@Suffolker- my DD got her 7th choice of college, and she was pretty miffed about it at the time despite it being gowned (which was one of her tick boxes). She had put all the Bailey colleges first, but ended up with the second Hill college in her list, which she’d not even really looked at. Like most, she is now happily settled and made firm friends in her “7th choice college,” and she proudly sports her college merch. It took a few weeks of being there for the love to start, though.
I have seen people try to impart “wisdom” like - look at the stats on college rankings and try to put a less popular choice (usually a Hill college) high in your rankings so you are more likely to get one of your top choices - which is backwards thinking, really. Some people are very lucky and get their first choice in the draw, others much less so. Ultimately the college is just a building and it’s the people in it they’ll bond to, and that will make the college special. My own hindsight advice is to caution your YP about taking against any of the colleges, which can be difficult given as Durham students themselves engage in all sorts of inter-college banter and in-jokes that can make it seem like there is a hierarchy of colleges. My DD’s college is quite self-depreciating and is often referred to as though it’s boring, but really it’s just like all the others barring the age of the buildings…
Re: second year housing, ALL the unis seem to go in early on grouping up and finding a place for the following year, not just Durham. There’s a real sense of FOMO about it that just didn’t exist when we were at uni. There will be places available after the first big wave of students looking for accomodation, but the bigger/better value/best located ones will go quickly. That said there always seem to be rooms coming up (people fall out, plans change) so the real driver for the FOMO seems to be more about having a known group to share with, rather than a lack of accommodation. The down side of the groups coalescing so early is that by time they live together some of them find they’re not as comfortable a mix as they initially thought, but that’s house shares!
I also don’t know about geography I’m afraid.