Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Guest post: Nicky Morgan – "Strike action will harm children's education"

119 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 05/07/2016 10:05

I am disappointed that the National Union of Teachers has chosen the path of disruption over negotiation and discussion. I believe this strike action is unnecessary and counterproductive – it will harm children's education, inconvenience parents and damage the profession's reputation in the eyes of the public.

We are already in regular and constructive talks with the NUT and, as I said when I attended the first meeting in May, I am committed to these talks and firmly hope that they will be meaningful and productive. Rather than playing politics with children's futures over the issue of pay and conditions, I urged the NUT to reconsider this damaging industrial action. Instead we should all be focused on giving children the best start in life and spreading educational excellence everywhere.

It has been clearly outlined in our conversations that the removal of unnecessary workload for teachers is a priority for this government , and our extensive work with the NUT, along with the wider profession, is helping to ensure that teachers can concentrate on what they do best.

The NUT has said that the Government has the wrong priorities for teachers, schools and children. To suggest we aren't prioritising school funding is disingenuous; the significance we place on education is demonstrated by the fact that we are investing more than any previous government on our schools. This year the schools budget will total around £40billion, an increase of around £4billion since 2011-12, so it is now the highest it has ever been. Additionally, the schools budget has been protected in real terms going forward. At a time when other areas of spending are having to be reduced in order to control the public finances, education has rightly been protected, reflecting precisely where our priorities lie.

It is also disappointing that the underpinning basis for this strike seems to be teacher pay. Average teacher pay is £37,800. Last week's school workforce figures showed that teaching continues to be an attractive career with more teachers in our schools than ever before – 15,000 more since 2010 – demonstrating how many people relish the prospect of a career where they can transform lives every day.

Under the academy system, schools have more flexibility to reward teachers for their hard work, allowing them to keep their best staff and recruit the brightest talent. We remain committed to our vision for an academy-run system where the best school leaders are free to innovate and run their schools how they choose. This commitment is fully funded. Taking the Spending Review and the Budget together, we have set aside the funding to support a high quality, school system where every school is an academy. Overall, we have made £600 million available in this Parliament to build capacity – including recruiting excellent sponsors and encouraging the development of strong multi-academy trusts.

Teachers are integral to our vision of delivering educational excellence everywhere and, thanks to their hard work, over 1.4 million more children are in good or outstanding schools than in August 2010. We will always listen and discuss legitimate concerns within the sector and try to resolve them as quickly and fairly as possible.

OP posts:
Trenzalor · 05/07/2016 20:03

Last year I asked for and got a modest £300 budget for my subject area (non-core subject in primary) - I kept it low as we were getting a renovation done which complemented my subject area. This year I asked for £500 as its a subject where things are used and need replacing. I, and all my colleagues, got £0. This is after a new curriculum that meant a great deal of resources became irrelevant and needed replacing.
We can't recruit enough teachers and have us to resort to employing a minimum of three supply teachers a week.
There are more problems, but it's just too depressing to go into. I will probably be quitting teaching soon. I love it, but this privatisation of education is seriously harming children and I won't be a part of it.

Timeforanewname2014 · 05/07/2016 20:09

I havn't posted for months but just reset my password to say this! I am a parent, not a teacher but fully, 110% back the teachers. My two children have wonderful, supportive teachers who help them shine every day, in circumstance being made increasingly difficult by you Nicky Morgan.

kavvLar · 05/07/2016 20:17

I am a parent not a teacher. I fully support the strike. Teachers are being asked to deliver far too much and the poor children are paying for it. Little lambs that should be playing, instead they are being hot housed for tests.

Asprilla11 · 05/07/2016 20:23

Nicky Morgan I agree with you, Teachers are being paid a salary that is not warranted.

They do a noble, very important and demanding job. Far more important than an MP. I believe the starting salary for a Teacher should be £74,962 and an MP should start on £37,000.

HTH

Flisspaps · 05/07/2016 20:32

"Unfortunately, Nicky Morgan's schedule this afternoon and evening means her office now can't confirm that she will be able to respond."

Not a surprise really is it? This hasn't really gone the way they envisaged - they wouldn't have agreed to the Guest Post unless they'd assumed we'd all (or at least a majority) be on side.

Mishaps · 05/07/2016 20:38

No it won't harm their education - the current education system is harming them. A day off from learning irrelevant stuff will do them no harm at all.

What IS doing them harm is the stress induced in teachers and children by the current system of levels and tests and artificial targets. The rise in mental health problems among children is no coincidence. How can you rest easy when this is happening on your name?

