Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

MN book swap clubs

Join our Book Swap forum to share and exchange your favourite books.

An Excuse for a Nice Sit Down and a Glass of Something: Lunavix's book

5 replies

CocoDeBearisCocoDeBear · 02/02/2008 20:12

...

OP posts:
lunavix · 04/02/2008 19:16

hey don't know if this book will be everyone's cup of tea but I didn't think it was mine either, both before I read it and after I read it the first time.

It's part of I believe an 11 part series, (think I'm on part 10!) and it's just fantastically well written. There's a few parts that made me go 'eeeeek' with some very touchy subjects, however... still enjoyed it.

FlossieT · 22/02/2008 13:13

I finished this a little while back but have been dithering about what to say here!

This was a good read (and needs to be, at 600+ pages!), but I found the violence too much, TBH - I am really feeble about that sort of thing. Villains are not just evil - they are the purest, most distilled form of evil you can think of, which I found a bit too disturbing. It also took a long time to get going - the first chapter is really pacy and exciting, but then it's about 100 pages more before things really crank into motion.

What he does really well is to get you to really care about the central characters, which is what makes you want to stick with it through its more uneven moments. It was a real pleasure reading something with such a sympathetic male protagonist. His female counterpart feels a bit underwritten, but then if you got too close to her, I think that would distort the overwhelming impression you need to retain of her particular power.

I don't think I'll be reading the rest of the series, but I'm not sorry to have read this one! Interesting pick, Luna.

rosmerta · 28/03/2008 16:27

Have to say, I really couldn't get into this & had to give up . I did try but its just not my cup of tea.

& its my 2nd attempt to read it now!

Sorry lunavix

squilly · 09/06/2008 21:59

I read this once before, a long time ago now...I've read up to the 10th or 11th book (I'm not sure what the last one was) and I must say I lost interest part way through the series and ended up reading them only because DH had bought them me for Christmas. They hooked me back in towards the latter part of the series again though. I think I just got a bit cross with the main character being so horribly tortured all the time. I know some people are unlucky, but this guy really does seem to take the cake!

I remembered the book having more humour too, so it was shocked to find it so serious and dark right from the beginning.

I also found the style a little hard to adjust to after having moved away from sci-fantasy for a while. BUT...after the first chapter I got engrossed again and really enjoyed re-reading this.

It took longer than I thought to read. It's quite a best of a book...and it was quite shockingly violent. I found the section where he turns the child against his parents particularly horrifying, then remembered that this wouldn't have affected me last time I read this as I was not a mum at the time. It seemed to have parallels with what can happen in the world if your kids get involved with 'wrong type'. Perhaps that's a bit gloomy but I did have PMT when I read it!!!

I think Goodkind's real strength is his compassion for his characters and the way he draws them so intricately. I agree the heroine is less well sketched in this first book, but it is for effect. And the 'will they, won't they' tension in this first book is quite fascinating too, particularly if you've read the following books and know where it's heading. You still find yourself willing them to get together. It's a bit like Ross and Rachel in friends, but perhaps a little darker!

I also like the way this kind of book threads different story lines together, till you end up with a blanket of multicoloured patches, sometimes a little disjointed on their own, but knitting together to make a grand, beautiful, piece in the end.

I am really pleased to have read this book again after so many years. It was almost a guilty pleasure...and I rarely read books more than once, so I've been surprised by this.

I got different things from it now than I did when I first read it, which just goes to show an old book can teach an old dog new tricks.
The resonance of the story differs with the passing of years and the changes in the reader can often affect the way the book impacts. Perhaps now I'll have to revisit a few more of my old books and see just which ones still hit the mark!

Thanks Lunavix....nice choice!

FlossieTCake · 07/07/2008 17:20

Not sure if lunavix is on here much at the mo but just to fill in - initial for this book are:

W F R

New posts on this thread. Refresh page