Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Money matters

Find financial and money-saving discussions including debt and pension chat on our Money forum. If you're looking for ways to make your money to go further, sign up to our Moneysaver emails here.

PRIVATE HEALTH INSURANCE: is it worth it?

13 replies

SpawnChorus · 18/08/2009 09:53

My dear old Dad has been paying for a BUPA policy for me (and more recently my family!) but is strapped for cash and can't afford it anymore. It's about £1700 per year for four of us.

We are totally brassic, and obv this is a HUGE amount of money to be spending on something "unnecessary". However, I have Crohn's disease and have recently been having a possible flare up. I'm pg so can't have any investigations until a month or two after the birth (i.e. until Oct/Nov). The policy will end in Sept, so I;m basically wondering if I should try to find the cash from somewhere to keep the policy going. Also, I'm guessing that if the policy lapses, I wouldn't ever be able to get cover in the future for my Crohn's disease (anyone know if that's the case?).

My greatest worry is the possibility of being denied life-saving treatment on the NHS. e.g. my Mum has breast cancer, and was given Herceptin (v expensive treatment) much earlier than she would have been on the NHS. I believe you are only eligible for Herceptin when your cancer prognosis is very poor and you only have months to live (or at least that was the case 5/6 years ago). My Mum was a "borderline" case but because she had private health ins she was given it. She's still clear of cancer (and is still on herceptin), and I have absolutely NO doubt that it's down to the fact that she was able to have it relatively early.

This is pretty rare, right? I mean if private health ins is just about swanky hospitals and getting your dodgy knee seen to more quickly then obv I would have no doubts about letting the policy expire. But if it's more of a life/death choice then erm...I might have to start planning my bank heist

Really interested to hear your thoughts.

OP posts:
StripeySuit · 18/08/2009 10:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SpawnChorus · 18/08/2009 10:16

StripeySuit - yes, I've also had v good experiences with the NHS generally, but it does worry me that just maybe you might get a luckier break with the life threatening stuff if you go privately.

That's prob a good compromise re ad hoc private scans.

OP posts:
SpawnChorus · 18/08/2009 11:21

Any more thoughts?

OP posts:
EldonAve · 18/08/2009 11:33

If you are brassic you may be better off paying directly for your own private care

SpawnChorus · 18/08/2009 13:33

Eldon - really? why? Does the current premium sound too pricey? It is for a family of four, not just for me. I haven't started looking around for cheaper policies (or an individual policy for me).

Or do you mean it might be better just to pay privately if/when I have a health problem, as per SS's suggestion? I suppose I'm just wondering how best to hedge my bets at the moment, as I do have a problem and I know it will be hundreds of £££ just to get it investigated privately, so maybe it's better just to cough up for the insurance. Hmmm.

OP posts:
EldonAve · 18/08/2009 14:36

No idea if the premium is pricey or not

Would you be likely to claim for more than £1700 of care in 12 mths?
What excess does the policy have?

Would you consider having your investigations done on the NHS?

SpawnChorus · 18/08/2009 15:25

Well the £1700 is for four of us. I need to find out how much it would be just for me I suppose. But anyway, for this year with my problem I think I could easily rack up £1700 in investigations. I would be perfectly happy to have them done on the NHS though.

However, my worry is that the investigations show up something awful (I'm thinking bowel cancer) and I could be in a situation like my Mum where she basically got v expensive treatment much earlier than she would have on the NHS, and has therefore got a much much better long term prognosis.

I can only hope that instances like my Mum's are extremely rare!

OP posts:
EvasMama · 18/08/2009 16:15

With a pre existing condition you may be covered with a new insurer (a 'switch') and get a cheaper premium. It all depends on whether you have had a claim in the last 12 months with BUPA and also if you have any claims pending.
If you have been to your doctor /consultant and he knows that there is a claim or flareup pending then he would have to disclose that to any insurance company when you claim - so you must be careful to keep cover continued.
(I speak from experience, having just shopped around for a new policy for me, with a pre existing condition)
Talk to a broker or talk to the different providers (Norwich Union, Axa, Pru etc.) who offer fully comprehensive medical insurance. Freedom Insurance is also an option (they do a cashback so you can get treated where you want, but there may be a shortfall)
Good luck!

EvasMama · 18/08/2009 16:17

just found the broker I used - Healthnetservices - 0800 999 08 999. It cant hurt to ask!

TheOnlyDailyMaleForMeisDH · 18/08/2009 16:22

I just switched our company scheme to a mutual group for which the premium is guaranteed for life regardless of age. It works by you having a pot of money which you invest in as well as paying a premium (which you draw out of to contribute towards a percentage of any insurance payout). But pre-existing conditions are very tricky. It may be worth talking to a broker - we used the Health Insurance Group.

SpawnChorus · 18/08/2009 20:19

That's really great info - thank you both!

I've spoken again to my Dad and we're going to probably go with the option of cutting the policy down to just me (not DH and the kids) for the next year. We're not sure yet how much cheaper it will be, but I'm sure it must be quite a bit less...He's offered to pay the year's premium and I can pay him back monthly.

If it's still too £££ for just me, then I'll definitely look into other cheaper insurers.

OP posts:
EldonAve · 19/08/2009 07:47

moneysavingexpert does 2 guides that might be useful
private medical

Healthcare Cashplans

EvasMama · 19/08/2009 09:59

Maybe keep the children on the policy so they have continued cover? it isnt usually massively costly (we were paying about £17 a month for our little one I think). Hope flare ups reduce and you have a happy time for the rest of the pregnancy

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread