Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

Guest post: "I had to use a foodbank - many families aren't 'just about managing'"

95 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 29/11/2016 11:43

Last week, I reached crisis point.

It feels like this has been looming since I was sanctioned in 2013. Following my sanction, I struggled with depression and agoraphobia brought on by anxiety. I started overeating and put on weight. It’s been a long road back to work and full health - I now work part-time, but my income is not always enough to pay my bills. Bit by bit, I have been sliding into debt.

Then a delayed benefit payment due to a computer error led to bank charges, which put me overdrawn. When it came to going shopping I had no money for food. With no opportunity to get help from family I turned to my housing association. I was given a voucher for the local foodbank, but it didn't open for a few days so I had to wait. That afternoon, my electric ran out so I sat there in the dark, feeling very alone, with no food to eat, and memories of my sanction filling my mind.

I was sanctioned for not looking for work. Fair punishment you might think, but the reason I wasn’t job hunting was because I was doing a two-week training course in a neighbouring town, leaving home at 7am and returning home at 7pm. I had been instructed not to jobsearch or sign on during that time, but later another adviser disagreed. I lost my £71 a week Jobseekers Allowance for four weeks.

I went without electricity, heating and food for most of the sanction. It climaxed on Christmas day. I spent it watching happy families walk past my window, while I sat silently, dealing with diarrhoea and waiting for it to get dark so I could try to sleep. It wasn’t until I received a Christmas card from a relative with £20 in it that I was able to eat and buy electric for the meter.

Less than two weeks later, I was told by the same Jobcentre adviser that I needed to learn a ‘work ethic’ - something clearly not demonstrated by my 20-year work history. She put me on mandatory work activity – workfare – which meant working full-time for free for four weeks in order to receive my benefits. Effectively, I was being punished for being sanctioned. I didn’t argue with her. Instead I went home, emptied the bathroom cabinet of the various pills I had stored away and tried to end my life. Less than a year before I had been earning £35k at a university in London.

In the run-up to the Autumn Statement, the papers were filled with news about so-called JAMs. These six million families who are 'just about managing' will no doubt be hoping that the government will fulfil its promise to make their lives better. But there is another group of families who have lost that hope. They are the ones who have been on the receiving end of harsh cuts to their income, through austere welfare cuts. Most of them also work but live in fear that the government will make their lives even harder.

I am not alone in receiving a sanction. Since the Conservatives were elected in 2010 until June this year around three million individuals have received eight million sanctions. Some may have been able to overturn the decision, but more wouldn't. The 3m figure doesn't include family members – mostly children – who are also affected by sanctions. For children living in sanctioned households, schools and foodbanks have become a lifeline, with teachers reportedly using money meant for education to buy food and clothing.

Some people whose benefit entitlement has been cut turn to social media for support. When Lauren got a letter from the council to inform her that housing benefit was being cut by £103.99 a week because of changes to the benefit cap, she went online to seek help. However, what she got was hate from people who are themselves 'just about managing'. Too many people now see single mums who rely on benefits as unworthy of respect and are instead treated as ‘breeders’ who are responsible for their own misery.

I was lucky to receive a more positive response when I turned to social media last week. After a period of feeling sorry for myself, I wrote a blog post using my phone and wi-fi from a neighbour and was able to get enough support to overcome my immediate problem. But there are many people out there who don't have this luxury. Over Christmas last year 23,901 jobseekers and a further 3031 sick or disabled people were sanctioned, with many of those potentially spending that time living without food and heating. Others will not have a home at all and will have been sleeping rough.

Many families will be concerned about facing the biggest squeeze to their pay in 70 years, which the Institute for Fiscal Studies recently predicted - but another group will be worried about not having an income at all. Last week during a debate on cuts to Employment and Support Allowance, MP Ian Mearns highlighted a constituent who had been forced to heat soup tins with a tea light following redundancy. Debbie Abrahams MP recently brought attention to one of her constituents who suffered a heart attack during his work capability assessment, and was sanctioned for not completing the assessment. Benefit sanctions and austerity have forced many households into undignified situations in order to feed themselves and their loved ones. These families are not just about managing - it is much worse than that.

OP posts:
PausingFlatly · 30/11/2016 16:15

As part of Universal Credit can they sanction the housing and child part which will now be combined.
This scares the living daylights out of me.

Yes, this bit is really worrying me (not for personal reasons).

