Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Multicultural families

Here's where to share your experience of raising a child or growing up in a multicultural family.

Role of MIL

4 replies

Ailaba · 14/01/2022 11:00

Please bare with me this will be long, but I really need some neutral opinion. I am married to Pakistani and we have 2 daughters (4 and 1). My question is if it is really tradition that MIL has big role in raising grandchildren and most of the chores are up to her? Basically does she have bigger role in children's life and mother is busy with other things and not taking care of her children? Why I am asking this is that when our second daughter was about to be born my husband invited his mother from Pakistan to live with us for 9 months and "help", I was thinking that she would help with home chores like cleaning and making food etc., But it all ended with situation that my husband was taking newborn to his mother as soon as she started to cry and fuss and not giving me chance to calm her down. And as a result my daughter was not getting calm down with me only with them as I had problems with breastfeeding she was crying even at my breast. And when I was playing more with my eldest my husband was accusing me that I neglect and ignore my newborn. It all put me in a very bad mental state and I even started to think that my newborn hates me. When I was sharing and arguing about this with my husband he usually said that I am racist that hates his mother, crazy and imagining things because daughter in any case is at night with me so they are not taking over just trying to help because I am struggling and if I have any problems they will not even touch my children so I can do everything on my own. Yes I was struggling, but I also was struggling with my first daughter, but there I had chance to learn how to calm her down and meet her needs. Basically what they did totally shattered my confidence as mother. Things got better when they got Covid and were in a bad shape, so I was taking care of my both children alone.
After that things kinda improved I could take care of my children and they really were there just to help with children (all house chores still on me, his mother cleaned house only couple of times during her stay). basically it all just suck out all my energy, confidence (I was even afraid to go out with my youngest) and all the time under pressure that baby is crying because my husband was standing in the doors ready to take her away. I understand that it's my problem and I should have been more active, but I just couldn't. Than she left and things kinda got back to normal (not between us with husband, I am thinking that I should divorce him, but I am afraid he might take children away (he and his mother was telling me that they met with one of my husband's friends and he was openly encouraging them to take children to Pakistan because I am treating my husband very bad (it is true we have many problems and I am not proud of that) and it is easy as his brother has done it. Basically they were telling me that to show how "good" he is that he is not doing it (his word's). Now she is coming back and again for 9 or even more months and I am dreading it already. I am so stressed out about it and just paying out different scenarios in my mind. Basically what my husband once said when I shared that I don't feel comfortable to live with his mother for so long is that I "give up" too easy because my reaction was to "flee" mentally and try to avoid her by leaving room, place where she is. And that they are just there to help and that I have to accept cultural context it is how things are done in Pakistan traditionally, mother's leave their children to dadi and do their things. But I can't I just don't feel comfortable and I can't get over that experience that I had one year ago. And doesn't help that my husband is all the time pointing out that our second daughter is so outgoing and friendly with him thanks to that they both were taking care of her. My MIL is not evil or bad or anything, if have to spend short period of time with her she is pleasant woman with her weirdneses, but all of us has those, but I just can't live with her for so long time, I feel so much pressure when she is there, like she is always listening and judging (I know I sound crazy). I just don't understand how not to "give up" so easily.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Danikm151 · 14/01/2022 12:02

That sounds intense.
You’re not being racist by saying you want to parent your own child.
They can’t get away with threatening you to take your children to Pakistan, he would need the other parents permission.

It doesn’t sound like a marriage it sounds like a dictatorship

star8 · 14/01/2022 12:11

Google enmeshment. I am from a similar background, not pakistan but neighbour. Its quiet common for some men to be enmeshed with their mothers so much so that their wife is secondary.
However, it does not make it okay. Do not allow such long stays. It sounds like an absolute nightmare on elm st.
Also, if they see taking children to pakistan as a solution to problems, never ever let him take them abroad alone ever.

mediciempire · 14/01/2022 12:12

Definitely not the case in Pakistani culture that babies are just given to their dadi to look after the majority of the time but it isn't unusual to have relatives (in particular his mother) to stay in your house for months on end. I understand why you feel pressure with her being there for a long time but it is quite typical to have them stay with you.

Diggersaursarethebest · 14/01/2022 12:14

You need to assert that your cultural norms matter as much as his do. So if your cultural norm is that mum is the person with the most authority and who does most of the care for small children, then that matters as much as your husband’s cultural context that paternal grandmother is in charge. So yes, it should be a nice thing that your MIL who you don’t dislike or disrespect is involved in your children’s upbringing, but that needs to happen in a slightly different way than your husband is expecting because your cultural norms also count.
Practically, you should speak to a family lawyer about getting an official ban on your children leaving the country without you. Sorry I don’t know the legal terminology but it is possible to do this. The idea is the that if the kids are ever taken to the airport by their dad they won’t be allowed through immigration.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page