Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Home decoration

Carpet in dining area and leather sofa in open plan? long.

10 replies

TKKW · 08/08/2013 13:09

I am sat here typing quite down in the dumps about decisions I have made about our kitchen and back room living area. It was "my project" and DH chipped in with some advice but just left it to me decide on how I wanted things. Im not blaming him btw nor am I annoyed with him

Basically, i have thought about our back room for months before undertaking the work but its all gone a bit out the window now.

We ripped all the old carpets out of the back room, ripped out half a kitchen which the previous owners installed to the back room beside the kitchen and have also pulled out the old actual kitchen and re positioned the pipes/ boiler etc.

Initially, I was dead set on having a stud wall rebuilt to separate the two rooms but midst my father in law and H doing that, I changed my mind as it seemed to cut the kitchen short and make a bottle neck of doors at one end of a very small galley kitchen.

The stud walls werent plastered at this stage and were taken down so now there is a 2door width gap with no real space to add doors again if you see what I mean unless a stud wall is rebuilt and a single door attached.

As we thought the room was going to be two separate (well, this is my recollection but my H recalls it differently!), we laid down pvc wood effect plank tiles. The plan was to use the adjoining room as a daily living room/ den type place with a 90x90 cm extendable table at one end, a 3 seater in the middle section and shelving at the bottom section where the wide opening is. It gets all the sun and its lovely and bright until about 2.30 - 3pm.

We had planned to carpet as the bottom floor in our house is totally freezing in the winter despite cavity walls insulated - its a 1930s house.

We have a stripped wood floor in the front room and we have a huge 2.5x 2.5 m rug in the middle to keep some heat in and I still find it freezing.

Last night I was thinking about all the crumbs and little bits of cheese my toddler loves to get around the floor and thought, "why oh why are we having carpet". The plan is have another one sometime soon, so double the food mess!

I asked Mr could we not lay real wood and he said no chance as it would mean re flooring the kitchen, taking some fitted kitchen units out and taking a door frame off to shave some wood from the bottom and rehanging. It would also mean re plastering in the back room for some reason (think around skirting boards there is some issue). We struggle to find not busy and good tradespeople around here so finding the person to do well is also hard.

He said we have to have carpet now and I need to order it soon. It was our plan to have some cheapish dark grey carpet and accept that it might have to be put in the skip 5-7 years down the line. Wasteful, I know.

I want to get carpets cleaned every 6-12 months for sure and I have just ordered some cheap oilcloth pvc table cloth as a splash mat to see how we get one with that before the carpet is laid.

Everyone is so in love with wood in the ground floor of their houses and I understand - its so easy to keep clean and with carpets, you have to live with the ground in grub unless you clean it with a rug dr or professionally.

Also, Im a bit worried about the open plan living now as our extraction fan is not great and can't be relocated to an external wall in the kitchen as there isn't enough wall space to house a hob and an extractor hood - our kitchen is teeny. We are vegetarian, dont fry often and dont really go for spicy food but we do love garlic!

We are planning on a leather sofa of some nice sort as we thinking perhaps food smells wont attach as easily.

I guess im just worried about how the house would fair on the market if we ever did need to sell it.

Can anyone advise on how smelly leather sofas in open plan get?

Please can someone give me success stories about carpet in dining areas to make me feel better?

OP posts:
TKKW · 08/08/2013 18:59

Has any one got a leather sofa in their open plan kitchen diner living room? Really getting twitchy and would be great to know if they did absorb smells.
Thanks

OP posts:
essexgirl31 · 08/08/2013 19:01

We have a leather sofa in our open plan kitchen diner and it doesn't smell at all.

Deux · 08/08/2013 19:08

We have a leather sofa in our openplan kitchen and it hasn't absorbed any smells at all. Actually i think it is far more forgiving than fabric would be. It's a matt finish its natural appearance is slightly scuffed. If we have any marks on it, i use baby wipes. I also occassionally spray liberally with pledge and give it a buff.

I tend to agree with you regarding the carpet. There must be a way around it, surely? Can you lay the pvc wood plank tiles and then just have a nice rug in front of the sofa?

essexgirl31 · 08/08/2013 19:11

We have wooden floorboards in our dining bit and tiles in the kitchen area. It looks fine. Instead of carpet could you look for something else? We got rid of our carpet in our dining area as it got really disgusting though I didn't look after it well! It sounds like you would.

My friend has a 7 year old and a 5 year old. She as a cream carpet in her dining area and it looks great. She has a vax cleaner that she uses regularly as we'll as getting it cleaned professionally.

essexgirl31 · 08/08/2013 19:12

Well not we'll.

iWillDoItInAMinute · 08/08/2013 19:14

Our sofa is not in an open plan are but it is 6 years old, I have 3 very messy DC and a dog who isn't supposed to go on it, but he does.

DH does love chilli/curry and eating on the sofa Hmm

It doesn't smell! I spot clean with wet wipes and rarely properly clean it. I have quite a sensitive nose -the rug stinks- the sofa is fine

Good luck, we have been fixing up our place for 6 years, I often doubt my decisions !

poocatcherchampion · 09/08/2013 08:30

it sounds to me a bit like you have lost your way with this plan, I hope you don't take that offensively I am trying to be constructive.

you have taken on a big job in planning these rooms and I wonder whether you need to refocus and remember what you want to achieve before rushing in and making expensive mistakes that you regret.

in my opinion carpet is a bad idea and I think you really think that too. I think the leather sofa sounds fine.

maybe also reflect on the flow if the rooms in their now open plan space to make sure you are using g it most wisely. if it wasn't your original plan then you might not have had a chance to think it all through and make the vest decisions?

sorry if I'm barking up the wrong tree, I hope this is some help..

TKKW · 09/08/2013 09:39

Poo, you're fine. Your post was constructive but I cant change the open plan thing now. I think my path is determined now to be honest!

The electric circuits for lighting and the doors not being secured on the flooring with the current material, lifting off the door frames for wood flooring to go under would undoubtedly involve replastering.

I think the walls could be rebuilt into a proper wall again perhaps with a door opening inwards to the back living area but after spending £1200 on plastering alone, we wont do that right now.

Yes, carpet is not going to be the most effective but luckily, the front room is completely separate with a door, has a wood floor and is technically the "formal" dining room which had used before as a living room with the sofas whereas everyone else on the lane used it as the dining room as per the tradition use.

Im just not sure about the smells thing and the carpet thing as before the back room was used by us a dining room, so smells were not noticed by us as we were eating there. Also, we practically live with the windows open from say april to september but winter times, the windows are only open an hour or so in the morning and then a short while in the afternoon.

I have form for being mind changer and I think Im doubting things now but our friends even before we started, said a part open room, ie 2/3rds wall, 1/3rd open, like is it now would be a good idea.

I dont know really! We've spent about £10,000 and the flooring, painting and furnishing haven't been done, so I feel so stressed about whether this is the right thing.

Can anyone tell me how they get on with open plan and cooking smells?

Thanks to everyone who posted on this.

OP posts:
TheWookiesWife · 11/08/2013 10:14

Hi ! Don't be glum - the carpet is hooverabble and the leather won't take on smells - so all that is workable ! Just think how lovely it will be to have everything working as normal again ! No more builders dust !
If you are really worried about toddler food going everywhere - Children sometimes love having their own table and chair !! Maybe an extra chair for a cherished teddy too, but in the kitchen - where the mess is easier to clean up, rather than wandering around with their nibbles ?!?!

TKKW · 12/08/2013 09:15

Hi,
back to update.
We had a builder /carpenter round to quote us for a final few things and we spoke about hardwood flooring.

We can't have it in kitchen as there wont be enough space under the cabinets in the kitchen to take the underfloor and wood boards but we can have it in dining room but the floors will be a bit different lookng and slightly in height.

He said another option in kardean in both kitchen and back room.

I really dont want to rip out the kitchen vinyl wood planks just to lay more vinyl kardean strips. The new kitchen planks are oak style in a lovely mid brown, so....

Was thinking of going to look at karndean in whitewashed oak effect or painted oak effect or light grey oak effect to put in back room.

So the kitchen would have mid brown oak and the back room would either have painted white oak or light grey oak flooring.

What do you think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread