Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

One-child families

Got questions about only having one child? Find the answers here.

For those who had one by choice: did you ever regret or reverse that decision?

64 replies

undecidednamechange · 21/07/2014 21:57

Over the years I have found Mumsnet a huge help in those early, nervous PFB days, and then a mine of useful advice and information on everything from food to holidays to what constitutes frumpy!

Now, once again, I would really appreciate the experience of others. So please excuse the long post - I feel, apart from anything, that I need to set my thoughts down in order, and would then be grateful for any advice from those who have felt similarly.

DH and I have a toddler DC, and now everyone around us seems to be on their second or third child. They keep asking when we will follow. We are very happy as we are, but I keep having niggling doubts about whether I will regret sticking at one in the years to come.

We are generally very lucky and appreciate this.
On the face of it, there are no real reasons not to have a second. My pregnancy, whilst not perfect, was not particularly complicated. The birth was not great, but not really up there with the most traumatic. DC was generally an average feeder/sleeper as a baby - nothing to boast about but nothing much to moan about either - and has grown into a generally cheerful toddler. I found it hard going at first, but managed to avoid PND. We won't know for sure unless we ttc, but there are no apparent reasons why we would not be able to do so again. It would be a bit of a strain financially (and logistically), but ultimately we could afford two if we wanted to do so.

Mentally, though, there are reasons. We are very happy as we are, and loving the toddler phase. We have managed to balance spending a lot of time with DC and as a family, while still working in jobs we enjoy and find fulfilling and finding a bit time for each other and for friends. I feel like there is a brilliant but delicate balance here - a pyramid which can easily be toppled, and I am not willing to give up on any of the elements. I did not enjoy being pregnant or giving birth; I found the early baby days really hard and am not sure how well I would cope mentally doing it all again with the added pressures of another child to look after.

The main reason for having another one, in my current mind, ultimately boil down to giving DC a play mate and someone to share life with later. Not a given by any means, as I know enough people who don't get on with their siblings and have even lost touch altogether. Oh, and to conform to society's expectations. Sigh. But I do wonder how I will feel in 5 years' time.

The background, so as not to drip feed. I was an only child, and was quite lonely. However, I think this was down to a lot more than just being an only child. My mother was an only parent, and not very sociable. I did not spend much time with other kids until I went to school. We never went on holiday with others, didn't often have people round, etc. None of those things apply to our family, and DC has been very happily going to nursery for several years. DH has a sibling, and they are very close now. However, he did feel somewhat deprived of parental attention, which he thinks may not have been the case as an only.

So, ultimately, as my title asks, are there are any mumsnetters out there who had the choice to have more but chose to stick with one? Are you still happy with that decision or did you live to regret it - or indeed decide to reverse it later?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
noddyholder · 08/08/2014 09:15

There is an assumption that later life is full of siblings and family harmony etc. this is not always the case. I have one child may have had another if health had been better but life is about so much more than family as in blood related. And more about a bigger picture. We need to stop categorising people and concentrate on nurturing the individual. My son is happy well balanced and social and I couldn't ask for more He does have a habit of bringing home many waifs and strays though and a quiet hose here is unheard of

BirdingWidow · 08/08/2014 09:15

I am in a huge dilemma over this. I have a DC who is nearly 2 and I am nearly 40. It took us 2 years to conceive last time and so I have no guarantee we will be able to have another even if we start now.

We have no doubt that we want another and that I want a sibling for my son too. That is purely based on the fact that we have loved every bit of having him and, for myself, I have also loved having siblings and wouldn't have wanted to be an only. Obviously not everyone feels that way about their siblings but naturally one's own experience is hugely influential.

The problem for us is that I am the main earner and have a high pressure job. Since having DS I have been ruthless about leaving work on time, working from home occasionally so I can see him more etc, and I feel that we just about have an acceptable balance. I really can't see how I could maintain the same quality of time with 2 though, with factoring in the logistics. No doubt DS would get a lot less attention from us, all told, but would a sibling make up for that? I don't honestly know which is best for DS. In the end biology will probably decide for us. Sad

BBQSteak · 08/08/2014 09:17

I would review the situation every 6 months and see how you see

otherwise you end up thinking about this the whole time

just think im going ot forget about it for 6 months then see how we both feel then

and do this for a couple of years

MillionPramMiles · 08/08/2014 09:54

undecided - the reality is you'll never know if you made the right decision either way because you'll never know how the alternative would have panned out.

