Agree with everything you are saying again hmb!
OPur school does do some of these voactional/aternative curriculum courses for pupils. In these cases the pupils (Y10/11) soend 3 days either at college or in a work place, and the other two days in school.
In school these pupils study core subjects - we call it Flexible Learning. They do English, Maths, ICT and some other things - not 100% on it all. I do the ICT stuff woth them. In ICT they are not doing an approved, certificated course. I'd like to change this thogugh for next year - didn't even know we were having this class 'till I got me timetable in September! They are not doing GCSEs in English or Maths either - they do some other quaification.
At college some are doing vocational courses and these take place either partially or wholey with a work placement. Typical vocational stuff is child care in nurseries, brick laying, joinery, plastering, etc. They also do some form of certificated courses along side this in that field.
However, when in school these kids still don't want to be there and still do not work. I spend the whole lesson forcing these kds to do some work and try and get some learning to take place. But it is a struggle and I fight them all the way. We wil get some learning done, but it won't be easy and I will have to force them all the way.
When challenged these kids just have no reasons for why they feel they should work in school. They tell me they don't need school qualifications - their uncle/dad/frienmd will give them a job, or they'll do on the dole. They seem to have no or little ambition at all. I find that really hard to understand, but have to work through it and keep challenging them and pushing them. I actually find it very sad that a 14 year old can have no desire to achieve something :(