My view is that raising children is a gamble full stop.
Certainly many of the people that I have known who have really gone off the rails or suffered because of their up bringing are those that had very strict, prohibitive upbringings with unapproachable parents.
My halls of residence were full of 18 year olds who had never been allowed out past 11pm and simply lost it when they had to make their own choices.
The article is typical DM bullshit - the tattoos aside the dress/hair/piercings/DM's etc were pretty standard fare when I was her age 20 years ago, as was the fact that the majority of the girls in my school were sexually active by 15 yrs old. And I went to a lovely school in the home counties.
The only thing I could disaprove of is the concept of no formal education because the DD has decided she can't be bothered to get up and that has been spun so fast that it is making me dizzy.