Having a second child might be lovely for all of you. It might also result in you having to give up work as childcare costs become unaffordable or having to move to a less desirable area with not great schools as you need more space or having to make other sacrifices as money becomes tight. It might mean you rarely have a moment to yourself or alone with your dh.

It's easier in some ways to dwell on the romantic notions of siblings playing happily together than the more practical realities.

trufflehunterthebadger · 08/08/2014 12:12

My best friend was apparently a dream baby. So her mum thought "she's been such a joy, let's have another"

Her brother was hyperactive, desctructive and generally made life very, very challenging. I know that her parents don't regret her brother at all but her mum does always mention it as a counter to "it's been so easy, another would be perfect"

And then there's always the chance of twins..... Grin

violator · 10/08/2014 10:23

Sassyb your remarks are off the wall.

As you've given examples in your life, I'll give you mine.
My DH has four siblings. They are not close. Three live on the other side of the world, the remaining two in the family see each other at Christmas. They don't dislike each other, they are just closer to their friends.
They had an "idyllic" childhood, groin up in the countryside with a sahm and a dad who was home from work at 4pm every day.
My DH had his friend as best man at his wedding, not one of his brothers. If trouble comes knocking, he calls a mate.

I have one sibling. We get on well but only since we hit our thirties. I'd have loved a brother but hey I didn't get one and if it was something I was resenting my entire life, well I'd need some psychological help for that.

My mum had 3 siblings. When her parents became elderly and died, she was left alone to look after them. Her siblings just didn't care all that much. She ended up very stressed and her relationship with her siblings never really recovered from that.

So while you may be living in a Waltons-style ideal in your head, life is very different.

thinkineed2admit · 11/08/2014 20:37

I have rarely met an only who wanted siblings, and I have 2 sisters but hate them both. We never speak and therefore may as well not exist for each other IYSWIM. Sorry, just the way it is!

Myself, I intended to have more than one but I find myself becoming more and more comfortable with our easy, lovely lifestyle with DD and I kinda don't want to ruin it? If she asks for a sibling I might rethink but for now...no plans...

Kelly1814 · 18/08/2014 16:49

Errr sassy I am TOTALLY happy being an only child. My worst nightmare as a child was that I would suddenly get a sibling! And I know lots of onlies who feel the same.

My Dh has a brother. They LOATHE one another. Haven't spoken for 30 years. He has a sister who he has a fractious relationship with and can go months without speaking to.

I look at him and think I have the much, much better deal as an only.

Lindalove · 29/08/2014 08:53

I'm 38 and pregnant with my first baby. If all goes well, fingers crossed, I very much expect it will be my last.

I have a brother whom I love very much but my main support in life comes from my husband and friends. So I hope I can parent a single child to be open and independent and outgoing to find their own family one day. I don't see it as my responsibility to create that future family now for them. It is however my responsibility to ensure my baby is prepared to make their own way in the world.

I admit some of my reasoning behind not having another child is because I honestly believe I'll do better with one than two. Personality wise I have limited patience, am independent and ambitious and have many things I need to achieve for myself. If I didn't do these things I'd be a sadder, more resentful person. If this means I am 'selfish' them I'd rather be branded that way than be unhappy.

I'm not a baby machine, but if I'm blessed to be a mum of one I'll be the most excellent mum of one I can be. And yes, also be me with my own dreams and goals and achievements I need to make up until I kick the bucket.

EveDallasRetd · 29/08/2014 09:11

I had 5 siblings. Two are dead. One I see maybe once a year, one I see maybe once every 3 months, one I see maybe every two months, but then only so she can ask me to look after her dog - If I didn't I doubt I would see her more than twice a year.

I was the youngest growing up. They all went off and got married/had kids before me. As a teen/early twenties I resented how much money it cost me in Xmas and birthday gifts. I hated being part of a big family.

All the kids are adults now, and I have a 9 year old. Only one of my siblings bothers to send birthday/Xmas gifts for my child - and I resent that too.

DD is an only by her fathers choice (I'd have had another one), but with my agreement. It took a few years but I'm glad. I've been able to spend more time with her, more effort on her, more money on her, more attention on her.

I have no regrets.

sewingmummy · 04/09/2014 21:04

it's really difficult...it's something I think about all the time...I feel guilt, pressure, panic & fear about my DD being an only. I also know she is happy, bright, sociable, kind & a much loved child.

We tried to have another child, but I a horrible miscarriage in August 2013. My DD witnesses me being taken away in an ambulance because i was hemorrhaging. So I find it really hurtful when people say that having an only child is cruel or selfish.

But is there really any right or wrong size for a family? As much as Sassyb0703 mother is unhappy at being an only child, there would also be a huge queue of people lining up to tell you how much they dislike their siblings. I don't particularly like my brother, my OH isn't close to his sister, my Mum hardly talks to her brother & my Dad's siblings fell out so badly he was estranged from 3 of them and never spoke to them again before his death in 2006.

I guess the grass is always greener. If you've got siblings, you might dream about being an only and if you're an only, you may wish you had siblings!

children need to feel loved & supported. They need to feel stable & secure. Can give that to one child or multiple children? That choice is down to you...

MrsTaylor35 · 05/09/2014 11:46

Dilemma !!! Our DS is only one child till now and that’s by choice. I knew my friend who reversed their decision to have onlies but at the cost of career of working mum. Well, it’s a personal choice of her.
We sometimes wish to have second one, when we see our DS is so happy when he is around other kids of his age. But we can’t afford it financially, mentally and emotionally. I took a break of 2 years to take care of DS and spend quality time with him in his early years. We don’t have any family help plus my job is so time-demanding. Managing work-family balance has been always challenging since we become parents and we feel sorry and guilty when we can’t give sufficient time to DS. So sometimes we really feel it is better to limit ourselves to only DC and give all our best possible time and love to him.
My DS is generally very happy go lucky kid and we try our best to fill his need of sibling with help of his school, day-care friends and cousins. So far so good, no regrets.
Sorry for ranting.

Kate.

buggerthebotox · 07/09/2014 10:26

sewingmummy I agree completely. The grass IS always greener. I have one, and managed it at the grand old age of 42, but I would have liked another (in hindsight) but ONLY as company for dd. I'm an only myself, with family all gone, and sometimes I just feel so sorry for dd! The hardest thing for me has been the struggle to keep her occupied with kids of her own age. Thankfully those days seem to be over as she's 12 now and independent.

I don't think it matters what you do-there's always someone whose life is easier/ better than yours and there are always going to be children whose lives are fuller/ nicer than your kids' lives. Or appear that way. The only way to deal with these feelings is to appreciate what is good about YOUR lives and just get on with it. Otherwise you'll be constantly beating yourself up.

ruthyless · 12/09/2014 20:55

Our DS has just turned 3 and I constantly get asked 'so you having another' often by people I barely know!! Personally I find it so rude! We love being a family of 3- we both work full time hours over 4 days each week, so each get a days 1-2-1 time (plus every weekend all together) and it's just magical! He's a kind, thoughtful, happy, bright and very funny child (obviously has his stroppy moments like any other child) and neither me or DH have any wish to have another child! However every now and then the doubts creep in, 'am I being selfish' 'Im I weird for not wanting another child or do people only have another because they think they should' 'is it just self preservation as we've had 4 m/c' 'Will he be lonely, spoilt, selfish etc.' Both me and DH both come from big families of 5 children and have great relationships with most of our siblings- and we have the added pressure of my mother in Law having hated being an only child! If we were going to have another one it would need to be fairly soon but I just don't think I want to!! Arghhhh!! Such a minefield! But I can't help thinking it would be worse to have number 2 and regret it, than possibly regret at some point in the future just having 1!!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page