Please or to access all these features

Product tests

Here's where users test and review products and give their feedback. If you'd like to run a product test please email [email protected].

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Read Mumsnet users feedback on the Tefal Cake Factory Easy Cake Maker

44 replies

EllieMumsnet · 18/03/2019 14:32

This is the feedback thread for the 25 testers who tried out the Tefal Cake Factory Easy Cake Maker (RRP: £169.99). Testers used the Cake Factory in their normal cooking routine and could also try out some of the recipes that came with the product.

Here’s what Tefal have to say about the product: “Fed up of sunken sponges and soggy bottoms? Or your temperamental oven burning bakes? Then you’ll love Tefal’s Cake Factory. With this precision cakemaker, you can enjoy consistent, mouth-watering results without the stress. From crispy meringues to hot sticky toffee pudding and perfectly oozing chocolate lava cakes, no bake is too tricky. Five automatic programmes intelligently set the correct temperature and time for a range of sweet delights, completely taking the guesswork out of baking. For when you become confident in your baking, there’s a manual mode that lets you take full control and create your own signature bakes. Download the free app for inspiration, featuring over 200 easy recipes – including vegan, gluten-free and low-sugar options. Little helpers can even get involved thanks to its simple controls and cool touch handles, whilst its compact size makes it convenient to use and easy to store.”

Testers please answer the following questions:

  • What were your initial thoughts on the product (design, size, quality, documental guidance)?
  • Did you use the recipe book and if so which recipes were your favourite?
  • Did you face any issues using the product or do you think anything could be improved?
  • What type of cakes or desserts did you bake in your Cake Factory?
  • Where did you store the product when you weren’t using it?
  • Would you recommend the product to your family and/or friends?

Selected testers will be required to leave their feedback on a thread on Mumsnet and on the Tefal website. All testers who leave the required feedback will be entered into a prize draw where 3 MNers will win a £100 voucher (each) of their choice (from a list).

Thanks and good luck!
MNHQ

Standard Insight T&Cs Apply

Read Mumsnet users feedback on the Tefal Cake Factory Easy Cake Maker
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
moomoo85 · 24/03/2019 14:56

- What were your initial thoughts on the product (design, size, quality, documental guidance)?
My first impressions when it arrived where that it was smaller than I thought it would be. This was a good thing as it meant that it was easy to store and didn't take up the entire worktop when out. I was very impressed by the quality of the machine. You could tell that it was a significant piece of kit rather than some of the counter top kids ovens you can get. The silicone moulds were great and again you could tell from feeling them that they would last well.

I personally liked the bold colour of the cake factory. It fit in reasonably well with my kitchen which has lots of other bold appliances. However I can see that it might be a bit much for some people.
The instructions were really clear and setting it up was so easy.

- Did you use the recipe book and if so which recipes were your favourite?
I used the recipe book a few times but mostly used the app as I found it easier to find what I was looking for in it. I have done quite a lot of baking over the last few weeks with it and have tried quite a few.

My favourites were probably the chocoholics cupcakes, the chocolate vanilla marbled cake and the condensed milk cake. They were all really easy to make but also came out with a really nice texture.

- Did you face any issues using the product or do you think anything could be improved?

There is very little that I would change about this product. I found it really easy to use. In an ideal world there would be the capacity to also make cake in a loaf tin. But I understand that the main reason this can't be the case is the size limitations.

- What type of cakes or desserts did you bake in your Cake Factory?
I started off by following only the recipes in the book and on the app but once I got a feel for how it worked I was able to get out some of my cake recipe books which I haven't been able to use for years due to my rubbish oven. I was pleasantly surprised that it worked for all of them. My favourites were from the humming bird bakery book which included a blueberry cake, carrot cake cupcakes and dairy free chocolate brownies. I was able to make cakes for my group of friends from my baby group which went down really well.

I found the meringue setting really easy to use and was successful in making my first meringue.

- Where did you store the product when you weren’t using it? During this testing phase it has mostly stayed on my counter top as I have been using it so often. When not on the counter top it is on the shelf next to my blender.

