Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

Guest post: "I don't want my daughter to be the 'token black girl'"

91 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 23/08/2016 09:57

In the summer of 2015, my three-year-old daughter Riley-Ann's request each day when she came home from nursery was the same: to have long, straight hair like her teachers, friends, and favourite cartoon characters. When this first happened, I stayed silent, thinking it was a phase that would soon pass. But she kept insisting on wearing a hat, and kept asking for different hair. I was surprised: I'd always made a conscious effort to tell her she is beautiful and surround her with a diverse range of books, dolls, family and friends.

I told Riley-Ann that her curly afro hair was beautiful - but this didn't work. One day, her request changed: she didn't ask for straight hair, but for white skin. She said she didn't want to be brown any more.

My heart sank, but I was careful not to react. I felt sad - angry, even - at what she was saying. I knew that just telling Riley-Ann to recognise her inner and outer beauty wouldn't work. I needed to show her that there were children out there that looked like her.

Step in, Annie. In the latest remake of the film the lead is played by the young black actress Quvenzhané Wallis. I thought to myself, if this doesn't work, I don't know what will.

I put the DVD on and walked into the kitchen, hoping this final attempt to get Riley-Ann to see the beauty of her natural hair and skin would work. Five minutes into the film - before the first song had even ended - she ran into the kitchen screaming "Mummy - take out my plaits." Grabbing me by the hand she pulled me into the living room and again asked me to remove her plaits. So I did. I took out every single one of those small plaits with beads on the ends that I had only just put in the day before.
Halfway through the film, I finished undoing her hair, and Riley-Ann immediately jumped up. "Mummy, look - Annie is beautiful... I am Annie and Annie is me. She LOOKS LIKE ME." For the first time, I truly understood the power of positive reflective imagery for children.

In her role as Annie, Quvenzhané Wallis had inspired Riley-Ann to embrace her natural hair and beautiful brown skin. To Riley-Ann, she was a superstar, the first young black girl with naturally curly afro hair that she'd seen on screen. My daughter saw herself in Annie, and felt empowered and inspired - so much so that the film was stuck on repeat for the rest of the weekend. I didn't mind, though, because my child fell back in love with the hair that grew out of her scalp and her dark brown melanin skin.

Riley-Ann had aspirations to be like Quvenzhané Wallis, and she was already modelling at this point. The agency treated her well, and offered her lots of jobs - but I quickly noticed that ad campaigns will often only feature one child of colour. Riley-Ann became the token black girl and I didn't feel comfortable with this. What about all the other little beautiful black girls? I wondered.

A lack of representation doesn't just affect children; it affects their parents too. When TV screens and billboards are populated almost entirely by white children with a token ethnic minority child, it can feel like we're not getting anywhere in our fight for diversity. I reached the point where I couldn't bear for my daughter to express any more negativity about herself, but I couldn't just sit back and complain - I had to do something. As a freelance producer, I have the skills to be a change-maker. So, I set up Looks Like Me talent and model agency. We aim to increase inclusivity, visibility and employability of Black and Minority Ethnic children in the creative sector and advertising, offering casting directors diversity when selecting artists or models from Black and Minority Ethnic backgrounds.

Redefining beauty with Looks Like Me, we can create an industry where black children are the norm, rather than token additions. Perhaps then, it won't take an 'Annie moment' for other little black girls to realise they're beautiful.

OP posts:
Katymac · 26/08/2016 21:05

Obviously I think she is

But is has been hard providing positive role models, books, dolls, history and the hair care is a nightmare!!

themoreiseeyou · 26/08/2016 21:22

61% of the inner London population is BAME (Black, Asian, Minority ethnic); 51% outer London. It is almost the norm for senior management teams in school's to be exclusively white. Is it appropriate to have told, albeit implicitly, that those best placed to lead are white? We teach a national curriculum but part of the hidden curriculum is self loathing in the non white community.

Mars · 26/08/2016 21:25
Mars · 26/08/2016 21:26

Can't believe she's 18!!!!!! Space Fairy is 18 in 2 today. Our wee girls are not so wee.

themoreiseeyou · 26/08/2016 21:32

61% of the inner London population is BAME (Black, Asian, Minority ethnic); 51% outer London. It is almost the norm for senior management teams in schools to be exclusively white. Is it appropriate to be told, albeit implicitly, that those best placed to lead are white? We teach a national curriculum but part of the hidden curriculum is self loathing in the non white community.

proofread this time.

Curvymumzy37 · 26/08/2016 21:35

I totally understand where you are coming from, my son who is 17 went through this over 10 years ago and has suffered a fair bit of racism throughout his who school years.

Unless you have mixed race children you will never fully understand, no race should be ignored, but when you can't identify especially as a child with someone on TV, magazines etc that child will begin to think ' oh this is how i should look' it's hard to come by any books,dolls, tv shows that a mixed race child can relate too! Her little girl may if been modelling but again that world is mainly white. Things are changing slowly! But not quick enough!

Cannonbear · 26/08/2016 21:39

Cannot believe someone on this thread said they were black on the inside.

Katymac · 26/08/2016 21:39

Not quick enough at all

A vast number of the cast of the lion king come from abroad as there aren't enough trained dancers in this country who are not white; when DD is trained she will have a vast number of shows to audition for as the school just can't keep up with the demand for non-white performers (Thriller, Bodyguard, Dreamgirls, Memphis) maybe the West End is more diverse?

Katymac · 26/08/2016 21:40

Sent you a PM (or 2) Mars...

Charley50 · 26/08/2016 23:03

I really liked Home, a Dreamworks animated kids film, starring Rhianna as the voice of the (mixed-race) protagonist.

pollymere · 29/08/2016 00:04

When my half Chinese daughter was in nursery someone suggested her self portrait should have yellow skin. It went well with the green eyes and orange hair they suggested too. My daughter's response to me was confusion as she knew she wasn't yellow and that her hair wasn't orange. I made sure her infant school was full of kids who were mixed race so that she felt proud of her own skin. It also stopped the you don't look Chinese comments too. You need to make sure yours isn't the token kid, otherwise they will feel different.

haloumi · 30/08/2016 08:33

I'm pretty sure this is MORE an advert for the modelling agency than a bleeding heart sob story it started out as. . . .

themoreiseeyou · 30/08/2016 08:51

Representation and positive images start in the workplace. Images in the media are controlled by a few people, mostly in London, who have no contact with any world that is not white, middle class and Oxbridge educated. So it's no surprise, even though the population of Greater London is 51% BAME, that there are so few positive images in the media of Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic people.

Katymac · 30/08/2016 16:29

Doesn't really matter as log as attention is brought to a situation which is unfair and wrong

elward · 05/10/2018 14:18

MadisonMongomery, I'm not sure I understand your statement, 80% of the population is white 'your not sure what she expects'. The POINT of the company was that she didn't expect anything, the point is that she got up and did something about the fact that her daughter isn't be represented. Just because 80% of the population is white doesn't mean the other 20% shouldn't be represented. 80/90% of the population in South Africa is black you wouldn't of expected something like Apartied to have existed but it did, you're comment is a tad annoying if honest.....

Xenia · 15/10/2018 17:33

What a lovely story. My son was the only white boy in his class (in London) a few years ago although that is a differnt thing in England compared say to Nigeria where I have sometimes worked where I would be unusual because I were white.

The advertising I see is not reflective of people - it has a vast number more of people who are not white than in the UK but perhaps it is just regional directed at my bit of minority white London.

Where I am from there are not that many people who are not white - Northumberland is 97% white and yet TV shows like Vera put non white characters in so often it is utterly ludicrous and makes it hard to believe the story.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page