Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

News

Aid for Africa - noble and compassionate or shortsighted and patronising?

26 replies

suzywong · 08/06/2005 01:15

I know that the Live 8 thing is in the news a lot and on people's minds. I was at the first Live Aid and it really opened my eyes and got my teenage energy going towards the great divides between the first and the third worlds and I was vigorous supporter.

However, I came across this comment on the BBC news website

As an African, I am full of anger knowing that my people have become mere pawns in this very cynical and self-serving antic of doing something for Africa - whatever this means. This is a game in which the real obstacles to our people's economic emancipation (i.e., African rulers) are gratuitously indulged at every opportunity, while our people become increasingly poorer.

I just wish that the Blairs and the Geldofs of this world would stop exploiting my people's suffering in this way. It is, after all, the case, that no impoverished African has ever asked anyone for aid. If the Blairs and the Geldofs of this world cannot join us in demanding responsible governance on our continent, I say, leave us alone; stop prolonging our suffering with these antics. Enough is enough!

UE, UK/Nigeria

and it made me think; is the first world misguided in it's zeal for aid or should the more toothy issue of tackling the widespread problems with those who govern African countires be addressed before aid is handed over?

There are plenty of other comments on that website, I just thought I'd start the ball rolling with this one as it's one that jumped out at me.

OP posts:
Kaz33 · 09/06/2005 20:49

Lets see some of the isssues:

  • Corruption fueled by the western corporations, its westerners giving the back handers as well.
  • Disease, TB, Malaria and AIDS which are devastating a continent in particular the young.
  • Is a democratic state the only answer, democracy in the west was won by the people. Does it work if imposed onto societies which have fundamentally different development.
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread