Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Money matters

Find financial and money-saving discussions including debt and pension chat on our Money forum. If you're looking for ways to make your money to go further, sign up to our Moneysaver emails here.

£412

241 replies

headaches80 · 25/05/2023 22:33

Hello everyone.

I’m quite meticulous with budgeting.
mortgage rate has gone up again. I’ve just done my forward planning calculation.

After all bills/ direct debits/ standing orders (all essential stuff like mortgage, energy, c tax, TV licence, life insurance) I have calculated that we have £412 per month left.

This is for food, clothes, gifts, any school trips and unexpected bills. also to include petrol.

I’ve not included the insurance (car, home/contents) etc which I tend to get annually (I’ll cross that bridge when I come to it).

I spend around £30 a fortnight on petrol (getting to work). I downsized my car to pay for Christmas.

How are you splitting your £412 in my shoes? This is joint income, 2 adults and two teens. Both adults working full time.

I’m thinking

£200 shopping
£60 petrol
£40 unexpected/ school trips
£100 left over (will get eaten up no doubt)

its not a lot :(

I know I can sell stuff on Vinted. I don’t have loads of extra to sell and intend to save this option for use ahead of birthdays etc, I made £200 recently ahead of sons bday.

I’m thinking of ditching the TV usage (making licence fee not nec).

if Martin Lewis is correct, I’ll save 17% on energy bills. This will save me an extra £42.50

Any extra income streams or savings that I’ve not thought of?

OP posts:
headaches80 · 26/05/2023 21:33

SiobahnRoy · 26/05/2023 21:21

Council tax up by £160 a month? It is capped at 4.99% increase outs is £££ and has increased by £30 a month (to £295). The mortgage sounds unsustainable tbh and if it’s combined with an expensive council tax bill perhaps moving is a better option ?

Yes. That was a typo. It’s gone up £60/m, to £310 from £250, although I notice that the April payment was £318.34, I think the first payment if the financial year is always more. We don’t pay c tax in Feb or March here.

OP posts:
TheInterceptor · 26/05/2023 21:37

Could your husband earn more?

Tootootoot · 26/05/2023 21:37

As you say you live in a nice area - could you put one bedroom on airbnb and the teens share when you have a guest? Or get a lodger? Either way you can earn up to £7500 tax free per year doing this.

Watfrordmummy · 26/05/2023 21:42
Biscuit
headaches80 · 26/05/2023 21:45

VanGoghsDog · 26/05/2023 10:29

What?

My MOT is c£60 a year, insurance £240 a year, tax £110 a year, maintenance say £300 a year. Nothing like £300 a month!
I don't pay for breakdown cover, which I guess most people do.

Re the OP - I'm not sure why people can't just accept this is what she has left per month and help with the question she asked, rather than trying to pick over everything she had said. So what if she has a "massive mortgage" on a five bedroom house? Her choice. She's asking how you would allocate the left over money. If that question doesn't interest you, move on.

Personally I would use some of the "just on case" money in month one to shop in bulk, at Costco, or one of those Asian supermarkets. If the kids like pasta etc it's much cheaper in bulk. As is rice etc.

Also, places like B&M sell quite a bit of food and are sometimes cheaper, but you do need to do the research.

Where I live with have a community pantry, you have to be on the ball to get a slot, and it's not free, but it's stuff like four pints of milk for 10p, a tray of pot noodles for 30p, etc. They do also do hot meals but I'm not sure quite how that works. Search on Facebook for anything local to you.

Thank you for your response.

I’ve filled in some of the blanks for people. I’ll provide fuller details tomorrow as it’s all scribbled in a notebook for the last few months.

I actually did some market research (I signed up to a company but I think you can only participate once a year) and earned £160 in Amazon vouchers in January. I’ve been using this to bulk buy toilet roll, a bit like your COSTCO suggestion! I’ve about £40 left I’m my Amazon account :)

OP posts:
headaches80 · 26/05/2023 21:47

Tootootoot · 26/05/2023 21:37

As you say you live in a nice area - could you put one bedroom on airbnb and the teens share when you have a guest? Or get a lodger? Either way you can earn up to £7500 tax free per year doing this.

No private bathroom! But… will definitely do this if we still manage to be here when the children leave home! My brother in law is doing this at the moment and loving it.

OP posts:
PriamFarrl · 26/05/2023 21:53

headaches80 · 26/05/2023 20:28

A M3 teacher, paying tax, NI, pension contributions and student loan contribution takes home £1804 a month.

Just to add that I’ve been teaching for 15 years and my take home (no student loan) is about £2300 a month.

headaches80 · 26/05/2023 21:58

PriamFarrl · 26/05/2023 21:53

Just to add that I’ve been teaching for 15 years and my take home (no student loan) is about £2300 a month.