And the picture is worse than just the sanctions part. Unless this has changed since UC was first proposed, people who HAVEN'T been sanctioned may have their UC cut.

The original proposals were, that JobCentre/DWP clerks would assign an arbitrary target amount for an unemployed or disabled person to earn (despite being declared Not Fit For Work even by the DWP), and that amount would simply be deducted from UC.

If you didn't earn it, tough shit. And since UC also cuts into rent, you couldn't just starve your way through a bad month - you'd be bound to be evicted too.

I sincerely hope this particular proposal has now been quietly dropped.

And I really do wonder if people who support this shit grasp that the people on the receiving end have votes? And how long they think divide and rule of JAMS vs Not Managings will continue to work? The safely enclosed arena of two-party politics won't survive the current trauma: we have no control of who'll come marching out of the mist with a banner carried by Super Wealthy Rank Opportunists, but which the JAMs and the Not Managings feel driven to unite behind.

PausingFlatly · 30/11/2016 16:17

x-posted with imajsaclaimant

So it sounds like what I described is already in force, under the guise of "sanction for not looking hard enough for additional work".

PausingFlatly · 30/11/2016 16:22

stumblymonkey, the JobCentre have had options of sanctions available for many years.

They just tended to use them sparingly and only where they thought these would have an appropriate effect.

In the new sanctions regime, JobCentre whistleblowers talk about sanctions being used as "saving money to the taxpayer" and JCs having targets for sanctions.

PausingFlatly · 30/11/2016 16:29

Part of the grotesqueness of the current situation, is that here we are, supporting foodbanks - a patchy and highly inefficient way of trying to support people, which essentially taxes "niceness" since nasty bastards don't bother contributing.

When a main reason for people needing foodbanks is the deliberate setting up of the DWP welfare system to fail - by sanctioning, by understaffing, by removal of the emergency loans system, and so on. And the DWP welfare system is the one funded by progressive taxation of even the nasty bastards.

PausingFlatly · 30/11/2016 16:41

BTW, I'm absolutely not suggesting that everyone who doesn't contribute to a foodbank is a nasty bastard. Just people who definitely answer that description, certainly won't be donating to foodbanks.

hesterton · 30/11/2016 16:56

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

expatinscotland · 30/11/2016 17:02

There was a horrid thread on here a couple of years back about foodbank donations. So many vile people scolding and sneering at any sort of 'treat' someone might donate to a foodbank. The past 6 years have brought out the worst in some people.

ThisisMrsNicolaHicklin · 30/11/2016 17:05

In my opinion no one should be sanctioned for any reason. I can't really think of anything that a person could do in relation to benefits that is bad enough to warrant the government actively removing the means to feed/heat yourself. The whole idea is barbaric and entirely futile as a money saving idea as other agencies (esp. the NHS) end up picking up the pieces.

I watched the Victorian Slum and it was really sad, watching as things got better for the Slum dwellers, knowing that it's all being unpicked now.

MothersRuinart · 30/11/2016 18:15

The supposed benefit or welfare system really is terrible in this country. Not only do you get arbitrary sanctions, you might have to end up having to pay everything back despite keeping everyone informed of your situation. It really is vile.

throwingpebbles · 30/11/2016 20:10

" I think the most generous are the ones who understand how close so many are to having to use them."

I have often noticed this too. It's easy for people to decide it's not their problem if they are very remote.

I have only been in a position of relying on tax credits, but even that was enough to leave me feeling very vulnerable and stressed. I am very organised with money, but the system is a nightmare, with everything geared to be uncertain and no clarity or simplicity. The system at present traps people and destroys them. its a monstrous distortion of the welfare state.

As an aside- what are good items to donate to a food bank, especially st this time of year? Our work is collecting and has suggested "festive" items and I was wondering what to pick??

SheDoneAlreadyDoneHadHerses · 30/11/2016 20:18

Chocolate treats, puds, biscuits, alongside usual fare, I think. And sanpro, deodorant, shampoo, etc.

bumpetybumpbumpbump · 30/11/2016 20:18

Even the word 'sanction' is disgusting.

