Frazzled - yes, you’re right that fewer can retire in late 50s now. I mentioned that upthread when talking about this earlier. You’re right that it’s available to fewer people now than in the past.
But actually, it can still be achievable for some and that is more likely if they haven’t taken on large mortgages in their 40s and 50s and have paid off the smaller mortgages they had early on. I know a number of people, who have decent but not amazing jobs, who are currently in their late 40s, who will retire in their mid to late 50s. They are mortgage free because they have remained in their modest family houses and paid off the mortgages they had and have since squirrelled away large sums for retirement, plus often been in good public sector defined benefit pensions too, which will give a decent guaranteed income, which can be taken at reduced rate anytime from 55.
I’m not saying what they have chosen is right or everyone should be so if it, or that everyone can go down that route. Everyone has to make choices about what to do with their money and to decide if they want to be making spending choices which involve spending commitments far into the future or not, in conjunction with what they would hope for regarding retirement.
Early retirement will become less of an option as time goes on. Actually, a minority, but a decent minority will be doing it who are in their late 40s and early 50s now. Less will be able to manage it who are currently early 40s and less as time goes on. But I suppose my key point was that choices about mortgages (and I know not everyone has many choices in this area anyway) directly impact retirement. People don’t always think about the 2 in conjunction with each other. Smaller mortgages can be paid off earlier and have shorter terms, meaning that huge monthly outlay is ended, which is necessary for most people to retire.
Lots of people don’t have many choices about retirement vs house. For those who do, some will choose the bigger house and consequently need to work into their late 60s. Others will choose to stick with their smaller house, knowing it will mean they can retire 5 years or 8 years or whatever sooner. There’s no right answer, but there are often choices to be made.