Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Money matters

Find financial and money-saving discussions including debt and pension chat on our Money forum. If you're looking for ways to make your money to go further, sign up to our Moneysaver emails here.

Is it possible to split things fairly whilst keeping your finances separate? And if so, how?

3 replies

CatchaFly · 10/07/2017 15:38

My DP and I are about to “properly” move in together after almost 3 years and a 6 month trial run sharing a rented property whilst my house was renovated – which we will be moving into. We’re currently exploring ways to arrange our finances/split bills etc.

Potted facts: We earn roughly the same amount and have two DC each. Mine live with us although DS1 will fingers crossed be off to university in September. DSS and DSD, who are very similar in age to DS2 – they’re all in their early teens - stay every other weekend, whilst DS2 goes to his Dad’s every other weekend. DS1 is out and about doing his own thing most weekends, which may or may not include visiting his father or letting anyone know where he is at all. DP pays maintenance to his ex each month whilst I receive maintenance from mine. The maintenance my ex pays me is currently about twice that which my DP pays to his ex. Half of this will be being diverted to support DS1 at University though shortly.

Currently our plan is that DP will contribute a sum of money each month which is roughly equivalent to a third of the major household bills, with me paying for myself and DS2 - via his maintenance. (We've bundled the "not here all the time" children into one if that makes sense and taken them out of the equation.) We’ll then deal with any other shared expenditure and associated savings on an ad hoc basis. Personal bills like mobile phone contracts, clubs, boring tv sport channels etc will all remain the responsibility of the person they’re associated with. To us this seems fair, but I’d appreciate a sanity check.

I’ve seen many advocate a 50/50 or proportional split but we’re both firmly on the same page that each other’s children are financially the responsibility of their respective parents. We’re both cautious and independent people and have no plans to marry, or for reasons I shan't bore you with, to become formally financially intertwined with a shared mortgage or anything in the immediate future. This probably sounds incredibly unromantic, we're both quite long in the tooth and happy with this. However the spanner in the works is that the "powers that be" seem to have a different outlook. DP moving in will have a considerable impact on DS1’s maintenance loan next year which means the shortfall that this will cause will need to be made up. I don't expect anyone else to pay for my children, especially my adult ones, but the fact is that things will become much tighter for me. How do we accommodate this?

OP posts:
HipsterHunter · 11/07/2017 13:52

I wouldn't move in together just yet if it is going to make you or your son worse off.

Does the sum of '1/3 major bills' include any kind of rental payment?

Does that sum contribute more to the household than the reduction in maintenance grant takes away?

HipsterHunter · 11/07/2017 13:52

Have you discussed the impact on DS1s loan and does DP have any suggestions?

CatchaFly · 12/07/2017 16:43

Hi HipsterHunter. Thanks for replying. Yes I guess that 1/3 is a rental payment of sorts - it includes a notional "rent", utilities, council tax etc. but doesn't include groceries etc which we'll be dealing with in other ways. (I have a mortgage, but DP won't be directly contributing to that as it could have potential legal implications which I wish to avoid - for now anyway.) It's not been terribly scientific to be honest: we both had a figure in our heads as to what might be fair for him to contribute and they were the same so we went with that.

There will be a net gain in overall household income even after the decrease to DS1's maintenance loan is considered - although only just. I will have to make up the shortfall but what I'm not clear on is whether it is fair to expect DP to shoulder part of that increased outgoing - as clearly the government feels it is?

Our discussion around this has not got further than agreeing that it is daft system and should take into account what a person living in the house who is not a parent is actually contributing financially rather than what they earn. And that should include consideration for maintenance being paid for dependents living elsewhere.

We've waited almost 3 years to move in together, and I don't think either of us would want to wait another 4. I mean money is important, but we're not on the breadline so it's very definitely not the only consideration.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page