You need to stop micro-managing education and let the professionals get on with what they do best - they know more about educating children than you do and you need to take a hands-off/let's try trusting the professionals approach.

Would it be appropriate for a non-doctor to micromanage the content of doctors' consultations? - of course not, people would die. Why then is it appropriate for non-professionals to micromanage what goes on in schools? It is just an insult to the profession and a dangerous way to proceed.

I feel so sorry for these poor children being force-fed information that gains them nothing and is often inappropriate to their age.

Here's one for you........how is it that a brilliant teacher who has a class with a high preponderance of pupils with special needs gets no pay increment because her pupils cannot reach the prescribed level in spite of the fact that they have made excellent progress within their abilities and that her teaching is exceptional? ........and her colleague who has a class of really bright pupils who sail through the levels gets the increment, in spite of the fact that it involves less effort? I would love to hear the answer to that.

When children do well at school and are happy and confident it is in spite of the government's interventions, not because of them. Time to take a back seat and let teachers teach - and accord them the value and esteem that they deserve.

Boogers · 05/07/2016 21:07

Nicky, you put so much sugar onto the bullshit you feed to the press releases that it almost seems like you believe it. Even with all that sugar, bullshit is still bullshit.

£37k average salary? What planet are you living on?

You thought you could come on Mumsnet, pay for a slot at the top of the page to put your views forward and everyone would kneel down at your feet and say "sorry Nicky, we were wrong"? Nope, doesn't happen like that.

You are just wrong on so many levels I don't even know where to start. I'm just glad you're not running for leader of the Tories.

Londonmamabychance · 05/07/2016 21:35

Nicky Morgan, you are the one playing politics instead of focusing on giving children the best start in life. Nothing about the current cuts, reforms or forced academisation will make education better for children, on the contrary, it will make it worse. Anyone who actually teaches, or who has spend time studying PISA results or other teaching literature will tell you that the route you're going down in detrimental to the quality of education in this country. Look at Finland, the country on top of all PISA ranking tables and you will see the exact opposite of the situation here: Respect for teachers, shirt school days with high quality lessons, much less testing and much less focus on evaluation. But of course, Nicky Morgan isn't interested in the quality of education in the country but only in her own political career. To accuse teachers of being selfish would be laughable if it wasn't so rude and rich coming from her.

KateMumsnet · 05/07/2016 21:37

@Boogers

You thought you could come on Mumsnet, pay for a slot at the top of the page to put your views forward and everyone would kneel down at your feet and say "sorry Nicky, we were wrong"? Nope, doesn't happen like that.

Hi Boogers - just to clarify, guest posts are never paid for.

LineyReborn · 05/07/2016 21:40

Nicky Morgan has scraped the bottom of the barrel here.

The whole thing is now even worse than the Ruth Kelly and Ed Balls years.

WifeofDarth · 05/07/2016 22:01

Thanks for your post Nicky Morgan. It has given me the opportunity to say that as a parent of 2 in primary school I absolutely support the teachers who went on strike today.
I can see how they are expected to do more with less, and they do their absolute best, but the job is far too stressful, and every year we say goodbye to amazing teachers who leave the profession.
I have also seen how the lack of investment affects the children. We're in a borough held by a conservative council - the council has sold off at least 4 school sites (and 2 sites that could have been converted to schools) that I know of. Our school has therefore been forced to double capacity. The result is that the kids have very little playground left, and moving through the school is a logistical nightmare.
Please start listening to the teachers - you never know, you just might learn something.

SteffWR · 05/07/2016 22:04

In Wales so don't have the same issues but this is why we've decided to homeschool early years. We believe that the education sector is too underfunded and too understaffed to give good quality education catered to the ability and aptitude of each child in the class as they should do according to the Education Act 1996. It's not ideal for us to homeschool but the quality of education is important to give kids the best start in life and we'll figure it out.

kelper · 05/07/2016 22:14

I support the strike.
My foster DS did his GCSEs this year. He attended two out of 9, because, and I quote, "I'm going to fail anyway mum"
He was spectacularly let down by his birth parents, the 5, yes 5, primary schools he attended who couldn't cope with such an angry child, the two high schools who also couldn't cope with such an angry child, and chose to suspend him rather than try and deal with him. He won't get C's in his English and Maths. He'll waste his and his lecturers time in september, still not getting his C's, when in reality he should be allowed to leave education and get a job.
My own DS is still in primary school, but we're already finding out what happens when you employ sub-standard cheaper teachers, who don't care. Its absolutely disgusting, and I hope you do read this, and realise how much damage you and Gove have done.
I'm seriously considering home education for my DS.

NoMudNoLotus · 05/07/2016 22:44

I respect the teachers in my DCs school because they chose not to strike.

