Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Guest post: "My little boy is a gorgeous, sparkling Lady Gaga - and he already feels judged"

65 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 08/04/2015 11:01

Lady Gaga woke me up at 6.24am this morning.

She stormed into my room, platinum hair waving, four-inch glitter platforms thudding, high-pitched voice proclaiming that "the show was about to begin NOW"; we must all go downstairs IMMEDIATELY or we'll miss it.

She can be a serious diva, that Gaga. She demands a full house for every single one of her thrice-daily performances; she insists on at least five costume changes per show; she has a wardrobe bursting with bling; she never wears fewer than six spangling earrings and eight diamanté necklaces at a time. She also has an insatiable desire for ice-cream, a violent dislike of spinach, a hatred of bedtime and requires at least two stories before going to sleep at night.

She also only exists in our house. Her personality is so large that she longs to venture out into the wilds of Hackney and proclaim her Diva-dom to the world. But even Gaga isn't impervious to the one thing that strikes fear into the strongest of Diva's hearts - the judgement of her public.

Our Gaga knows that she's expected to look and act a different way: she 'shouldn't' be wearing her new eye-shadow; she 'shouldn't' be perfecting her hip wiggle dance move. Instead, she 'should' be wearing trousers; she 'should' be playing football; she should not, in fact, be calling herself a 'she' at all. Even at just five-years-old, this splendid specimen of all things sparkly is expected to hide her light under a gender stereotype.

And I've battled with this conflict myself, too. All any parent wants for their child is an easy life (in the best sense of the word) and for them to be safe and happy. We had a conviction that we'd never force our boy to be anything other than who he wanted to be, yet, when this conviction was tested, we found ourselves trying to resist fuelling his 'girly' requests. If he wanted to buy a princess magazine so he could add the attached pink lipstick to his collection, we'd try to steer him towards Spiderman or pirates. I even suggested to his best friend's mum that maybe they could buy our boy a football for his fifth birthday, because it might encourage him to play the sport. I found myself battling with prejudices I didn't even know I had.

His dad and I eventually decided that it was best that he didn't wear his 'girl's stuff' outside the house. We'd seen how it hurt our boy when his friends laughed as Gaga made her grand entrance at home - how would strangers react on the street? Instead, we explained again and again that different people like different things and tried to build up his glimmering armour.

When it became clear that our boy's passion for tutus, high heels and dresses wasn't just a brief phase, we agreed that he could wear some stuff outside the house - hair-clips, jewellery, and the more practical accessories - but by that point, he'd already decided that he didn't want to. He'd received too many questioning stares from his reception classmates when he'd tried to dress up in the princess costumes at break-time, or wear the paper flowers in his hair at craft-time.

A year on, our diva is stronger than ever. We've learnt to fully embrace and be proud of our boy's inner and outer Gaga. Her full glory may still just exist inside our house (our boy's choice, not ours), but her influence extends way beyond that. Put simply, she makes our bejewelled boy happy - and he can kick some serious arse on any dancefloor. He invites his trusted friends to Gaga's exclusive shows and has even accepted a couple of them as 'backing dancers'. Superhero toys are now stowed in our daughter's room (she's two and her favourite word is 'Batman'), replaced by many, grin-inducing Barbies.

I recently read something interesting: when Barbie was first released in 1959, guess who begged to be bought this gloriously shimmery vision in pink? Boys. Way more boys than girls. So, G.I. Joe was born. The boys still wanted Barbies, but they were bought the Macho Man instead. I wonder how many other young boys are struggling with what they 'should' be doing, wearing or being. As parents, all we can do is support them - and try and make life easier for these courageous non-conformists by helping them to choose for themselves.

OP posts:
JeanneDeMontbaston · 08/04/2015 15:45

Why do you think it's an April Fool - other than the date? Confused

Btw, to clarify what I said before: I have no reason to think MNHQ don't contact bloggers to ask them for guest posts. I just know they've mentioned before that OPs of Guest Posts don't always know when their post has been put up - just that it'll happen at some point.

Sorry if that was confusing. I only know because they mentioned it on another thread about Guest Posts, when someone complained that the OPs never seem to get very engaged with responses.

munchkinmaster · 08/04/2015 15:45

I feel a bit bad after skimming the blog.

Op your choices are your own and it's not for me to judge. I would not be brave or confident enough to open up like you have.,

wannaBe · 08/04/2015 15:53

because that post bears no resemblence what so ever to the rest of the blog. Yes, its clear the op has had a hard time in the past, but this just doesn't add up in context to the rest of it.

mammamic · 08/04/2015 15:55

Great insight. I had alter egos as a child - boys and girls. When girls do the gender thing, so much less fuss is made.

I'm amazed at how many psychologists are on this thread Wink

If a child is happy, feels loved, safe and secure and knows their parents adore and support them, they will grow into well adjusted happy adults, regardless of how they dress or refer to themselves.

TheWildRumpyPumpus · 08/04/2015 16:11

4 inch heels are not ever sold for 5 year old children, surely?

LucySMumsnet · 08/04/2015 17:09

Hi everyone,

Just a quick one to clarify - the blogger was happy for us to publish this guest post, and knew it was being posted today. Appreciate that the publication date on her blog has caused some confusion, but we're confident the post isn't a joke.

26Point2Miles · 08/04/2015 17:43

mummyis the op wrote this to be published publicly, so yes, it is up to us how we perceive it and how we discuss it!!

'Embrace your child' well yes, but early waking and demanding behaviour impact on others as well as kicking/punching/biting.... So this child needs a parent to discipline him and to be managing his behaviour, not letting him trample over everyone!

In our house my dc have siblings, parents who sometimes work night shifts.... They can't be allowed to wake the whole house at 6.24 for some 'show' Hmm

MsDarksbane · 08/04/2015 18:53

I'm going to respond to this as if it were actually true, although I'm dubious as to whether it is or not.

Honestly, apart from the things you as a parent have allowed (possibly, if it's true) such as a make-up collection, heeled shoes and wardrobe full of 'bling' (really?) nothing here strikes me as out of the ordinary for a child of that age engaging in imaginative role play. If every child who liked to dress up as someone of the opposite sex turned out to be transgender, we'd have an awful lot more transgender people about. All this pandering, and calling him 'she' is ridiculous.

As for the getting everyone out of bed at 6.24 in the morning for a 'show' - that would go down like a lead balloon in this house. As would demanding everyone watch him perform three times a day.

Someone needs to do a bit less pandering and a bit more parenting - being a diva is not a good trait, regardless of your gender.

ArcheryAnnie · 08/04/2015 20:23

OP, on your home blog you have this post tagged as "transexual kids". Are you genuinely approaching this with the idea that your child is trans, or might you be convinced by this thread that playing with alter egos and different identities is a very unremarkable activity that many children do?

SouthWestmom · 08/04/2015 20:31

Oh god why is this even a thing? It's so boring to read about people thinking they are so bloody different for 'letting' their boys dress up in tutus. Maybe if you didn't go overboard about how special and different you are you'd notice the rest of us with our boys with painted nails, wearing fairy wings, doing ballet, and growing their hair long?

AppleAndBlackberry · 08/04/2015 21:14

Not sure this was a great choice of blog posts Mumsnet, I've read some of the rest of the blog and she does seem a bit vulnerable/struggling?? I'm concerned about the effect of all the criticism on this thread on the blogger.

26Point2Miles · 08/04/2015 21:20

It's all so attention seeking.... The guest post not the kid....

Mrsflippity · 08/04/2015 21:51

It's all too easy to forget to be kind with the perceived anonymity of the Internet as protection. But this piece was written by a woman who clearly cares for and worries about her child just as we all do and some of the comments here are hurtful and judgemental. Shame, it could have been a chance to relate and reassure. She clearly refers to her son as a boy... The use of 'she' refers to him dressing as Lady Gaga, 'diva' can have other connotations - in this case I took it to relate to him mimicking a popstar rather than being badly behaved. I found this piece to be moving and thought-provoking and I wish the writer well.

grannytomine · 08/04/2015 22:31

My son was always big and very masculine looking, no chance of anyone thinking he was a girl but he went through the being a princess phase. Never has a child looked so inappropriate in flouncy dresses, think heavy weight boxer in drag. We just let him dress up and at some stage it stopped, I think he was sixish but honestly can't remember.

Fortunately he never demanded we watch him dance at stupid o'clock as saying no can cause offence.

His big brothers still tease him about it sometimes although they took no notice at the time, they were old enough to know better.

maud876 · 08/04/2015 22:52

I do think gender sterotyping is very bad now.
When my children were growing up in the 70s and 80s there were loads of toys suitable for both boys and girls.
My eldest son was very girly, loved dressing up and playing babies with his sisters. I bought him an action man and all they did with it with hold weddings and marry it to barbie.
He wanted to wear a skirt for school and when I explained it probably wasn't a good idea, this was in the 80s remember, he asked if he could have a kilt.
He's still not what I would call a macho male, he just bought a sewing machine to make his own clothes, but is married with 2 sons and seems very happy.
I would go with it, maybe explaining that some things aren't suitable outside the home.
Did go through a stage where I and his sisters wondered if he was gay.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page