I’ve only just seen this thread so apologies for the late input. I feel it’s important to help each other through the problems with progesterone, there are so many women out there who are intolerant and being let down by health professionals.
I too had an horrendous time on Utrogestan and I have no history of suicidal thoughts or mental illness, it was absolutely awful, I didn’t want to live, my husband was so worried.
I’ve since seen a menopause specialist and I’ve tried all sorts of regimes and every time the progesterone buggers me up, I love estrogen though. So eventually I’ve plumped for Tridestra, 3 months on an estrogen tablet followed by 2 weeks on a progesterone called medroxyprogesterone, it’s one of the lesser androgenic ones, this is the only regime I can cope with. You have a withdrawal bleed after the progesterone phase and then it’s back to the estrogen.
I’ve tried taking medroxyprogesterone every day with estrogen so I don’t have a bleed but after a couple of months I start to feel unhappy, anxious, weepy, panicking, unreasonable, you name it, absolutely bloody awful.
There’s another continuous HRT called Femoston which also has a lesser androgenic progesterone. I’ve found that a short burst of progesterone is all I can tolerate. It’s taken nearly 4 years to get sorted, but without the estrogen for me my life was pretty miserable.
I hope this helps you with your journey through the HRT maze. All the best 😬