Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

One-child families

Got questions about only having one child? Find the answers here.

For those who had one by choice: did you ever regret or reverse that decision?

64 replies

undecidednamechange · 21/07/2014 21:57

Over the years I have found Mumsnet a huge help in those early, nervous PFB days, and then a mine of useful advice and information on everything from food to holidays to what constitutes frumpy!

Now, once again, I would really appreciate the experience of others. So please excuse the long post - I feel, apart from anything, that I need to set my thoughts down in order, and would then be grateful for any advice from those who have felt similarly.

DH and I have a toddler DC, and now everyone around us seems to be on their second or third child. They keep asking when we will follow. We are very happy as we are, but I keep having niggling doubts about whether I will regret sticking at one in the years to come.

We are generally very lucky and appreciate this.
On the face of it, there are no real reasons not to have a second. My pregnancy, whilst not perfect, was not particularly complicated. The birth was not great, but not really up there with the most traumatic. DC was generally an average feeder/sleeper as a baby - nothing to boast about but nothing much to moan about either - and has grown into a generally cheerful toddler. I found it hard going at first, but managed to avoid PND. We won't know for sure unless we ttc, but there are no apparent reasons why we would not be able to do so again. It would be a bit of a strain financially (and logistically), but ultimately we could afford two if we wanted to do so.

Mentally, though, there are reasons. We are very happy as we are, and loving the toddler phase. We have managed to balance spending a lot of time with DC and as a family, while still working in jobs we enjoy and find fulfilling and finding a bit time for each other and for friends. I feel like there is a brilliant but delicate balance here - a pyramid which can easily be toppled, and I am not willing to give up on any of the elements. I did not enjoy being pregnant or giving birth; I found the early baby days really hard and am not sure how well I would cope mentally doing it all again with the added pressures of another child to look after.

The main reason for having another one, in my current mind, ultimately boil down to giving DC a play mate and someone to share life with later. Not a given by any means, as I know enough people who don't get on with their siblings and have even lost touch altogether. Oh, and to conform to society's expectations. Sigh. But I do wonder how I will feel in 5 years' time.

The background, so as not to drip feed. I was an only child, and was quite lonely. However, I think this was down to a lot more than just being an only child. My mother was an only parent, and not very sociable. I did not spend much time with other kids until I went to school. We never went on holiday with others, didn't often have people round, etc. None of those things apply to our family, and DC has been very happily going to nursery for several years. DH has a sibling, and they are very close now. However, he did feel somewhat deprived of parental attention, which he thinks may not have been the case as an only.

So, ultimately, as my title asks, are there are any mumsnetters out there who had the choice to have more but chose to stick with one? Are you still happy with that decision or did you live to regret it - or indeed decide to reverse it later?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Lally112 · 07/08/2014 21:18

I don't have one out of choice - I always knew I would have more but MiL and FiL didn't think they would, They had DH at 19 and 22 and FiL had a vasectomy after.

Ten years later and they wanted another and had to have FiLs vasectomy reversed and it worked eventually but it took a long time. DH and I have been together since I was 13 so I was there for most of it and when BiL was born when DH was 16 it was great for everyone but the TTC path had taken its toll on the whole family.

Oneforthemummy · 07/08/2014 21:50

On every thread about only children someone always wades in with the 'selfish' comment to describe parents who chose to have one child.
I found your posts a little offensive Sassy, suggesting that my decision to only have one child is selfish. There are many reasons behind my decision (difficulty in conceiving, PND, age, not to mention the fear of what a second birth/child could do to my mental state) and yes, I have many, many moments of guilt and worry that I should be providing a sibling for DD. DD is too young to understand or express any thoughts about having a sibling (she is two next month) but I have to trust that I will be able to raise her as a happy, confident, sociable child who will not feel a sense of loss about something she never had.
Ultimately, you have to do what feels right for you and your family.

JackShit · 07/08/2014 21:51

I have one due to health issues and I feel like shit about it every day.

Sassy, your posts are beyond rude. This planet is grossly over populated and smaller families need to become the norm.

Catmint · 07/08/2014 22:01

We have one DD. It took us a long time to conceive and I'm now too old to have any more.

DP adamant from the first that he only wanted one: I find it difficult at times. We can provide DD a much better life economically and emotionally than we could with more children, which is wonderful at age 7, but I do worry for her being alone later.

Very sadly, my brother and his lovely partner have been unable to have children; so DD will be truly alone. Obviously we couldn't have predicted this, but it haunts me.

This year's school report told us of DD's 'inner confidence' and I hope very much to continue to nurture this because she will need it.

CateBlanket · 07/08/2014 23:29

Sassy - you're being obnoxious.

