Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

News

shrek

12 replies

bexkir · 08/07/2007 21:06

i too am one of those people who you all seem to hate although i didn't join to have my say i am going to anywayi took my 6 year old daughter to see shrek last week sitting waiting for the film to start we were faced with the advert of madeline, maybe it is me or maybe it is just a mum thing but it bought tears to my eyes, we haven't stopped our daughter from seeing the news about the abduction but niether have we explained what has happened we have just left it open for her to ask us if she wants to i hadn't realised how much she had taken in when she promptly told me that 'that little girl was taken by a nasty man' when should i have told her ???? should i have told her before we got to this point, i then decided to tell her that it may not have been a 'nasty man' but maybe a 'nasty lady' as they are also out there. what do we do know do you frighten children to never speak to strangers as after all isn't this how we all make new friends. i now have made the desission that this advert cannot be bad as anything that makes a child think of the dangers of strangers cannot be bad ..... can it??????

OP posts:
mytwopenceworth · 08/07/2007 21:15

I think what people who are reading this story in papers are failing to understand is that people on Mumsnet are actually just as upset about this girl's disappearance as anywhere else.

It is not that they don't care - they do. There are many, many threads where people are saying how upset they are, how awful it is, what can they do to help etc.

The reporting of this story makes people think we hate this girl! Not true.

Stay, read the many many threads. Read how many people here have felt about this.

What some people have objected to is

1 - not being warned that this was to be shown. They would have wanted to prepare their children.

2 - that it is their job as parents to decide how, when or if, such information should be discussed with their children. Not the cinema.

Take for example, my own ds. Both are autistic. I have chosen to not try to tell them anything. I know that they could not understand, but it would probably frighten them. They may fear that they could be taken away.

Do you see? It is not that mumsnet is the official WeDon'tCare site! We care but it is about what is appropriate.

We as adults know what has happened. Showing this in a childrens film is telling our children what has happened. This is our job and the way it was done was not how many of us would have chosen to present the information, if we had chosen to at all, based on the age/understanding of our children.

The media does not care about this. They want to tell a good story. Never let the facts get in the way of a good story it is said. How true!!

Stay. Read. Make up your own mind.

doughnuts · 08/07/2007 21:17

haven't we done this subject to death ?

mytwopenceworth · 08/07/2007 21:18

Actually. This is my first ever post on any thread on this topic. So I haven't done it to death! I just thought op might like a balanced view.

CountTo10 · 08/07/2007 21:18

Ditto donughts.

And may I just say twopence - at last someone has finally managed to put an eloquent argument together as opposed to the abusive mud slinging that has erupted over the subject. Nice post!

bexkir, lovely to meet you and welcome to mn, but plllllllease can we have a different subject now!!!

littlelapin · 08/07/2007 21:18

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

tiredemma · 08/07/2007 21:19

The Madeleine McCann situation has really tugged at my heart strings- I feel desperatly sad for her parents, cant bear to think of what the child may be going through and cannot ever begin to imagine what it must be like for her parents to wake everyday wondering where she is, or whether she is still alive or not......

....however- I really do not want my son ( age 6) to know that you can be 'snatched' from your bed. How I choose to inform my children about 'stranger danger' should be my choice, not the choice of the Odeon group.

Please dont think that we are heartless- far from it. In a nutshell- I want to shield my sons for as long as possible to the dangers out there

LittleBoot · 08/07/2007 21:20

Bexkir, if you do a search in the News section and also put in the words Madeleine/ Madeline/ Maddie/ Maddy I'm sure you'll get a good overview of what people think.

Welcome to Mumsnet.

doughnuts · 08/07/2007 21:20

yes, sorry - credit to mytwopence - sums it up perefectly.

bexkir · 09/07/2007 11:30

i have read many of the listings in this topic and donot feel that you are heartless in any way i just felt that i neded to have my say in this subject i fel our children need to know that we do not live in a fairytale world where everybody loves everybody else maybe it is that my daughter is very friehdly to all she meets that this story has hit me so hard to her anybody who speaks to her is a 'nice' person who will not hurt her she is also under the impression that only men are 'nasty' and take children .i am not knocking anybody who wishes to shield their children from this world in any way i am just very angry that we are in a possition as parents to have to warn our children of these dangers as they do exist

OP posts:
Nbg · 09/07/2007 11:33

FARKING SHREK

ARGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!

I bet Mike fecking Myers is bloody raking it in atm.

The Cinema was wrong. End of story.

pagwatch · 09/07/2007 14:58

Nbg - is that the next one
Shrek, Shrek 2 , Shrek the third, Farking Shrek.. I might go and see that one.

MhamaiJane · 09/07/2007 15:05

I also haven't posted on any of the many McCann threads but wanted to say "Excellent post MTPW!"

New posts on this thread. Refresh page