I’ve not been teaching £15 years.

I guess you’re on M5 or M6?

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 26/05/2023 22:09

I don't think it was unreasonable for people to surmise (correctly) that the actual issue (and therefore the best place to focus any solution) must be an extremely high mortgage. Sorry op, that must feel rotten. But I think your energies are best focussed on exploring ways to get that down.

UsingChangeofName · 26/05/2023 22:09

@AliceMcK - I did read what you'd written, but the thread was asking if the OP could feed 2 adults + 2 teens on £45 pw.
You then shared that you'd dropped £45 worth of food at the food bank - but that wasn't really relevant as the OP wasn't asking if someone could do a shop for a foodbank for £45, she was asking if she could feed her family, week in, week out, for that amount. To do which, you would need protein and lots of other things besides .

@headaches80 - people haven't been nasty on this thread.
You've come on and asked for help balancing your family's money. But then, people have realised what you've written doesn't balance with the figures you've talked about, so they've asked for more information so they can help you.
If anything, people have been incredibly patient, considering you've asked for help, but not been at all clear with the details of what you are asking for help with.

PriamFarrl · 26/05/2023 22:10

headaches80 · 26/05/2023 21:58

I’ve not been teaching £15 years.

I guess you’re on M5 or M6?

Sorry, that came across the wrong way. What I mean is that to be on M3 your take home sounds about right. It’s easy to see that with a large mortgage it could be a stretch.

Calmdown14 · 26/05/2023 22:20

Great you have a mortgage appointment booked. That is the crux of the problem.

Presumably you have paid a chunk off and the LTV has improved since you took it out?

Have you worked out the multiplier to your joint salaries now?

headaches80 · 26/05/2023 22:21

PriamFarrl · 26/05/2023 22:10

Sorry, that came across the wrong way. What I mean is that to be on M3 your take home sounds about right. It’s easy to see that with a large mortgage it could be a stretch.

Thank you. I thought that is what you meant but thought others might misinterpret.

Again, I’m not wanting a political debate, that’s not what this is about. I love my job. I’m sure you do too.

Education has relied on informal solutions for far too long. I didn’t mention teaching in my initial post for this reason. I added it to respond to the work more hours/ do overtime/ ask for a rise comments (which I understand, but there’s the answer). My comment was more to those that suggested I ask for a raise or complain… to who, I ask? My headteacher? He is in the same boat and actually worked out his hourly pay (hours actually worked) the other day! The current strikes are exactly teachers putting their foot down (at my school, no one went on strike as no one could actually afford to!)- hey, there’s my little ‘non political rant’.

I love my job. I’m not going to get a job at McD’s earning £13 an hour, even though I’d probably be better off doing so. I’d hate it and go mad.

This is about how I survive on £412 each month.

OP posts:
headaches80 · 26/05/2023 22:33

Calmdown14 · 26/05/2023 22:20

Great you have a mortgage appointment booked. That is the crux of the problem.

Presumably you have paid a chunk off and the LTV has improved since you took it out?

Have you worked out the multiplier to your joint salaries now?

We have a reasonable equity (mostly because we were gifted (by my mother) a sum to buy in the first place). It’s around 25% equity.

yes, a calculation of what we can ‘afford’, based on our income, comes in well below what we need. Yes, ironically, private rentals in the area would cost more (within the area we live).

I’ve done a few online calculators tonight.

I’ll put it all together tomorrow. Mostly to prove the horrible people wrong.

OP posts:
Alsobeyondshit · 26/05/2023 22:48

If op only gets £60 from a 6% pay rise that means she earns £1000 a month? Teaching assistant?

headaches80 · 26/05/2023 22:49

UsingChangeofName · 26/05/2023 22:09

@AliceMcK - I did read what you'd written, but the thread was asking if the OP could feed 2 adults + 2 teens on £45 pw.
You then shared that you'd dropped £45 worth of food at the food bank - but that wasn't really relevant as the OP wasn't asking if someone could do a shop for a foodbank for £45, she was asking if she could feed her family, week in, week out, for that amount. To do which, you would need protein and lots of other things besides .

@headaches80 - people haven't been nasty on this thread.
You've come on and asked for help balancing your family's money. But then, people have realised what you've written doesn't balance with the figures you've talked about, so they've asked for more information so they can help you.
If anything, people have been incredibly patient, considering you've asked for help, but not been at all clear with the details of what you are asking for help with.

Thank you. On the whole, you are right.

I wrote the post yesterday evening as I was in despair (having calculated June’s finances). I then went to bed and woke up to some of the replies. I was in a rush to get to work and focussed on the few negative (and, frankly, unkind and bitchy) responses.

When I got home (trying not to be political but this was after a 12 hour day) and read what has followed, I was pleasantly surprised that most were positive and helpful (hence my subsequent response).