- Would you recommend the product to your family and/or friends?
I have been. I have especially been suggesting it to my friends who would like to try baking but don't feel very confident in doing so. My husband has also been raving about it to his friends at work as he has been enjoying the cakes that I have made so much. It isn't cheap but it is a complex piece of kit so I think it is probably worth the retail price.

It has been lovely to test and it has got me back into baking including being able to start teaching my son to bake which is exactly what I wanted.

Read Mumsnet users feedback on the Tefal Cake Factory Easy Cake Maker
Read Mumsnet users feedback on the Tefal Cake Factory Easy Cake Maker
Jaspermcsween · 24/03/2019 16:50

I was delighted to be asked to test the Tefal cake factory and here is my review

  • What were your initial thoughts on the product (design, size, quality, documental guidance)?

I was pretty excited when I opened the box it came in. It was very well packaged .
The cake factory is very visually appealing . It’s a combination of modern and a bit retro. I understand the pink might not be to everyone’s taste but I love it .
It looks a bit like a very expensive toy. ( not too far from the truth - and who doesn’t like a toy? )
It is smaller than I expected. It feels very sturdy and well made and the inner silicone moulds are substantial and good quality.

The documentation took a bit of navigating on account of the different languages.

Did you use the recipe book and if so which recipes were your favourite?

Yes. From the recipe book I made fruit scones,carrot cake muffins and orange and cinnamon muffins. All worked very well . However the chocolate lava cakes were the favourites - amazing and ridiculously simple to make. Served with whipped cream they make a very impressive dinner desert.

I used it to make some of my own favourite recipes and they all turned out well.

Did you face any issues using the product or do you think anything could be improved?

No issues really. It’s very well designed and pretty much foolproof . It was a bit tricky lifting the hot baking tray out but a doubled up teacloth and a pair of washing up gloves did the trick .
The app was a bit odd. After typing in everything in my store cupboard it then came up with over a hundred recipes, most of which required additional ingredients I had not listed as available !

What type of cakes or desserts did you bake in your Cake Factory?

The ones mentioned above, plus a couple of my own recipes ( walnut coffee cake and an all in one chocolate cake ) . I would like to try making some savoury things in it.
I like the fact that it makes a smallish quantity of whatever. Things got baked, and then eaten!

Where did you store the product when you weren’t using it?

It’s still on the kitchen countertop ! It’s too lovely to hide away. I’m really very taken by it and it has recently featured in a couple of my dreams Confused
I will eventually make room for it in the pantry off my kitchen which could do with a clear out

Would you recommend the product to your family and/or friends?

Yes, and have done already. It’s quite expensive but would make a good wedding gift , or a special gift for a child who is just learning to bake .
There is something almost magical about putting the mix in cold, closing the lid , pressing the settings and trusting it to do its thing .
And it gave a perfect bake every time.

I have a list of people who want to borrow it before deciding whether or not to buy one.

Thanks to Tefal for giving me the chance to try it out.

NEWLEAF12 · 25/03/2019 18:20

Can you use self raising flour in the recipes instead of plain flour and baking powder my cake factory sponge is always heavy and dry

picklemepopcorn · 25/03/2019 18:24

I used self raising and didn't like it as much- possibly coincidence. I was surprised- they rose more than the plain plus baking powder

Notthebloodymustardcushion · 25/03/2019 22:40

What were your initial thoughts on the product (design, size, quality, documental guidance)?

I wasn’t keen on the colour of the cake factory, it’s certainly not an object that I would want on display in my kitchen, which poses a storage issue due to the size of the product.
There was a strong burning smell on first use, although this seemed to dissipate on further use.
The recipe book probably didn’t include as many recipes as I was expected initially, however, the app has lots to choose from, and I can see the App being very useful in the future! I have already seen new recipes added, so hopefully that will continue.
The cake factory felt very sturdy, came with some good quality moulds and seemed intuitive to use alongside the specific recipes.

  • Did you use the recipe book and if so which recipes were your favourite?

We used the recipe book to make the raspberry bars, and I used the app recipe to make the walnut brownies (We hate walnuts, so substituted for pecans)

The raspberry bars rose beautifully (see below pictures) and were nice enough, but nothing spectacular, I may add white chocolate next time to pep them up a bit.

The brownies, tasted INCREDIBLE, although the mix was a little dry/crumbly, more like a biscuit texture than brownie, so I will try to play with these a little going forward to see if I can improve on them. Perhaps more butter?

Sadly, due to ill health I was unable to attempt any further recipes as yet, however, I cannot wait to attempt some melting middle puds!

  • Did you face any issues using the product or do you think anything could be improved?

Burning smell (see above)
Please make it easier to remove the hot cake trays/molds after use, as this is a little fiddly with oven gloves.

  • What type of cakes or desserts did you bake in your Cake Factory?

See above.

  • Where did you store the product when you weren’t using it?

Utility room counter, as too large to store in my cupboards.

  • Would you recommend the product to your family and/or friends?

Honestly? Not at it’s current price point, I think if you already have an oven (as do most people) then the lack of quantity you can make in the cake factory is a huge downside for me, because if I were to make muffins/scones etc... then I tend to batch cook for the freezer, which would just seem faffy with the cake factory however for just a quick bake on a saturday afternoon, it’s quite a fun novelty. I could be persuaded to recommend however, on the back of potential future success with melting middle chocolate puds... Wink

Thank you for allowing us to test out this product, it has been enjoyable, and I suspect will continue to be so long into the future!

Read Mumsnet users feedback on the Tefal Cake Factory Easy Cake Maker
Read Mumsnet users feedback on the Tefal Cake Factory Easy Cake Maker
Read Mumsnet users feedback on the Tefal Cake Factory Easy Cake Maker
picklemepopcorn · 28/03/2019 13:51

Who is going tomorrow then?

Just looking up Windsor to see what else to do.

hanliying · 29/03/2019 20:39
  • What were your initial thoughts on the product (design, size, quality, documental guidance)? I love the design except for the color. It looks stylish and durable
  • Did you use the recipe book and if so which recipes were your favourite? I used the app on my phone. It is very easy to use as i can check all ingredient at home and follow its suggestions.
  • Did you face any issues using the product or do you think anything could be improved? No issues
  • What type of cakes or desserts did you bake in your Cake Factory? Banana break and chocolate cupcake
  • Where did you store the product when you weren’t using it? leave on the kitchen counter
  • Would you recommend the product to your family and/or friends? yes, especially for families with kids over 5 yrs old as it is great fun for them to participate
jamoncrumpets · 01/04/2019 15:32
  • What were your initial thoughts on the product (design, size, quality, documental guidance)?

Smaller than expected, looks a bit like a George Foreman, not sure why it had to be pink but at least it wasn’t super girly

  • Did you use the recipe book and if so which recipes were your favourite?

I haven’t used any of the books but I have used the app to make three different things. My favourite recipe is definitely the cherry madeira sponges - yummy!

  • Did you face any issues using the product or do you think anything could be improved?

I did notice a smell of burning plastic on first use. My first machine started showing an error message on the first use. I contacted the help number and we were unfortunately unable to get it working again. Tefal sent me a new machine.

  • What type of cakes or desserts did you bake in your Cake Factory?

Meringues, brownies, individual cakes and muffins

  • Where did you store the product when you weren’t using it?

On the kitchen counter.

  • Would you recommend the product to your family and/or friends?

Possibly, but I didn’t feel the performance was any better than a decent oven. It is perhaps more convenient, but it is also quite expensive.

HalloumiGus · 01/04/2019 19:09

I was gutted not to get selected for this so reading enviously!

akindredspirit · 02/04/2019 14:25

Delighted to have been chosen to test this!

  • What were your initial thoughts on the product (design, size, quality, documental guidance)?