Artistic · 07/08/2014 23:55

After DD turned 3, this question of should we have another regularly raised its head. I had a tough pregnancy. Not so much because of complications, rather because of being ill as a child myself and subsequently having a delicate adult health life. Recovery from childbirth was very hard, sleepless nights drove my health off the rails. On top of this I developed unrelated joint & dental complications in the years after childbirth (triggered due to pregnancy). Overall going back to work & bringing up a toddler - it was all too much for me. But the question never left me. I finally realised that I wanted another baby - for DD and for myself too. So when she turned 6, I took the jump though DH was not convinced I could go through it & that he could again support me through such a long recovery. But I decided that I'd regret it if I never went for it - even if logically there were good reasons not too (including the delicate balance we had now achieved). Expecting DC2 now when DD is 7. Very pleased to have gone for it. The gap is high but I couldn't have coped with it sooner, so better now than never. So glad DD will have a sibling, and so glad I will not spend my later years wondering 'what if'.

I'd say - if there is no grave medical reason stopping you & the question is on your mind, then go for it - when the time is right. There are never enough reasons to have a second child but the regret of not having one can be haunting!

SnotandBothered · 08/08/2014 00:14

As an adult only, who was the daughter of a mother who is an only and a father whose siblings lived in Australia and never kept in contact. I can categorically say that I was not lonely growing up despite having no siblings, no cousins, no aunts - nothing, and I am a happy, confident adult who bears no grudge at being an only.

I have two DC born very close together and I can see the benefit to them of having each other, but it doesn't lessen what I had: undivided attention/love and the ability now to be perfectly content in my own company as well as my wide circle of friends.

It's not about being an only child, it's about the childhood your parents give you.

Do what feels right for your family.

Athrawes · 08/08/2014 00:24

If I was ten years younger then yes I would have another. But I am 44 and my only child has just turned 4 and I feel that the risks to mother and child are too high for me personally to take to try for another. I know that other people have healthy babies and pregnancies at 46+ but get narked when people suggest that I should take that route. Only I can judge the risks that I personally deem acceptable.
Yes, it would be nice for DS to have a sibling. It would be nice for him to live near his cousins. But regret is a very negative and often useless, unconstructive, limiting emotion and I try hard to be sucked in by the pressure from other people. But, as you can tell, I do get cross!!

Sassyb0703 · 08/08/2014 06:13

and again... stated in both my posts ..your decision to have an only child is your right. My point is made regarding those parents who choose lifestyle above having another. Wanting another and not being able to have one for health (mental or physical) age/infertility or because relationship troubles,is whole different situation. I was not being rude, I was expressing an opinion. A decision to have an only child is made by adults but the impact is on the child. As the relative of 5 onlies (2 now dead) I was making my point from the child's point of view that the sadness of not having siblings does not finish in childhood and can sadly last a lifetime. - and I don't mean in a wierd personality disordered way..just a wish that life had been different..probably why she had 5 of us Grin

CPtart · 08/08/2014 07:13

We too were unsure about having another but did so due to fear of regret, and it was the best thing we ever did. They are only 2.4 months different in age though and to see their relationship develop is my single favourite part of parenthood.

CPtart · 08/08/2014 07:15

2.4 years not months!

RainbowTeapot · 08/08/2014 07:25

We were only going to have one (difficult birth and not living in ideal circumstances.)

I was happy with this as we were so close, getting on well, didn't want to start again.

we.moved when she was nearly 2 and circumstances felt better. I wanted her to have a sibling although couldn't imagine how I'd love anyone else as much...

I had no 2 when no1 was v.nearly 3. To begin with in sleep deprived state I wondered what I'd done and could see how easy ot was for those with one.

BUT it changed at some point. No2 is 2.5 and the girls are S close as can be and miss each other if either is away. They will play in the garden/sitting room together all the time while I cook.etc and don't need me to entertain them. There is always giggles and laughter. They both twll me the other is their best friend.

For us 2 has been fantastic. And you really do love the second little one. Now theyve both got personalities its great to watch them play together. Having a second has improved life more than double.

RainbowTeapot · 08/08/2014 07:26

I think close to 3 years is the perfect gap. Id do that again of I had my time again :)

FleeBee · 08/08/2014 07:33

I am an only child of an only child mother. I don't have any issues with it & neither does my mother. I've enjoyed being an only & I love my own company.
My father had 2 brothers, one had a child but we aren't that close to my uncle or cousin. My other uncle died quite young without having children.
I don't feel I have suffered at all not having a sibling and I'm more than happy with how things turned out.

GoodboyBindleFeatherstone · 08/08/2014 07:49

My friend's 9yr old daughter HATES her 7yr old sister. Why assume that all children want a sibling?

I have a brother who I am quite close to now, we fought as children. He has issues from being an older child and I have issues from being a younger sibling.

My DS will probably have issues from being an only.

Damned if you do, damned if you don't.

