Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Director Dispute

7 replies

Icanflyhigh · 26/02/2021 12:28

Not sure if anyone can help, and this might be long...

DP purchased business premises last year and got the keys in September, purchased with a business partner (long term friend of 10 years plus).

Premises were financed by half mortgage and half loan from business partners mother. Mortgage is in the name of the Ltd Company they set up together. Fast forward to now and DP really wanted to get cracking with building the business up (we have had no income for a year due to Covid and a delay in getting keys to the premises) There was a robust business plan in place (general repairs garage) but this has been deviated from as business partner wanted to focus on decorating the building first and was insistent the business wouldn't open until the premises were all painted and the floor tiled ready to go. Realistically, this should have taken a few weeks, but they started trading on 5th October and have been having cars come through for service and repairs since then - enough to just about cover the mortgage and overheads, but not enough to build a buffer to allow the purchase of materials to decorate to the standard the business partner requires or take a wage.

So 5.5 months later, the building still looks the same etc and DP has been forced to find alternative employment - we were getting very close to choosing whether we paid the rent OR the bills as we couldn't afford both on just my income - our savings are now non-existent having used them to sustain ourselves.

The business partner, it seems, only ever needed DP to secure a mortgage, he couldn't do it on his own.
DP has written, with advice from a solicitor, a without prejudice letter and said he wishes to sell his shares to the business partner, and upon doing so will resign as a director and walk away. Business partner has ignored this (we now know he has a habit of ignoring legal stuff which we didn't know before).
DP has 25% share in the Ltd Company, business partner has 75% share. We cannot afford to go down the solicitor route as we already know that a legal bill will outweigh anything we are likely to recoup from the business. There are two financial charges relating to the business, and both against the company name, nothing against DP personally. If he resigns as Director, he will no longer be financially liable for anything - but we really want to be reimbursed for the shares - he has worked 14-16 hours a day for over 5 months prepping this place etc, received no wage from it and is really fed up that it looks like he will get nothing.
Does anyone know where we go next? Can he just sell his shares to anyone who will by them, or transfer them to someone who will be a royal pain in the backside to the business partner?
The shares were never linked to the director at set-up - something the business partner has tried to push through on a special resolution since this all happened - but we have refused as a board meeting was not called and there were no details provided prior to it.

At the moment we are thinking that DP just resigns as director to ensure his financial liability is removed, and in doing so, ensures a copy goes to the bank - this will likely cause the bank to ask for the mortgage to be repaid and then taken out in the remaining director name only - which we know he cannot do as he hasn't got the funds to do this.
Any advice greatly appreciated.

OP posts:
Hadalifeonce · 26/02/2021 12:33

If you have an accountant, it may be worth speaking to them.

prh47bridge · 26/02/2021 12:58

Can he just sell his shares to anyone who will by them, or transfer them to someone who will be a royal pain in the backside to the business partner?

It is impossible to answer this question without seeing the company's articles of association.

notapizzaeater · 26/02/2021 13:47

You can't just walk away from a directorship. He would still be liable for the mortgage/loan and anything else legal to do with the business. Likewise the other director doesn't have to buy his shares and depending on how the company was set up he might not be able to just sell them. Have you got legal cover with the business cover?

prh47bridge · 26/02/2021 16:09

@notapizzaeater

You can't just walk away from a directorship. He would still be liable for the mortgage/loan and anything else legal to do with the business. Likewise the other director doesn't have to buy his shares and depending on how the company was set up he might not be able to just sell them. Have you got legal cover with the business cover?
Whether he has any ongoing liability for the mortgage or the loan depends entirely on whether he gave personal guarantees. Whilst it is not impossible, I would be surprised if there were any personal guarantees for the loan since it came from the other director's mother. A personal guarantee is more likely for the mortgage, but it is quite possible there is no personal guarantee there either and the OP certainly implies none was given.

Unless the business has broken the law whilst he was a director he will have no ongoing liability for anything legal to do with the business.

If there are no personal guarantees he can indeed just walk away from his directorship. He will not be liable for anything, even if he is still a shareholder. That is the whole point of a limited company. The company is liable, not the directors or shareholders. The directors can only be made liable in limited circumstances.

Icanflyhigh · 26/02/2021 21:53

Thanks

We have had a solicitor check and the two charges relate to the mortgage and the bank account but both are in the ltd company name and not personal.

Essentially we have lost a few thousand pounds in legal fees in setting up the business, and a year of time, in a year when we couldn't do very much anyway.

Would really like to walk away with something rathe than nothing, but if all we can take is no financial or legal liability then so be it.

OP posts:
prh47bridge · 26/02/2021 21:58

Check with the mortgage lender to make sure there isn't a personal guarantee. It wouldn't be registered as a charge. It would just be one of the pieces of paper he signed when the company took on the mortgage.

Icanflyhigh · 27/02/2021 09:36

Thank you, I'll get him to check that with the bank.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page