Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Living overseas

Whether you're considering emigrating or an expat abroad, you'll find likeminds on this forum.

Germany: 1st year Grundschule homework experiences, please, I'm tearing my hair out!

29 replies

TheKitchenWitch · 19/01/2014 12:18

Ds started Grundschule in September last year and has been enjoying it and (imo) getting on well.
We have the first parents' evening coming up at the end of this month and one of the things I need to discuss is the issue of homework.

His weekly school hours are:
Mon, Wed, Fri: 8.00 - 11.20
Tues: 8.45 - 3.30
Thur: 8.00 - 12.20

He gets homework every day except Tuesday (when they have Ganztagsschule). Homework consists of 1 x letters/writing, 1 x maths and 10mins of reading.
The school says each of the first two should take 15min each, so an ideal total of 45mins homework a day.

First of all there is no way that my 6yo can complete the writing homework in 15mins, not because it's too hard or too much, as such, but because the level of perfection required. We've had lots back saying "letters are not exactly between the lines" etc. I always check his homework, and often watch while he's doing it, and tbh to me it's been absolutely fine, I wouldn't have thought twice about it. If on occasion he does something obviously wrong, I tell him and he corrects it.

The maths - this is probably more doable in 15/20mins, but only if ds concentrates totally and completely and doesn't get even a bit distracted for a moment...which I'm not sure is entirely realistic at this age, is it? What I mean is that for him to complete a whole page of sums takes longer than 15mins not because he's working out how to do them but because he's not entirely concentrating and totally commited to the idea of getting the homework done :o

Altogether, with the 10mins reading, he absolutely can't get it done in under an hour, and it's usually quite a bit more than that.

What do we do? If he doesn't finish it, he either has to finish it as school the next day (he says in the Pause, which I totally disagree with) or brings it home again...which means we have even more to get done.
How hard can/should I push him? It seems like so much to me, and I don't think it's right that the supervision of eg whether he's doing his letters right or not is down to me (that's what the teachers are for).

Am I just being naive? Is this just the way it is here and we have to do it like this? But then again, i'm not prepared to accept daily battles and struggles over this - how can I make him do it faster AND better? And isn't 1 - 2 hours homework quite a lot for Erstklassler?
I've talked to other friends here and have heard very similar stories, so it's not just us. There are a few whose dc zip through the homework and complain that it was so little, but they seem to be more the exception :o

Sorry this has been so long, but I'd really appreciate any tips or advice or just shared experiences. TIA :)

OP posts:
HeinousPieTrap · 27/01/2014 09:22

hello- we're in BW too, I have one in 1. and one in 4. Klasse. We're pretty new to this…

They do get homework, but I was told DD1's shouldn't take longer than 45 mins, and DD2's not longer than 15 mins. They do get homework very day pretty much, but obviously it's not too onerous. Also if it were taking longer than the time, I was told I must come and see the appropriate teacher.

This is different to Brandenburg however, where we were before - DD1 didn't get any homework at all there really - just occasionally the lyrics to a song she should learn or something quite laid back like that.

They always finish by 13.05 at the latest. They do homework after lunch (obviously helps I'm a SAHM!) and then they know they can go out to play with their friends or watch telly or whatever, so seems to work OK.

I hope you can work it out with your DS. Seems to me it can't be just him who would struggle to do that much sitting down homework aged 6 (not saying it's impossible of course, just that I can imagine many would find it hard - my DN would for instance!)

TheKitchenWitch · 27/01/2014 13:08

Well, I had the talk with ds's teacher today and was pleasantly surprised :)
We discussed the homework issue and agreed that while we should obviously aim to get it all done, as neatly as possible, within the right time, she didn't want him sitting there for hours getting frustrated either, so I should just make sure he was making a proper effort, and if that meant less got done then so be it. Or, he could whizz through it but then also had to understand that if it wasn't neat enough, he wouldn't be getting a smiley face that time.

She didn't seem to have as much of an issue with his not concentrating as his maths teacher does - she (the Klassenlehrerin) said that he did daydream a bit, but reminding him to get on with it seemed to do the trick, and he seemed to have no problems keeping up with what was going on. It was altogether a very positive review of his first half year!

Shock at MrTumbles 3 - 4 hours of homework a night!! That is imo totally unacceptable. Children work at a different pace and schoolwork should take that into account.

OP posts:
HeinousPieTrap · 27/01/2014 13:51

oh that's great to hear KitchenWitch! Sounds like he's doing great. I have a DD like that, bit of a dreamer… hopefully they're thinking great thoughts Wink

We've got ours next week, hope it goes as well as your Ds's has!

MrTumblesBavarianFanbase · 27/01/2014 15:22

It doesn't here though does it kitchenwitch ? That's just how it is. In all honesty it wasn't so much the pace as the dreaming... should she have been allowed to lag further and further behind because of daydreaming rather than ability? It was a stressful yearbut for now she's back pn track - and not 6 months behind as she would have been if she had been left to work at her pace and not had to keep up... it eas hard at the time but not clear cut that it was wrong.

As she was home by 11.45 she'd have lunch and outdoor time and still be done by 4.15 even if dhe did homework for 3 hours, but the problem was all her friends started ringing around at 2pm to arrange afternoon play, so she'd miss out if not done by then..

New posts on this thread. Refresh page