So I drive a 2014 polo, tiny engine (1.2) and my car insurance is not going down 
36, passed at 17, did a pass plus and have 6 years no claims. I did have an accident in 2016 but TBH it wasn't cheap before then. In 2014 I lost my no claims as my car came with free insurance which didn't protect my no claims (I realised later..) and someone punched my car causing £1000 worth of damage. That's dropped off but they counted it as a fault because they couldn't obviously claim back off a pedestrian
Is it likely to be my area or how much I drive or... I would like a car with a bit more power in the future and my insurance is still coming in around £550 per year. I know that's not massively high but I'm driving a car with no acceleration capacity 
No convictions, never had a speeding ticket, clean driving license