@MyGreyBiscuit I too have seen that post and had the similar feeling about DD applying too. I have been subject to these comments for months now from various people as I work clinically as an AHP in the NHS.
However I must say I have had a balanced view from various Drs, older ones still positive because they had a much better time training and funding wise and now earn very well. Younger Drs are more realistic about their jobs, but despite their negative comments, always end with 'but I wouldn't have wanted to do anything else'. DD came on wex and visited my dept so I took her to two Consultants (both fairly young) and told her to listen to their opinions carefully. They were at opposite ends of the spectrum, one said DD should go to London and be a lawyer as she'd earn loads more, the other said they'd convince her to be a Dr by the end of her wex.
So I don't give my opinion. I am new to working in the NHS (qualified 5 yrs) so a lot of experience of work outside the NHS and I take everything with a pinch of salt. All jobs can be dreadfully stressful and badly/well paid. Being a Dr is a vocation and vulnerable to political decisions with one employer, making it a unique profession and incomparable to other roles I feel.
I just ask that DD takes a long term view, considers those opinions she's heard and read about and actually imagine herself on the wards as an FY1/2. DD still doesn't want to do anything else atm. She is young and yes naive but I will support her in whatever she wants to do.
I also think that if she gets to the end of a 5 year medical degree and finds she can't or doesn't want to be a Dr, that degree will open many doors to other related jobs so it won't be wasted. Many YP do at least 4 years at uni including masters degrees nowadays and yes the debt is horrific but it is the only way YP can gain professional careers in a lot of fields.
Gosh I have gone on! Anyway, as I am not a Dr this is just my humble opinion but I am just going to travel alongside DD in her journey and see where it leads her!
We are off to our final open day at Leeds today (in the hurricane winds and rain!) and I am a little sad as I have loved seeing all the unis. DDs application is already in though so this is just to complete her knowledge of those she's applied to. I have a secret soft spot for Leeds as I was offered a place there once (couldn't take it due to practical/placement reasons) but I loved it and am familiar with the city.
Any last visits for anyone else?