I expected this to be larger than it is. I was pleased to see how compact and neat it is. The colour is very pink and reminiscent of childrens toys but actually it looks good next to my red food mixer and red juicer. The silicone cake moulds, metal baking tray and wire rack all feel and look quality items.
The recipe book being in many languages was rather thick and bulky considering how much was actually relevant to me. I thought there would be more recipes but those provided were a good mix of different bakes.

  • Did you use the recipe book and if so which recipes were your favourite?

Yes I did use the recipe book and our absolute favourite was Chocolate Lava Cakes. These were a great success and enjoyed by the whole family. The recipes were very easy to follow .

  • Did you face any issues using the product or do you think anything could be improved?

No real issues. I found the machine very easy to use. Results were very good and even. One slight problem was removing the tray or cake moulds from the baker whilst hot, but I mnaged with a teatowel rather than my bulky oven gloves.

  • What type of cakes or desserts did you bake in your Cake Factory?

I made the Chocolate Lava Cakes, meringues (very successful) scones and a plain sponge which I turned into a lemon drizzle cake. I notice that there are different moulds that can be bought as extras from the Tefal website. My grandchildren were particularly excited to use this with me and I let Rosie (11) have a go. She loved it and made the Raspberry Bars. (She was very impatient and wanted to lift the lid to see how they were doing!!)

  • Where did you store the product when you weren’t using it?

It sits well on the work surface next to my mixer and juicer. The cake moulds are in a cupboard below.

  • Would you recommend the product to your family and/or friends?

I would recommend it to friends and family who don't bake but would like to! It is easy to use and produces good results. It is particularly good for those with children as I found with my grandchildren who were all very keen to have a go.
I wouldn't recommend it for people who are already regular bakers as I feel it would be surplus to requirements.

sunshinestanley · 02/04/2019 14:31

What were your initial thoughts on the product (design, size, quality, documental guidance)?

The pink was garish and childish. A nice grey, or something neutral would be preferable.

It seems well made and sturdy. However, the colours on the lid make it seem as though only the small pink section on the top should lift up.

The handle at the back is handy but it would be better if there was some way to secure the lid for storage.

The interface is simple and easy to use. The booklets provided were okay although more recipes would be better. I did download the app though.

Did you use the recipe book and if so which recipes were your favourite?

I made a marble cake, the Italian crumble chocolate cake and the molten chocolate cakes.

Did you face any issues using the product or do you think anything could be improved?

Clip to secure the lid. Longer lead, though that could be because we have an old decrepit kitchen with very few sockets.

This might appeal to children but my own kids needed me to lift the trays out after melting butter and baking.

What type of cakes or desserts did you bake in your Cake Factory?

See above. I wasn't overly impressed with the marble cake and it seemed a bit of a hassle (separating egg whites and whisking and adding later). The Italian crumble cake asked for a huge amount of Nutella - 400g for a single traybake which was outrageous! I used half and the end product wasn't very nice (perhaps because I halved the Nutella...).

The recipes seemed to ask for rather random ingredients. White wine vinegar in a simple chocolate cake, almond flour, buckwheat flour and soya yogurt in banana bread etc. Stuff which I don't generally have in. There seemed to be an enormous amount of fat in some recipes too. Plus never any SR flour, just plain and baking powder. The recipe book and app did come across as French or American with the rather random ingredients.

Where did you store the product when you weren’t using it?

It stayed in the bench for a while, was eventually tidied to the cupboard and is now on the bench again. It's a large piece of equipment for what is essentially a fancy oven for cooking very small portions.

Would you recommend the product to your family and/or friends?

No. Far too expensive and I struggle to see what the advantage is over an oven. The immediate switch off and not needing to check the cakes was great, but £170 is way too much to pay for that convenience. It is too small so doing several batches just makes the baking process take longer than the normal oven. The App kept losing my fridge ingredients and was tricky to search. I'd rather have a better browse ability. More savoury recipes would be better.

Perhaps if you love a gadget and have more money than sense then yes, go for it. But it's a big no from me I'm afraid. Exciting for the first couple of tries then just a bit of a chew on.

picklemepopcorn · 02/04/2019 18:19

I can recommend the sticky toffee pudding...!

ScarletBitch · 03/04/2019 02:39

After reading all your reviews, I think I might treat myself to one. My 7 year old wants to make the Chocolate Orange Cake!

Myusernameismud · 03/04/2019 22:44

Gahhhh so late to the party, my original feedback didn't post! Lame rural broadband. Here goes.

What were your initial thoughts on the product? (design, size, quality, documental guidance)

Well, it’s very pink. That was a big drawback for me, because it makes me not want to keep it out on the worktop (I like things to match) and also because it’s a little unnecessary. I get what they’re trying to do, but I don’t like it. DS didn’t care, but some boys, and even some girls, might be put off by that. It’s an ok size, not too bulky and the smooth lines are aesthetically pleasing. Really good quality, I have to admit that I dropped it almost as soon as I took it out of the box, because I’m seriously clumsy but it suffered no damage. The enclosed instructions were clear and simple.

Did you use the recipe book, and if so which recipes were your favourite?

I made a few things from the book, my favourite was the chocolate lava cakes, although I had to reduce the cooking time slightly because the first batch weren’t gooey in the middle. I mostly used the app for recipes, I loved the step by step feature, and the fact you can start a timer on your phone from the app, so if I was out hanging washing in the garden I might not hear the cake factory beeping, I’d hear the timer on my phone in my pocket.
My only complaint is that some of the recipes were a bit over engineered. Amazing banana bread can be made with bananas, flour, eggs, butter and sugar. There is absolutely no need to add buckwheat flour and yoghurt. Again, I understand the thinking, but I’d suggest if the product is meant to be aimed at families, they might want to simplify a lot of the recipes. Tefal, if you're reading this, happy to help you develop your recipe book wink wink, nudge nudge.

Did you face any issues using the product or do you think anything could be improved?

Not really any issues, there was a funny burning smell on first use as others have said, but it dissipated very quickly. I do think there’s a lot of room for improvement in the recipes, both in the booklet and on the app. As I said above, a lot of them were overly complicated, and could so easily be simplified. They are also, because of the many ingredients, expensive to make.

What type of cakes or desserts did you bake in your cake factory?

I tried the giant cookie cake, carrot cake muffins, raspberry cakes, marble sponge and quite a few of my own recipes which, with a bit of tweaking of times/temps worked really well. I even made a quiche in it, which worked really well!

Where did you store the product when you weren’t using it?

Honestly, I left it out on the worktop because I have a lot of worktop space and not much cupboard space. I knew I’d use it much more if it was right there in sight. I’ve since binned off an old blender in a kitchen cupboard (and replaced it with my fancy Ultrablend, thanks Tefal!) and fit it in there. It’s compact so stores away neatly.

Would you recommend the product to family or friends?

Yes and no! There are certain people I would recommend it to, the type who love a kitchen gadget and I’d particularly recommend it to anyone who enjoys baking but feels like they don’t have the time (or they have an ancient and very temperamental oven, like me!)

But it's quite expensive, and although it's a good quality product I don't know many people who would just spend that on a product which is essentially single use.

Myusernameismud · 12/07/2019 09:37

@EllieMumsnet did the winners ever get drawn for the vouchers? I've been keeping an eye on winners corner but not spotted anything as yet.

EllieMumsnet · 12/07/2019 13:24

@Myusernameismud apologies the winners were: Theseptemberissues, jamoncrumpets & chilledteacher Smile

OP posts:
NEWLEAF12 · 01/09/2019 19:09

Has anyone tried to make the mini pear and chocolate cakes I'm sure the recipe is wrong my first disaster

PurpleCrazyHorse · 08/09/2019 20:07

Sorry no. It's only had sporadic use, mostly for chocolate lava cakes Blush

Myusernameismud · 28/09/2019 20:09

Well well, fellow testers. What have we here? Videos on the Tefal website, you say?

Sneaked up on me while I was scrolling through Instagram.

www.tefal.co.uk/cake-factory

Scroll right down.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page