Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Other subjects

concerned that friend is potentially in a controlling relationship

12 replies

worriedaboutafriend · 11/01/2008 14:58

I am a regular but have namechanged because I don?t want to be recognized in rl.

I have a friend who I met about 2.5 years ago through our dc being at preschool together. She is lovely, and over time I also met her dh who seemed like a lovely, genuine, if perhaps a bit of a lad type guy.

Anyway about 8 months ago we all went to their dd?s party, and afterwards another friend said to me ?I think x dh is very controlling and possessive of her. She was very relaxed and the instant he walked in the room her whole attitude changed and she seemed to be afraid somehow.? I hadn?t noticed if I?m honest, he?d never seemed the controlling type, although he is much more outgoing than she is and I had wondered if she perhaps feels a bit as if she lives in his shadow iykwim?

But some things over the past few months have led me to wonder if my friend could have been right.

Firstly, she?s stopped doing the school run altogether. Her dh runs his own business, and yet he does drop off and pick up every day without fail. If ever she does do the school run, he generally comes with her. A couple of times I have seen her and asked if everything is ok and she?s said something like ?oh yes, it?s just that I?m never ready in time so dh just says shall I do it? with a sort of nervous laugh.

One day she did pick up her dd and they came to the park, about half an hour later he turned up saying that he thought she was coming straight home as he needed the car. He?d walked all the way to the park to say that, when they both have mobiles so he could have called her?

Recently she asked me to buy something for her dd on holiday, to replace an item she had bought for her in the same place but which dd had left on the aeroplane. I bought it, and gave it to her dh who was doing the school run that morning, and he had no knowledge of the fact she?d asked me to buy it. Then for about two weeks after he kept asking if she?d given me the money, despite the fact he is the breadwinner and could have given it to me?

She used to have lots of friends, but now she doesn?t seem to keep in touch with any of them any more.

I feel guilty being suspicious of this guy, he does seem genuine, but seems almost too genuine if that makes sense. Going out of his way to be the perfect father/husband/to do good by others, cosying up to the teacher for little chats after school, telling them what a lovely job they?re doing etc, it just seems too good to be true iyswim?

I do also feel guilty because they?ve been good to me in the past, he has been out of his way to offer me lift home when I?ve been to school functions and would have had to walk home in the dark that sort of thing, so to be accusing him does feel wrong somehow.

But thing is, I can?t get involved can I? I can?t approach this woman and ask if she?s in a controlling relationship because really it?s none of my business is it? And besides I could be wrong.

Am I wrong to be suspicious or does this sound odd to anyone else?

OP posts:
worriedaboutafriend · 11/01/2008 15:04

bump

OP posts:
Flllightattendant · 11/01/2008 15:07

It sounds odd.

I am with you on this, from what you describe.

Sadly I think there is very little you as an outsider can do. You would need to be a very good friend. Is thre any way you could make it clear to her, when he isn't around (If that ever happens) that you are there if she ever needs to talk, or just let slip something that tells her you know and will be there if she needs you.

Be very much the opposite to him though. If he gets an inkling you are onto him, if he is controlling her, he will whip away your friendship quick as anything.

How awful for you to be a bystander, it must be very frustrating

Flllightattendant · 11/01/2008 15:09

Sorry by being opposite to him, I ean be really relaxed with him and never let on that you are concerned. That way you won't be on his hitlist of friends to get rid of. Even maybe say something like 'gosh she is such a muddlehead isn't she!' and see what his reaction is...that might be a bit risky though.

Flllightattendant · 11/01/2008 15:10

...and even if that made it very apparent that your suspicions are correct, it wouldn't give you any advantage in terms of helping her, so probably not a good idea after all!

cestlavie · 11/01/2008 15:17

I wonder how many of these 'signs' you would have noticed if the person hadn't said about her DH being controlling etc? Generally, I think we need to be careful looking for evidence of something which may or may not exist as we can always find some level of 'evidence' to support it. For example, if someone says they think your partner might be having an affair, next time their phone is switched off you'd assume the worst whereas ordinarily it would never cross your mind.

worriedaboutafriend · 11/01/2008 15:28

cestlavie I do take your point, but I do think I would have noticed the park incident as being odd. plus would definitely have noticed her never doing school run, although might have put it down to there being something up with her.

OP posts:
bossykate · 11/01/2008 15:36

sorry i think you need to get out more!

god forbid a dad should do the school run!

worriedaboutafriend · 11/01/2008 18:02

bossykate lots of dads round here do the school run. but...

she is a sahm, he isn't, he has a supposedly very demanding business to run, and yet he seems to manage to pick up his dd at 3:00 every afternoon without her mum being present, ever.

The mum doesn't have other children to look after, so it's not a case of dad doing the school run while mum deals with siblings.

Plus the incident at the park.. he walked about 15 minutes from his house to the park to tell her that she needed to come home because he needed the car. He could have called? After that he walked back home and she got her dd and drove.

It just strikes me as odd is all. She does things as and when he says.

OP posts:
TurkeyLurkey · 11/01/2008 18:08

Can't you give her a ring and arrange to go out with her? If you maintain a friendship with her she is more likely to trust you and confide in you if he is being overbearing.

Or alternativley you may find out its a load of old bolleaux.

OverMyDeadBody · 11/01/2008 18:10

Maybe there is another explanation, rather than that he is controlling?

Like maybe she is ill and having special treatment or has an appointment that means she can't do the school run, but they have both decided that they don't want anyone else knowing yet? That would explain the nervous laugh about why she doesn't do the school run. Maybe she didn't have her phone with her at the park, or her DH was worried when they didn't come home and acted irrationally?

bossykate · 11/01/2008 20:57

sorry if i sounded harsh maybe it is one of those things where "you just have to be there". i think all the things in your post could have a perfectly rational explanation. maybe they have decided it's simply more convenient for him to do the school run? if he runs his own business he may well have the flexibility to do it. maybe that means she can have a shower in peace after they've both gone. who knows?

FlllightAttendant · 12/01/2008 10:39

Having been out with a couple of controlling men, and read a fair bit on domestic abuse, I would say these signs are worrying.

I hope we're wrong but I'm glad you are looking out for your friend just in case.

It sounds as though he has a lot of power in the relationship, and 'needs' to know where she is/check up on her all the time.

That's a sign of a very insecure and potentially abusive man.

If it is true, he would be doing the school run because he doesn't trust her to be out mixing with other people, as she might find out that the way he is treating her is not normal.
He would have walked to the park because phoning her would have given her the opportunity to lie, and he would then not have had the control he needed.
It also had the surprise factor so he could have caught her out if she was doing something he didn't like.
Plus it gives him more of an image of authority, to actually turn up in person.

Interfering with her transactions is also worrying - taking charge of every single part of her life in other words. And the fact that she nervously makes excuses that just sound ridiculous is something else that I would be concerned about.

I personally would have little doubt that she is being treated in a very controlling manner.

I think the only thing you can do is to try to remain her friend whilst pretending to her DH that you suspect nothing.

Good luck. I really hope she finds a way out of what is going on - if indeed something is.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page