Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Other subjects

I am disgusted at the misplaced GREED of Cancer Research UK

27 replies

BonyM · 04/08/2006 21:23

Dh is a research scientist and had applied to the Leukemia Research Foundation (who are controlled by CRUK) for a grant which was subsequently approved subject to agreeing terms.

He had an email from them today, to say that they cannot now release grant funds to him because "LRF is unlikely to accrue any financial benefit for an outlay in excess of £250K".

Basically, they wanted dh's university to agree that in the event of the drug making it to market, they would get 50% of the income. Note, income, not profit, so if the drug were successful and made for example 1 billion pounds, CRUK would take 0.5 billion pounds, even if it cost 0.5 billion to develop. Because of a previous deal, the technology is now owned jointly by the university and a commercial company so it was impossible for the university to agree to this.

Instead, LRF were offered, initially, double their grant back if the drug became marketable, and then, when they refused that, "milestone" payments at each stage of development. Basically, they refused to give the grant unless they were promised 50%.

Am I the only person to think that this is a totally inappropriate stance for a charity to take? What about potential patient benefit? All they seem interested in is profit.

Sorry for the rant, but I really felt that other people should know how they operate, that patients are being denied the possibility of new treatments because the charity won't get any financial benefit (of course, 500K is no benefit!).

I am so .

OP posts:
MrsBadcrumble · 05/08/2006 09:07

Blimey. My dh is a research scientist too (different field) so I know how irritating it must be for your dh to have put so much into the grant application (bloody grant applications take up huge amounts of dh's "free time") only to get jerked around like this.
Not only that but dh had cancer and CRUK have a big research facility at the hospital he was treated at, so we donate money monthly.
Is there another funding body he can apply to?

zippitippitoes · 05/08/2006 09:08

I think it's related to risk isn't it? The higher the assessed risk in an investment then the higher the return expected if there ever is one and as you say drug research is a high risk area. Cancer research presumably give many grants in the hope that one will come up with the goods..that one has to pay towards the failures?

I think charities are now very much businesses. Their fundraisers are commercial companies. The idea of a charity being anything other than an organisation which needs to be run as a business is long gone.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page