Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Money matters

Find financial and money-saving discussions including debt and pension chat on our Money forum. If you're looking for ways to make your money to go further, sign up to our Moneysaver emails here.

can Dell charge my card for a faulty computer?

5 replies

AitchTwoOh · 27/11/2006 11:41

by all means skip to the last paragraph, cos that's where the question really is...

i ordered a new laptop a while ago, waited in for it to be delivered (9-5, grrrr) and when it arrived it was frighteningly noisy, as if a component wasn't fitted properly. also the dvd player took ages to load.

so i emailed them to ask for a replacement. heard nothing back. emailed again. got a message saying that they could send an engineer out.

i told them i didn't want an engineer, but they insisted. i insisted right back, of course, that i get a replacement.

then i heard nothing, so i phoned. had a long conversation about the engineer again. explained again that i didn't want it.

then, (about a fortnight after i'd got the laptop) i phoned again and had another convo about the engineer, but the girl finally understood that i didn't want a fix, i wanted a new computer. she told me that i would have to wait another fortnight for a new computer to come out (i told her that was bad practice on the part of Dell, and hardly insurmountable but that i was nevertheless prepared to wait.

a fortnight later i wait in for a whole day, get my new computer but the bloke refuses to take the old one away. so i now have two computers.

a month after that i got an email asking me to phone a number to return the broken laptop. i didn't phone, too busy, plus i thought it was a bit of a cheek really. the next day they phoned me, telling me that i'ld have to wait in a whole day for the courier to pick it up.

i told them this was unnacceptable, and said that i had already been inconvenienced enough and that i would need to have a conversation with someone about some compensation or goodwill gesture before i was prepared to wait in another day.

she said this would be impossible and that Dell would just charge me for the computer if they didn't get it back. i told her i wanted to give it back, of course, but after someone had taken responsibility for all the inconvenience.

she asked me to write an email detailing my inconveniences, but i said that Dell should have a record of all my calls so it shouldn't be necessary, and that it seemed unfair to waste more of my time. then she hung up, but to be honest i got the feeling it was an inadvertent thing cos there wasn't any 'heat' in the conversation really and the line kinda clunked out...

anyway... i've emailed dell a few times since to tell them that i don't want their computer, but they still haven't got back to me.

SO, my question. i have given Dell permission to take money off my account for one computer. the second one came with an invoice that said 'no charge' all over it. so are they in a position to charge my card for a piece of equipment that they themselves acknowledge is not fit for purpose and that i have indicated i wish to return to them?

OP posts:
octobermum · 27/11/2006 12:05

If you have used a credit card - contact them and tell them that this in dispute with dell, they should put the charge on hold until its been sorted out.

I have to say when the company i worked for bought some computer and we had probelms with their customer service ie "crap" it was only wheni phoned and refused to explain what the probelm was again and demanded the name of the director who dewlt with complaints did i get a phone call and the probelm resolved within days after months of unanswered phone calls and emails.

Ellaroo · 27/11/2006 12:21

I think technically they are wrong to just charge your card when it was initially sent out as a 'no charge' item. Have dealt with Dell before and they are buggers, their call centre is a nightmare and the service rubbish. However, I can see why they want to charge you now - I do think if they've sent you a new one then you do have a responsibility to send their old one back. Could you not pursue compensation after you've sent it back rather than using it as ransom? - they have no guarantee that you would send it back even if they did compensate prior to this, so think you are unlikely to get anywhere until it is back with them. Good luck.

KathyMCMLXXII · 27/11/2006 12:34

Sorry to hear about this - I would not buy a computer from Dell again after my experiences with their customer service when I got this one (broken dvd when it was just about still under guarantee but they messed me about so much that by the time they'd admitted there was a problem it wasn't under guarantee any more - I was too busy to resolve it at the time so I just gave up and bought an external dvd drive from someone else)

I don't know anything about law or anything but it sounds to me like you are in a strong position re them charging you again (don't see how they can do this if the second one came with an invoice which said 'no charge') but you should make it quite clear you are happy for them to come and pick it up but at a time convenient to you - expecting you to wait in a whole day is not reasonable.
I imagine if you have records of you consistently saying 'yes you are welcome to come and pick it up but I can't wait in a whole day' you will be on strong ground. Don't expect you have much hope of any compensation, though.

AitchTwoOh · 27/11/2006 13:15

by compensation i really mean a copy of some anti-virus software or one of their other free gifts, so i don't think it should be too difficult.
i'm not really holding it ransom, they have already missed an opportunity to pick it up, i just want someone to acknowledge the hassle they've put me to, and if nothing else to apologise.
i'll contact the bank...

OP posts:
AitchTwoOh · 27/11/2006 21:42

bumping in case any financial experts are watching i'm a celebrity get me out of here and idly MNing.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page