Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

The council damaged my mums car - how to proceed?

5 replies

billyokey · 14/10/2014 08:08

A week or so ago my mum got a burst tyre while she was out driving on a Sunday morning. Her car is one of those that doesn't have a spare, the a puncture repair kit, which she tried to use but the tyre was absolutely gone. She was on her own and didn't have phone/purse on her. She was panicking and managed to pull her car into a small side street, where the only free space was a disabled parking spot. She then had to walk 6 miles home, where she then had to ring around for a recovery company who would come out on a Sunday to go and collect her car.

When she got back to the car with the recovery vehicle around 2.5 hours later it had been removed by the council and been impounded. She went to pick it up and paid the parking ticket and release fee, as she accepts she was parked in that space without authorisation, but did try to appeal to their better nature which got her nowhere.

However, when they took her to her car in their lot it was damaged - a big dent and lots of scratches on the wheel arch. The man from the recovery company said it was obvious this had happened when the council had lifted it off the road, as he knew the kind of hoists they use. My mum was given a form to fill in and sent on her way after taking pictures.
She has filled in the form, sent them pictures of the damage alongside the pictures taken by the parking attendant who ticketed her car before it was removed, which clearly show no damage. Now the council have come back and said they didn't cause the damage, and it could have been caused in the 15 minutes between the parking attendants pictures and their vehicle removing it to the impound lot. This is extremely unlikely!

My mum is not willing to let this go and wants the damage paid for, but where does she stand? is the onus on her to prove that the council DID do the damage, or is the onus on them to prove that they DIDNT?
Sorry its so long - appreciate any insight or advice!

OP posts:
jerryfudd · 14/10/2014 08:13

Issue small claims proceedings. Civil cases are decided "on the balance of probabilities" as opposed to beyond reasonable doubt so in the circumstances you describe i would take my chance that a judge will find that given that photos show no damage before and after being hoisted there is damage the likelihood is it was caused by them.

britishbakeoffblues · 14/10/2014 08:21

Is the area covered by cctv?

billyokey · 14/10/2014 08:31

Thanks for responding - would small claims proceedings cost a lot of money? I wondered about CCTV too, as the side street is at the back of a car park - but how would we find out or be able to view the footage? I guess all we would need to see is that noone else came near the car in between the parking attendant and the removal vehicle

OP posts:
jerryfudd · 14/10/2014 11:58

Fees for issuing start from £35. They increase as to the value of the claim. Proceedings can be issued on line. I would get a couple of quotes for the damage as you will need to evidence your loss.

If you are seeking cctv footage do it fast as most systems only keep for short period before recording over

specialsubject · 14/10/2014 18:00

and for future ref - breakdown cover and carrying a phone is absolutely vital for anyone with these shitty modern cars with no spare tyre.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page