They are no different to any other teachers - but still put our DC first.

I have the utmost respect for them.

How many of those teachers that went on strike today actually stayed on the picket line???? Strike by all means - but don't piss parents off by going & getting your nails done , which is what I know a previous teacher has done.

SausageSmuggler · 05/07/2016 22:53

The fact that you have come on here and spouted this horse shite, I presume with the aim of getting us onside, just goes to show how out of touch you are with reality.

My daughter starts school in September and adores art, imaginative play and being outdoors. I'm dreading her school life for the thought that she won't be able to thrive in things she loves.

Get yourself to some schools and open your eyes.

heavenlypink · 05/07/2016 22:57

The rigid structure of the curriculum these days leaves no room the the 'nurturing' some children need. Without this they are doomed to fail. The SATs were on the whole cruel - except spelling which was actually easy! The maths was 'doable' though to answer all the questions on the arithmetic paper in the given time was a challenge. However the English paper was an utter farce! The new English SPAG curriculum teaching children (YES CHILDREN) work that is at least year ahead is crazy. You constant demands on schools are actually bullying.

Children have missed out today. Sports Days, school trips, end of year celebrations will be happening. Some children will have missed out on a free school meal. Some children could well have been left 'home alone' as parents could not afford to take a day off work.

Politicians have no idea at all of life in the real world.

I propose a Monty Brewster box on the next ballot paper

*NONE OF THE ABOVE
*
..... because right now you are all showing how incompetent politicians really are!!!

BlueEyeshadow · 05/07/2016 22:59

Nicky Morgan didn't come back to comment last time she spouted her bile on MN, so I doubt she's reading the answers here. Really wish she would though. So much more sense on here than in the DfE!

hideouspain · 05/07/2016 23:29

Nicky,

No-one believes this crap. Even you don't. If you did, you would reply...

Sixweekstowait · 05/07/2016 23:37

Well it's all been said hasn't it but I do wonder how many children had their education ruined two weeks ago when their schools were used as polling stations - didn't hear you mention anything then Nicky. Also when are we going to get a SS for Education who understands the concept of 'average' ?

BackforGood · 05/07/2016 23:46

I can't make up my mind if you think it's ok to just lie, or if you can really, truely be this ignorant about education Confused

hmmmum · 05/07/2016 23:46

I support the strike. What's one day of missed school compared to the damage inflicted on education by this government?

Slippersandacuppa · 06/07/2016 00:08

Nicky

Because of you, I am seriously considering homeschooling my four children. Thanks to a truly wonderful school with lovely teachers, my eldest (Yr 4) loves his time at school. I am so worried that that is going to change. Quickly.

I sat in on a meeting with our governors. We aren't in a deprived area. So we receive roughly half the funding of the school two miles up the road, per child. We attained outstanding in our last Ofsted visit. So we receive less funding. We have areas of the school in depsperate need of maintenance but our capital budget has been slashed from £33k to £6k per Annum. We had to rely on our PTA to raise funds for new IT equipment. We can't even find the money to properly stock our library.

Our classes our oversubscribed, our classrooms cramped.

But the two things that worry me the most are:

1, Those wonderful teachers I mentioned are burning out. They care about the children so struggle to fit everything in, arriving early and finishing late. And then try to squeeze all the extra, fun and IMPORTANT things on top. They can't carry on - I know of so many who are thinking of leaving.

2, This system is absolutely not fostering a love of learning. There's no scope for my six year old to dig around in a topic as much as he'd like to or my eight year old to spend extra time on the subjects he enjoys. You are snubbing out my children's' curiosity.

I watched you on the news today. Just to be clear, I am 100% behind the teachers today. All the parents I know are behind them and (I couldn't work out if you'd suggested the next bit as a joke!) I'd like to meet a pupil who disagreed with them!

I would love for you to come and visit our school. I'd be happy to go through all the figures with you and show you round our classrooms.

I bet you'd be surprised.

Slippersandacuppa · 06/07/2016 00:09

Apologies for the typos. Tired.

AndNowItsSeven · 06/07/2016 00:12

I am another parent who fully supports the teachers. My year six child is autistic , this year has involved so many tears and anxiety thanks to the new sats. My dd was so distressed she had to take the tests in a private room. She like a pp has poor handwriting due to her Asd and told me last week she knows her teacher assessment marked her down due to this. She had tears streaming down her face as she spoke to me.
So don't you say you care about my daughters education because you don't ,not one bit.

Asprilla11 · 06/07/2016 04:33

I think it's safe to say the reaction to this guest post is AngryAngryAngry