Active discussions

Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Talk
Other subjects
Original poster

Harry Potter and the goblet of Fire film - have you seen it? Is it scary?

18 replies

puddle · 02/05/2007 12:27

Ds (just 7) is reading the book at the moment. He will want to watch the film as soon as he has finished the book. I haven't really been keeping an eye on the story so i don't know what happens in it, have just the odd chapter that I read to him and bits that he has read out loud to me/ told me about.

How scary is it? I can see it's a 12 cert. My ds is quite sensitive about the tv (scared of Dr Who for eg and won't watch it now) but he is much more able to watch things when he has already 'seen' them in his head from reading the book...eg Prisoner of Azkerban was fine (although have just looked and that's a PG...)

OP posts:
MamaG · 02/05/2007 12:29

My DD age 7 watched it. It is quite scary, some bad stuff happens, but she was fine. She is quite tough though and had read the book first so knew what was coming.

I read all her books before she does though, always, so I can guage whether they are too scary for her.

saltire · 02/05/2007 12:29

I thought the book was more scary (for a child) than the film. The scene in the graveyard where Voldemort and his death eaters appear is a bit scary, it depends on your child. DS2, who is just turned 7 loves it, and has been watching itsince it came out, but DS1 who is 9 hates it.
There is also the scene in the campsite, which isn't so much scary, as just very dark, all filmed at night. perhaps you could watch it yourself before giving to your child

princesscc · 02/05/2007 12:32

If he's seen the rest, he'll be fine. The book is far worse than the film. The scene in the maze at the end is a bit scarey, but like Saltire says, if you watch it first, you can judge for yourself. Its very long btw!

Notquitegrownup · 02/05/2007 12:33

Hi I posted exactly the same thing last year. DS1 is also just 7, and has only just started enjoying Dr Who, rather than being freaked by it - they sound very similar.

I think as long as he has read the book, it is not too bad at all. The graveyard scene at the end is potentially the worst bit, but it is all over disappointingly quickly - not nearly as vivid as the book's descriptions. We didn't find it any scarier than Azkaban. I think it probably has the higher rating because Cedric dies at the end, and they have to show that as it is such a central part of the book.

I would watch it with him, and offer him a cushion/be prepared talk about it/switch it off if he needs it - but I don't think you will need to. As you say, once you have read the book, it seems rather tame.

Original poster
puddle · 02/05/2007 12:34

he is loving the book but will only read it if I am pottering (ha!) around in the background.

OP posts:
Original poster
puddle · 02/05/2007 12:35

mamag I feel bad now!

I do agree in principle I should probably be reading things first but honestly it's 100s of pages and I refuse to spend my reading time on it.

OP posts:
princesscc · 02/05/2007 12:35

Can't wait to have this conversation post Order of The Phoenix! Only about 8 weeks to go now!!

MrsWeasley · 02/05/2007 12:37

not been keeping an eye on the story

Original poster
puddle · 02/05/2007 12:38

Notquite - I dodn't know someone dies in this one. Have no idea who cedric is - he's not a central character is he?

OP posts:
Original poster
puddle · 02/05/2007 12:39

Sorry Mrs Weasly! The joy of them reading independently is that he can read JK while I plough through Hilary Mantel (also spooky stuff though so you should approve...)

OP posts:
MrsWeasley · 02/05/2007 12:47

LOL Oh course as a mother of many I approve of all reading.

but Harry Potter books are of course the best ;)

Notquitegrownup · 02/05/2007 13:33

Hi Puddle

Cedric is central to this book, but not one of Harry mates, so it shouldn't be too traumatic. The scene in the graveyard is quite violent in the book from what I remember, but Cedric doesn't suffer at all, it's instantaneous. DS1 knew from the hype when he read this book that someone died, and I so let him guess who, just to prepare him a bit. You might like to play "So, what do you think is going to happen . . ." with your ds!

Original poster
puddle · 02/05/2007 15:38

Eeek I think I may need to prepare him! does it happen right at the end?

I may just drop 'so what do you think of cedric then?' into the convo.

OP posts:
Notquitegrownup · 02/05/2007 15:59

Hi Puddle

It's near the end. Harry and Cedric are in a competition, have various challenges to do which end up in a giant maze. However, Voldemort spirits them off to a graveyard, where his helper kills Cedric immediately. Vodemort's helper then binds Harry to a graavestone and takes some of his blood to give Voldemort strength. Voldemort then slices off the helpers arm before dualling with Harry in front of a gathering of Death Eaters. It's all quite dark and dramatic and dealt with quite superficially in the film. However, theres a really exciting conclusion as (obviously) Harry turns the tables, doesn't die, returns to Hogwarts and then discovers - well, I won't spoil that bit for your son.

MamaG · 02/05/2007 21:39

Puddle - don't feel bad

I love reading anywya, will read the back of a tube of toothpaste if nothing else is to hand

(pcc - me too )

MrsWho · 02/05/2007 21:50

We skipped over that scene at the end for the first couple of times so dd could see it turned out ok IYSWIM (she already knew about Cedric but was worried about Harry )
Now she'll watch it 'cos she knows what happens next.

GythaOggsFrog · 02/05/2007 22:02

at all these brave dc.

Dd 7 (a voracious reader) has been pesteriing me to let her read my () Harry Potter books, but I've been holding back as she finds the Famous Five books scary .

Gawd knows what she'd make of the films.

I've just introduced her to "The Little House on the Prairie" dvds and she finds Nellie Olsen scary and refuses to watch

MrsWho · 02/05/2007 22:45

my dd1 will happily watch Dr Who, Harry Potter but then cries at Herbie

New posts on this thread. Refresh page