Sanction. Punishment for struggling or being poor.

theveryhighlife · 30/11/2016 20:21

Brilliantly written. The inequality in this country needs to be addressed. The system is failing too many people and it's heartbreaking. I hope you're managing to get back on your feet.

hesterton · 30/11/2016 20:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BroomstickOfLove · 30/11/2016 20:27

Jesus. Even if you ignore all appeals to basic humanity, surely it's counter-productive that the punishment for being ill, disorganised or unable to challenge rules which are impossible to follow should be worse than the punishment for actually committing a crime? Surely, eventually, prison with food, warmth and shelter becomes an attractive option.

myoriginal3 · 30/11/2016 20:28

Such a lovely thought pebbles. My most valued items have been
Pot noodles! Hmm
Orange juice.
Chocolate

I would imagine mince pies would go down well with English folk?

It's so hard to say this but being handed 22 tins of beans to try to carry home single handed is soul destroying.

Other things which were invaluable were shampoo shower gel and sanitary towels or tampons.

Oh and washing powder and wash up liquid and oil for frying (a lot using food bank may not have use of a kitchen though, hence the pot noodles )

awesomeness · 30/11/2016 20:33

i once was sanctioned years ago for 8 weeks, through an error on their part, said id missed two interviews with them (yet i had proof i'd rung them and had a several minute conversation both times) i'd rearranged them for job interviews they had made me go on with a threat of loosing my income support, my son was 8 months old and they wanted me to go back into full time work (i didn't get the jobs because the employers didn't believe i could commit to full time work and they were right)

i didn't eat for days to keep my son fed, they wouldnt supply anything for a food bank because it was my fault, i had no heating, no electric, i could of lost my son, it was through winter on the run up to xmas, no presents, nothing, i was literally on the bones of my arse, after 3 weeks and several phone calls and false promises of getting paid the next day, walking 8 miles there and back twice to the job center with the promise of an emergency payment that wasn't fulfilled, a family member realised what was happening and took us in, i was in terrible debt, lost an awful lot
of weight, i was very ill, my son had a cold, i wouldn't afford to pay anything to my family member at all, i was in the bones of my arse and barely surviving

1 week before xmas i get a letter saying they'll reinstate my benefits as it was an error of theirs and they found the call logs and notes and that i shouldn't of even been having interviews as my child was under 5

no apology, it wasn't back dated.

took me years to get back on my feet just because they didn't do the job properly and tried to force a single mother with an 8 month old back into full time work

that's not 'just managing' that's just surviving

myoriginal3 · 30/11/2016 20:37

Oh and uht milk. And tuna.
I've seen mothers there who like Ella something or other food pouches

myoriginal3 · 30/11/2016 20:40

Awesome that's just horrific!

You've earned your name.

Cherryskypie · 30/11/2016 20:44

Make sure that you buy mince pies and Christmas pudding without alcohol in. Food banks can't take stuff containing alcohol.

All Tesco should have collection points over the next couple of days.

awesomeness · 30/11/2016 20:44

now at least £10 usually more of my weekly food shop is food bank stuff, i've spent a fair amount on presents to donate to a local charity that distributes them, i can often be found with homeless people in liverpool distributing food, shoes, sleeping bags, sanitary protection, toiletries etc

i was driving around last night picking up heaters for a young mother with broken boiler,no money, a bad landlord and didn't drive, i took her food for her and the kids and a chocolate treat too

i know what it's like to be right on the line, and now i have a decent job and a nice house, and i like to give back

frikadela01 · 30/11/2016 20:44

Its a despicable practice. I grew up in quite bad poverty and am thankful to be out of it but far too aware that any of us could be in this position one day. Agree with pp who have said sanctions hark back to the deserving and undeserving poor. Scrap all sanctions and stop blaming the poor aand vulnerable and start helping them.

As for food banks. I donated a load of selection boxes and mine pies. I do usually give money though after chatting with last who runs it and she said money really comes in handy so they can buy bits that are missing from the donations (they have set items that mist go in every bag)

hmcAsWas · 30/11/2016 21:01

I am sharing your blog post with my dc. Sadly they seem to have a Daily Fail perspective on benefit claimants (not based on what I have told them I assure you! - I've been doing my best to re-educate them and open their minds). I think they have picked up these attitudes from the media, peer group etc - its the prevalent ideology

RJnomore1 · 30/11/2016 21:28

I do think people should be suppprted to get into work.

Supported. Not punished. If the point is to get them into employment I fail to see how them being homeless starving or frozen with cold can help them get into a position to secure employment.

If it's not to get them into employment it's just. Barbaric stick used for those who are being othered as less than human. That's scary as a society.

Really sad to see the shite about there being lots of people committing benefit fraud being spouted further up the thread too.

expatinscotland · 30/11/2016 21:40

Condiments and spices are good to donate, too.