couldn't face it this year, am too pregnant) but people still got all arsey and don't understand what we're doing. Which has caused some bad feeling, and some from me, as I think if people love and respect you they should respect what you want to do, not enforce their wishes on you.

We did end up having only the parents there and went for a meal afterwards. It was really nice, but difficult in that they still don't get it, IYSWIM, and think we're a bit mental. Given the time again, I think we would have just lied about the register office bit so that people would focus on the party next year instead.

SLightly different circumstances, I know, but HTH a bit...Good luck and don't be pressurised, you'll only resent it.

EffiePerine · 05/06/2008 12:30

What does your DP think? In the circs I would say his family = his problem

morningpaper · 05/06/2008 12:35

Aw Brocolli this was my dilemma exactly and I felt like you did - if anyone is going to be there, shouldn't it be the important people?

ANYWAY we arranged a big summer party in the garden, invited everyone, and then got married that morning so it was a wedding do. People couldn't complain because they were all invited. Job done. Some people said 'If we'd known it was a wedding we would have come!' but we said that's the whole POINT, we don't want a WEDDING, we just want to have a nice day

solo · 05/06/2008 12:37

I'd do it and tell no one...keep them guessing when you move abroad. They'll get over it - eventually.
Or...do the e mail thing to tell everyone. Done and dusted. End of.
Good luck and Congratulations(I think)

Pidge · 05/06/2008 12:50

Gosh, sympathy. Dp and I felt exactly like you, but after much fretting about legal protection decided with huge reluctance (particularly on my part) to get married. So ... took both kids and 2 friends as witnesses on the bus to the local registry office one morning and got it done.

No family invited - would have been an irrelevance, if anyone quibbles ask them would they insist on being present when you go to solicitor to make a will. It's the same thing.

Dp insisted on telling our parents ("out of politeness") which meant my mum and dad spilled the beans and someone months later came up at a family party and congratulated us, and dp and I honestly had no clue what they were talking about! With friends we didn't announce it at all, but if it comes up in conversation we don't deny it. It's just a tedious admin detail as far as I'm concerned. You wouldn't send an email out saying "hey we've just switched mortgage provider" and to me this is no more interesting .

As for a party - we actually had a 'celebration of our relationship' several years before the registry office visit. We were able to make it what we wanted without any of the pressures of a wedding, which people inevitably have certain expectations of. It was lovely.

colacubes · 05/06/2008 13:02

I understand broccoli, myself and dp are not married, its been brought up, but the thought of all that cash on a party is not my idea of fun, plus I dont think I am the wedding type!!

But If it was such an issue for the inlaws, and you have to get spliced any hoo, I would put on a frock, and have a little do, for his family, sometimes making someone else happy is a good thing, if you got to do it anyway, let his mum feel like she's being part of it and let her celebrate. Plus excuse for a new dress and a little get to gether before you go!

ecoworrier · 05/06/2008 13:47

I would do it and tell absolutely no-one until such time as you choose to tell them.

If anyone tries to make a fuss in the future, say it wasn't a 'wedding' it was a legal process that had to be gone through at that particular time, and that no-one missed out on the event/party because there wasn't one!

There are some things you have to do for yourself, and your choice of where and when and whether you get married, and what sort of occasion it is, is definitely one of those things. It is for you two as a couple, nobody else.

BroccoliSpears · 05/06/2008 19:02

MP - am smiling at the people who would have made it if they'd known it was a wedding - the important people make it even when it's 'just' a summer party.

DP thinks the same as I do, but (as he will be the first to admit) he's not brilliant at dealing with his family. It's his step-mother not his mother, and he doesn't always read her well.

OP posts:
BroccoliSpears · 05/06/2008 19:04

Pidge, I'm printing off your post and learning bits of it by heart to quote at PILs!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page