This old house has never had a fitted kitchen, DownThePubWithStevieNicks. There's nothing much in the way of cupboards except the dresser bottom. Pretty much everything is on open shelves etc, which makes having these uninvited and unwelcome guests especially tricky and hazardous. That they've probably been scurrying about on everything doesn't bear thinking about, so I'm trying not to! Thanks for the tip about the containers.
There's never been any evidence of caught mice here over the years, so like you Lurkingandlearning I suspected just our cat's very presence kept them away. He's on my lap supervising me posting but that's as far as it goes for pest control help from him, at least these days.
We're not a minimalist household, nor with OCD levels of cleanliness thankfully, so being completely fastidious isn't coming easily or naturally. Not having a fitted kitchen and having pets and DC who understandably drop crumbs and leave toys about no doubt isn't helping. I suspect mousey had been nibbling remnants of cereal in the bowl and pooping at the same time. 'Oh yuck' indeed, or something similar.
Luckily there is rarely any food in our kitchen bin as it goes separately for recycling. I haven't noticed any disturbance to the bag the food waste is collected in either. Thanks for the tip about silver foil. I didn't have any wire/steel wool as recommended by RoamingGnome so I used foil last night to block a tiny worn away gap in the corner of the old wooden back door and also the bit where the draught excluder is missing along the bottom - now wondering whether the mice were responsible for that! Good luck with your own battle - with winter laziness and mice - Lurkingandlearning!
The latest on the traps is that the cereal bowl - no more poops - trap still hasn't been visited. I've moved that trap now to the hall, where I thought a mouse might also have been nibbling a bar of chocolate left on a chair. I can't tell whether or not the banana trap had been visited again last night. I don't want to disturb it too much as it seems to be the trap of choice and I don't want to put any mice off it.
What a pain, especially the week before Christmas. Hoping the little buggers don't get into any gifts or DCs' little chocolate stocking fillers - if they go upstairs it will be war!