I’ve had some excellent ideas that have already put me well on track to make some changes. I actually feel really excited about getting my daughter on board with this too.

My overwhelming gratitude to those that have offered support, kind words, solidarity and the help that was asked for. I appreciate the kindness and the positive/polite constructive feedback. I’ve had a couple of private messages too (mostly suggesting that some people seem to make a habit of kicking others when they are down and offering kind words), I’m appreciative of these.

To those shaming me, accusing me of lying and mocking, then shame on you.

OP posts:
headaches80 · 26/05/2023 23:36

Alsobeyondshit · 26/05/2023 22:48

If op only gets £60 from a 6% pay rise that means she earns £1000 a month? Teaching assistant?

Read my above comment.

We pay tax , national insurance and pension contributions on our salaries. In the months (maybe two overnights per year) that I’ve been able to do additional hours (weekend residentials), around 40% of my hourly pay has been deducted (for tax.NI and pension). THIS IS NOT THE SAME AS THE 40% FOR HIGH INCOME EARNERS. THIS IS THE WORKER BEING PAID 60% OF HOURLY RATE DUE TO (20% tax)….. PLUS….. DEDUCTIONS MENTIONED ABOVE.

OP posts:
AnOKYearForTheRoses · 26/05/2023 23:45

My estimation of £60/m increase if teachers get their 6% was an estimate. Don’t forget that tax, NI and pension also come out of any rise (to the person that said a £60 increase would equate to £1000/m salary). If my estimate was incorrect then I’m delighted

I hope you don’t teach maths.

A 6% increase on your gross salary will result in a 6% increase of your net salary, unless there are other implications such as a move in tax bands.

As an example, if you earn £2k/month gross and that works out as £1.5k net, your 6% will be added to the £2k and will result in a 6% percent increase on the net also- you’ll have 6% of the smaller amount (eg, the net pay).

Forgetting tax bands etc for a moment, if I told you I was doubling your gross pay, you’d expect twice as much money in your pocket because the net had also doubled.

NewNovember · 26/05/2023 23:51

headaches80 · 26/05/2023 21:45

Thank you for your response.

I’ve filled in some of the blanks for people. I’ll provide fuller details tomorrow as it’s all scribbled in a notebook for the last few months.

I actually did some market research (I signed up to a company but I think you can only participate once a year) and earned £160 in Amazon vouchers in January. I’ve been using this to bulk buy toilet roll, a bit like your COSTCO suggestion! I’ve about £40 left I’m my Amazon account :)

What company please?

headaches80 · 27/05/2023 00:03

AnOKYearForTheRoses · 26/05/2023 23:45

My estimation of £60/m increase if teachers get their 6% was an estimate. Don’t forget that tax, NI and pension also come out of any rise (to the person that said a £60 increase would equate to £1000/m salary). If my estimate was incorrect then I’m delighted

I hope you don’t teach maths.

A 6% increase on your gross salary will result in a 6% increase of your net salary, unless there are other implications such as a move in tax bands.

As an example, if you earn £2k/month gross and that works out as £1.5k net, your 6% will be added to the £2k and will result in a 6% percent increase on the net also- you’ll have 6% of the smaller amount (eg, the net pay).

Forgetting tax bands etc for a moment, if I told you I was doubling your gross pay, you’d expect twice as much money in your pocket because the net had also doubled.

I hope that YOU don’t teach maths. YOU are wrong. Albeit, not an exact calculation, (I’ll include that tomorrow). I’m pretty accurate in my £60 a month rise (after deductions).

OP posts:
headaches80 · 27/05/2023 00:05

NewNovember · 26/05/2023 23:51

What company please?

Message me and I’ll happily let you know

OP posts:
headaches80 · 27/05/2023 00:15

EllandRd · 26/05/2023 03:49

People on benefits have to manage an awful lot less

Rude

OP posts:
headaches80 · 27/05/2023 00:16

transformandriseup · 26/05/2023 05:07

I honestly can't see how OP is in this situation, we are on lowish incomes (less than a teacher) with one working 4 days a week and we have a lot more left over than the OP.

Rude

OP posts:
headaches80 · 27/05/2023 00:17

ThankmelaterOkay · 26/05/2023 06:07

So you both went to university 20 years ago? Aka no/low fees. You are late 40s, early 50s?

I don’t see how you don’t both earn £40k+. Unless you are paying insane pension contributions, your take home would be like £4000-5000.

A crazy drip feed is not going to go well here OP.

Rude

OP posts:
headaches80 · 27/05/2023 00:18

ThankmelaterOkay · 26/05/2023 06:40

It’s made up.

If it was massive, how’d they afford it? How did they secure it at their ages? how do they still have student loans in their early 40s?

Rude

OP posts: