We did Eurocamo for years when the kids were younger and loved it. Loved the freedom and always picked a site that was a good base to explore the region on day trips out in the car.
We then bought our own tent and camped in the UK every summer for a few years and loved that too.
Was persuaded to try an all inclusive resort by a friend who loves them. We hated it from the start. Nice food and the kids loved being able to help themselves but I just felt so claustrophobic. I missed my outside deck that comes with Eurocamp or just the sitting outside the tent of an evening on our UK camping trips.
In the end we hired a car half way though the week and went off exploring. My friend was horrified that we'd left the resort!
Swore we'd never do another and then circumstances led us to being in an all inclusive in Dubai one February half term. On the second day we escaped again and went off exploring. Enjoyed it overall but just don't like how busy and noisy it is being with so many other people.
The last few years we've hired villas in Corfu - perfection. We try out different beaches and bays and either eat out or buy salads and tapas style food and bread to enjoy on the terrace of an evening.
This year due to having our villa holiday cancelled because of the flight disruption ( literally as we were leaving for the airport) we ended up panic booking an all inclusive to Croatia with a days notice . Loved the area but the hotel was soul destroying and I just hated being around so many other people all fighting for the limited space on the beach/ around the pool or at the restaurant.
We will never ever as long as I live book an all inclusive again. Ever.
I'm sure if you book very very high end resorts you will have a better experience ( out Dubai hotel was 5 star and nothing to complain about but I just don't like the vibe)
Next year we are booking a UK campsite and taking our trusty air tent out for its final two week holiday before our DC 16 and 14 refuse to camp anymore. They've allowed us one more trip as long as we go with our camping friends who have kids the same age.