Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Local

Find conversations happening in your area in our local chat rooms.

School place in Cambridge not given to sibling - appeal process

8 replies

annacambridge · 18/05/2019 14:12

Hello all!

I am here to kindly ask your opinion/expertise on the following: our family has moved to Cambridge and we have two children; one was given a school place at our school of choice and will start reception this year; the other one needed an in year transfer and was not given a place at our catchment school (where his sibling got a place) but instead he was given a place at a school considerate "inadequate" by Ofsted.

We are obviously not happy with the situation, specially because we have chosen our address in Cambridge close to our school of choice because it had (and has) places available at my older child year group. School say they have places but due to a child with special needs they are not taking new children. School is also aware that a sibling was offered a place, but said no to my other child. We have appealed to the decision and we were given a date to attend the appeal panel.

Should we take someone to this appeal panel? What are the chances my child would be accepted, given our situation? Is it a bad start to have to challenge the school before my children start? Any info is very welcome.

My older child is confused and upset that his brother has a place at the school and that we can't tell him the same; we try not to go into details, but the reality is that he's keen to know which school he is going to and why he is not going to the same school as his brother... small things like buying uniforms are now a source of anxiety to my son and all the family.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Teddybear45 · 18/05/2019 14:15

The special needs of the other student might be signficant behavioural issues and they might be in your older child’s year — in which case the inadequate school might actually he the better option. Can you get more information behind the rejection? Maybe meet the head before you appeal.

annacambridge · 18/05/2019 14:41

I appreciate your message @teddybear but it's essential for us as a family to have both our children at the same school, we may wait for the older one to be offered a place or have a place allocated after the appeal.

OP posts:
LikeDolphinsCanSwin · 18/05/2019 14:43

Post in Primary Education. There some awesome admissions experts there.

TheVandalsTookTheHandles · 18/05/2019 14:44

I appealed for my daughter when she didn't get into same school as sibling (both out of catchment at time of applying and when my older son got his place they allowed in 10 more than usual ) we went to the council at shire hall in Cambridge and won the appeal. The retired head mistress who decided the out come was amazing and totally on our side. She even told the council officer off for not offering our daughter a place! So in your position I would definitely appeal.

annacambridge · 18/05/2019 14:54

thanks @LikeDolphinsCanSwin I will do it!

thanks @TheVandalsTookTheHandles. We have already appealed and had our appeal panel booked at the Shire Hall. Should we go husband and me? Or would you advise us to take an expert with us? How long is the panel and how formal? Do we need to explain our situation or the decision maker would have read all the support documentation and do a quick hearing before deciding? How was your relationship with the school afterwards? Any input helps as anxiety grows...

We will decline the school place offered at the "inadequate" school and will think of hoe schooling until we have a decision on the appeal (hopefully in our side)

OP posts:
Helspopje · 18/05/2019 15:01

Currently the child with the place is not yet on the roll. When he joins in September your older child will become top of the wait list for a place in his year.
The yr place for sept is not ‘now’ so they haven’t placed them at different schools iyswim

TheVandalsTookTheHandles · 18/05/2019 15:52

Just me and dh went. Lasted shouted 30 minutes I think then we had to leave the room while they made their decision. We just put our case forward that the admissions team had let 10 extra kids into an already oversubscribed school for my son's year so why couldn't they go over by one this year? We had details of the over subscription criteria eye with us. Also stated how difficult it would be to have 2 kids in 2 different schools. And the head mistress agreed with us! Wasn't too formal at all.

TheVandalsTookTheHandles · 18/05/2019 15:54

Sorry for typos. The relationship with the school has been fine. Its really out of their hands and up to the admissions team.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread