thanks climategirl & Bidwells your replies have been very interesting to me too - & no I wasn't putting too much store on a short conversation between 2 DCs in A&E, it did initially put me off, but I was more surprised our friends DD wasn't sent there, as was always intended by her Teacher Mum -
reading this thread & looking into the 2 local catchment Schools has made me think again, not least because another friends older & once also very academic, model pupil DD went off the rails on hitting Senior School & the support just wasn't there in a way that worked, the same Mum is now also looking at BC for her younger DD
& I've got to admit, though Private Ed doesn't really appeal to us as such, (all our own personal private Ed friends have wasted their Education :( & none have ever really worked & generally have a very entitled attitude
) but we also realise that things have changed since myself & DH were at School, a lot more distractions & less Teacher power, so we are still seriously considering BC, I really like what I see on their website, again see happy polite DCs coming & going from there, we've a few years to decide, but reading your 2, far more experienced posts has helped a lot