Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Local

Find conversations happening in your area in our local chat rooms.

Looking for views on York (city and schools)

6 replies

DadManners · 12/07/2021 17:51

Hi all. We are considering a move to York, and I'm hoping some current or former residents can answer a few questions and help us to get a balanced view on the city/area, including schools.

From what I've read online so far, the consensus seems to be that it's a very likeable, friendly, compact city, plenty going on, good schools and some really nice areas to live, but that means expensive property and being besieged with tourists, students and nightmare traffic.

So my first question is... just how bad is that traffic, and is there anything that makes it especially worse than your average city traffic elsewhere? Are there any notorious traffic blackspots to be aware of? Is the tourism really a nightmare, and what about race days?

As regards property, it definitely looks a good bit dearer in general than where we are currently in the Midlands, but then when I factor in the school catchment premium for both areas, the differential actually shrinks quite a bit. Then there's the issue that the housing market has gone a bit crazy recently, so we'll see if or how much that calms down.

So getting a bit more specific, we have been looking at Archbishop Holgate's School as a strong possibility and would therefore want to live within reasonably easy reach of that area (Badger Hill / Hull Rd). Catchment may not be a big issue as I'm assured we should qualify for a foundation place, so in that case it would be more a factor of what's available and affordable.

I know the inevitable question is what our budget and requirements will be, and I can't answer that yet as we've got more work to do on the figures (mortgage affordability, valuation on current house etc). But ideally, we would prefer somewhere not too urban (or flood-prone!), with easy access to countryside walks, as long as it's not a major trek to get to school or into town. Dunnington looks like one place that might suit us nicely and Heworth also looks a good (if pricey) option, but I'd be interested to hear any other suggestions, and whether there are any particular up-and-coming (or down-and-going!) areas to watch out for. I wouldn't rule out other villages if the commute is bearable.

Speaking of commuting, the work situation is still a bit up in the air just now and whilst we're hoping to continue working from home most of the time, there's still the possibility of needing to travel into town and can't rule out a commute into Leeds for one of us, so I'd be interested to hear people's experience on that front (and obviously this could influence our choice of area, once we have a clearer idea on the work front).

Just going back to schools, we're still keeping an open mind so would be interested to hear any feedback on AHS or the other secondaries, but also on primary schools as we would expect to be moving in time for DD to start Y6 in our new location. I've had a good look at the school performance data already, so now I'm really interested in building up a more rounded picture of the schools (hoping to visit some in Sep/Oct) and what the parents and children think of them. The Ofsted Parent View surveys are a good resource in principle, but the availability (and age) of results is actually quite patchy, so the more feedback we can get here, the better.

Last point is just to say that if any other specific pros and cons spring to mind about living in (or near) York then we'd love to hear them, warts and all!

Thank you in advance.

OP posts:
DadManners · 12/07/2021 21:50

p.s. Tang Hall seems to be derided by some, defended by others - is it really that bad?

OP posts:
mayblossominapril · 12/07/2021 21:57

I used to work in york and the traffic was horrendous, still is. I find the streets too crowded to want to go and shop there, it’s my nearest city.
Schools, I don’t know about the state schools but the private ones are good.
I would try and visit a few times, especially on race days to really get a feel of the place. I’m biased against busy places as I grew up in the middle of nowhere!
There is plenty to do in and around york and the city has a nice vibe

mayblossominapril · 12/07/2021 21:58

Most people I know who live in york cycle a lot as it has great cycle paths and really good public transport

DaisyWaldron · 12/07/2021 22:13

Most of the secondary schools in York are very good. I live in the south of the city, so most of the children I know go to Fulford, Archbishop Holgates, All Saints or Millthorpe, and I would be happy for mine to go to any of those schools. All Saints has a good rep for creativity, Archie's is more structured but both are also known for good pastoral care, Millthorpe is a bit more laid back, Fulford has more of an emphasis on academic stuff, but they all do well for a wide variety of children. Friends whose children go there also have very good things to say about Huntingdon and Manor. Some parts of York are in the catchment of Tadcaster Grammar, which is also very good.

Estate agents tend to call the nicer bits of Tang Hall "Heworth", even though they mean the streets off Fifth Avenue. I know several people who live there, and they seem happy there and have bigger than average gardens for their house size.

If you are thinking of living in one of the villages with a teenager, check the bus timetables. Regular buses will make the difference between independence and constant lifts, as will good cycle routes.

BirdIsland · 13/07/2021 07:59

I live in York and work in Leeds. I walk to the station and get the train, it's roughly an hour door to door. The train is quite expensive though.

There are very few 'bad' bits of York, but strangely those I would avoid are rarely spoken about - Tang Hall is generally fine, although the Heworth side is definitely nicer. I would genuinely avoid Bell Farm, also Pottery Lane, and parts of Chapelfields.

Huntington and Archies are good schools, Fulford is very good. Dunnington is a nice little village (and I think Fulford catchment) but obviously it's a bus to school as opposed to walk. Huntington also a nice place to live. I don't know much about Badger Hill but haven't heard bad things so that's probably good. I know friend who lived there as students so probably keep that in mind when viewing houses - who lives next door!

The traffic is bad. But you get used to it. As PP said, walking or cycling are good options. Tourism is fine, not an issue at all, and actually quite nice to see people enjoying your home town.

It's a really lovely city, I feel lucky to live here.

DadManners · 13/07/2021 10:22

Thanks everyone, lots of useful tips there. We'll be visiting in due course to get a better feel for the different areas. Definitely sounds like it's worth planning to avoid driving wherever possible and walk, cycle or catch the bus, which should suit us fine.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page