Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

What was your experience of Jury Duty?

12 replies

Hyppyb · 04/01/2024 19:35

Hey,

I was wondering what was your experience of Jury Duty? How long was it? What's the waiting around like? Did you find it traumatic?

OP posts:
MissIndecisive2023 · 04/01/2024 19:37

I've been called up twice. The first time I had 2 short (2 day each) trials. Neither were traumatic. The second time (during covid) I wasn't chosen on day 1 so was released for the rest of the 2 weeks.

Take a book/phone and snacks! I didn't find the waiting too bad but I don't mind my own company! Sometimes if they know you aren't going to be needed that day or for the rest of the day etc they send you home early so you aren't always waiting around all day.

Itsnamechange · 04/01/2024 19:41

Probably not that helpful as mine was Sherrif Court rather than High Court (Scotland) so it was a fairly quick case. I was there for 2 days. It was an assault case. Not traumatic because the woman wasn't left with serious injuries afterwards. Having to call every day that week before I was taken was annoying but otherwise there wasn't loads of waiting around.
I'm probably a weirdo as I'd like to do jury duty for a more involved case. I found the procedural stuff fascinating.

Velvetbee · 04/01/2024 19:43

I served 11 days on a trial for multiple historic rapes. It was moving and fascinating. I felt very proud to be part of it. There was a lot of sitting around though.

thelongarmofthelaw · 04/01/2024 19:46

I was called for jury service in 2022 - I served for about a week and a half around the time of the Queen’s jubilee.

if I’m honest, it was one of the most difficult things I have ever had to do. My case was a violent one - rape and false imprisonment, and gbh against two separate women, over a short space of time; the defendant had only been out of prison for a few weeks when the first event took place.

he was an utterly nasty piece of work, and I found even being in the same room as him challenging. That said, he tried all sorts of delay tactics, and shenanigans in the hope of getting a mistrial. The judge was very strict with us and I later learned that it was because it wasn’t the first time they had attempted to prosecute. With all of his silly games we probably only heard 2-3 days of evidence in total, and there was no defence (he represented himself and refused to say anything when he got the chance).

the thing I found most difficult was that you cannot talk to anyone about the case at all until it’s over, and some of the testimony was harrowing. Those poor women were really put through the wringer and I was generally appalled at the way they were humiliated in questioning.

we didn't have to deliberate for long and then we heard just how dangerous he is to women. He was given a long sentence and not eligible for parole, but from his attitude I don’t think he is capable of rehabilitation.

it’s funny - I was thinking the other day that if I’m called again I’m sure I would be pretty anxious.

whateveryousay · 04/01/2024 19:47

I served two weeks last year and was on the jury for two cases. I loved the whole process, found it fascinating. Neither case was traumatic for me.

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 04/01/2024 19:48

I found it fascinating. I did two cases, one attempted murder (more dramatic than it sounds) and one arson. Both pretty straightforward so took about a week each I think - it was over 20 years ok so memory hazy!

I wasn't fussed by the waiting around, there wasn't that much of it really. We got sent out to our break room a couple of times while the lawyers and judge went over technical legal points, but there was a coffee machine and magazines, I think I had a book, so no issue. A few times we finished for the day mid afternoon and got sent off early, or told we weren't needed until mid morning the following day. I was 18 and working in a call centre so the compensation I was getting was equivalent to my wages, but for far fewer hours, so I was pretty happy.

NahHumBrag · 04/01/2024 19:52

I sat for a month on a complicated rape case. Three weeks for evidence and then we took 5 days to deliberate. It was extremely stressful and traumatic for us all.

Gumbo · 04/01/2024 19:53

I honestly thought I'd love it and enjoy sending someone dodgy to prison. As it turned out I found it really upsetting which surprised me! I felt very sorry for the poor fellow who was guilty, as he'd done something stupid (but very understandable), and was something that many people might have done.

Lots of hanging around pointlessly waiting for something to happen when not in court or the jury room though...

SpikyHatePotato · 04/01/2024 19:55

I was called for a fortnight and ended up being discharged for the second week. Which was quite annoying as I'm self employed and had turned down work, and it was too short notice to pick up anything else. At least when at the court, I got paid (a bit).

2 1/2 days of waiting around, reading, working on laptop, playing (very ancient) Trivial Pursuits with other waiting jurors. Got called for the panel for a couple of trials expected to run for many weeks, but you're allowed to give reasons why you can't sit on a long case (I had a long contract booked in and would have lost months of work).

Sat on one case in the end - GBH. The defendant admitted hitting the victim, but the CPS were going for a more serious offence. I hadn't really realised before that you can only look at the evidence presented to you - there were discrepancies and holes in all the testimonies, but the Jury can't ask for clarification/more information, or anything else. We all thought the defendant was guilty, but since no evidence had been presented to prove it, we had to say Not Guilty, because you have to go on the evidence, and it has to be beyond all reasonable doubt.

Hyppyb · 04/01/2024 19:58

Thanks, I have jury duty soon, was just wondering what it's like, I know the type of court it's all serious crime so worried it may be traumatic but also really hoping its over soon as I have other things going on like waiting for a hospital app and ivf.

OP posts:
Soccermumamir · 04/01/2024 20:10

I loved it. Yes, there is a bit of hanging around, so I took music and a book. I ended up getting chatting to a couple of others, and we all hung around with each other. I was meant to do 2 weeks, however my second trial went over by a week, so I did 3 weeks in the end. I got called up like 3 times, but the first case je decided to plead guilty 🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️

olderbutwiser · 04/01/2024 20:20

I did a 6-week fraud trial. The most astonishing thing was that the fraudsters ever thought they'd get away with it. When it finished they said we could have 10 years off jury duty, but most of us wanted to do another immediately - we felt we'd got the hang of it now.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page