MarlboroMary · 08/08/2014 07:53

Sorry, haven't got time to read the thread but in answer to your initial question I am grateful every day that I only had the one child. It wasn't initially planned that way, but by the time she was 1 I decided 1 was enough and have never regretted it.

She is 8 now and I'm positively thrilled I didn't have another. She gets all my attention and effort and is very well socialised. We ended up putting her in a private school which we could't have afforded to do for 2 kids. I'm so glad she's at the age where she can be more independent and there are no younger kids to look after.

She has several cousins and lots of friends, and her dad and I have very good relationships with her. I grew up with a brother I was never close to despite being close in age, I don't think a sibling is automatically a good thing. I think it's such a pleasure to have one child, it's a delight most people don't allow themselves because they think they should have another for the child's sake. That's really not the case, both dd and I have lovely lives and I'm grateful not to be run ragged with more kids.

I'm surprised at how many people nowadays have only children. It was quite rare when I was younger but I know so many only children and they all seem to be happy and doted upon.

FamiliesShareGerms · 08/08/2014 08:00

We were only going to have one for quite some time - DH was adamant, and I accepted that having one with DH was preferable to me having more with someone else.

Fast forward a few years , my bio clock started ticking wildly and DH realised that DS was the sort of child who would thrive with a sibling. We ended up adopting DD when DS was 5 and it was definitely the right decision for us to expand our family: almost as soon as she joined us we both felt complete.

LadyIsabellaWrotham · 08/08/2014 08:03

A social media friend announced she was pg when her DS was seven. Her follow up post started "I know a lot if you will be shocked.." And explained very openly that after 6 years of being absolutely adamant that they only wanted one child they'd quite simply changed their mind - it dawned on them slowly that they desperately wanted another baby/child. As far as I can tell they are now very happy with their new baby (toddler now).

Oneforthemummy · 08/08/2014 08:33

Fair enough Sassy, but your point doesn't just apply to those who choose to only have one child. Can you know for sure that your child wants a sibling? I know plenty of people with bad or no relationship with their siblings. Surely deciding you want another child because you want your child to have a sibling is also selfish?

dreamingbohemian · 08/08/2014 08:39

Sassy your comments are daft, sorry. Many many people are perfectly happy being only children, it's ridiculous to say parents who choose to have only one are harming their kids and just being selfish (unless they have a reason good enough for the likes of you).

I agree that if your mother is still upset about it at the age of 75 she has other issues going on. Really, having a child entails no more than 9 months of sacrifice? Okay.

RainbowTeapot · 08/08/2014 08:45

Having a second was definitely the best thing we've ever done. It simply wouldn't have been the same with just one in the end.

I think we were worried about things before that really weren't a problem. I certainly wouldn't want a child to feel "doted on." I expect id have over parented/been too intense with my first if id stuck to only one. Having a second has really broadened everyones life.

However to really is for you to decide in your situation. Not for others. Lots of people have one, regret it and so have another!others are happy with their decision.

which way arr you leaning? You could start a thread on the advantages of two if you want to hear more ?

trufflehunterthebadger · 08/08/2014 08:50

Never, ever regretted. We only ever wanted one, i am a singleton and i don't think it did me any harm. I'm very sociable, never felt the desire for any siblings. DSIL is on baby 3, her eldest is just 23 hours younger than DD, i never ever look at her and think i would like more. Actually seeing them cements our decision - my patience levels can cope with one. Fortunately DH feels exactly the same. I never feel broody over newborns, i don't really have the maternal gene !

It's not financial, if we won the lottery i still would not have any more. I just don't want any more !

trufflehunterthebadger · 08/08/2014 08:57

but I do worry for her being alone later

Having siblings is no bar to being alone ! My dad saw his brother for the first time in 15 years at christmas, my mum has 3 sisters. None of them spoke to her for about 5 years after my gradmother died (eldest aunt told lies about her) and she only sees one of them now about once every 6 months. The eldest is dead but they never reconciled for 15 years. She sees the second eldest around once every 3 years.

My cousins (3 sisters) don't speak to each other. Neither of my grandmothers saw their siblings other than at weddings and funerals. However they weren't lonely as they had their own families.

trufflehunterthebadger · 08/08/2014 08:59

you are making a decision that suits you but 9/10 does not suit your child nor, given the choice would they choose it

What a load of crap

freyaW2014 · 08/08/2014 09:04

My only child is 11 next month. It wasn't a choice, my relationship with her dad ended when she was a toddler and despite a few disastrous relationships have remained single ever since. I thought I was happy with one for years but last year I became really broody after several friends and work colleagues became pregnant! I am now 20 weeks pregnant with my 2nd child via sperm donation and I feel very happy with my decision! I feel like I'm 'completing my family' when I didn't feel I had a choice years ago. One child is great but for me there was always a little sadness I never had another, it just took 10 years to realise!