Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Guest post: "My little boy is a gorgeous, sparkling Lady Gaga - and he already feels judged"

65 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 08/04/2015 11:01

Lady Gaga woke me up at 6.24am this morning.

She stormed into my room, platinum hair waving, four-inch glitter platforms thudding, high-pitched voice proclaiming that "the show was about to begin NOW"; we must all go downstairs IMMEDIATELY or we'll miss it.

She can be a serious diva, that Gaga. She demands a full house for every single one of her thrice-daily performances; she insists on at least five costume changes per show; she has a wardrobe bursting with bling; she never wears fewer than six spangling earrings and eight diamanté necklaces at a time. She also has an insatiable desire for ice-cream, a violent dislike of spinach, a hatred of bedtime and requires at least two stories before going to sleep at night.

She also only exists in our house. Her personality is so large that she longs to venture out into the wilds of Hackney and proclaim her Diva-dom to the world. But even Gaga isn't impervious to the one thing that strikes fear into the strongest of Diva's hearts - the judgement of her public.

Our Gaga knows that she's expected to look and act a different way: she 'shouldn't' be wearing her new eye-shadow; she 'shouldn't' be perfecting her hip wiggle dance move. Instead, she 'should' be wearing trousers; she 'should' be playing football; she should not, in fact, be calling herself a 'she' at all. Even at just five-years-old, this splendid specimen of all things sparkly is expected to hide her light under a gender stereotype.

And I've battled with this conflict myself, too. All any parent wants for their child is an easy life (in the best sense of the word) and for them to be safe and happy. We had a conviction that we'd never force our boy to be anything other than who he wanted to be, yet, when this conviction was tested, we found ourselves trying to resist fuelling his 'girly' requests. If he wanted to buy a princess magazine so he could add the attached pink lipstick to his collection, we'd try to steer him towards Spiderman or pirates. I even suggested to his best friend's mum that maybe they could buy our boy a football for his fifth birthday, because it might encourage him to play the sport. I found myself battling with prejudices I didn't even know I had.

His dad and I eventually decided that it was best that he didn't wear his 'girl's stuff' outside the house. We'd seen how it hurt our boy when his friends laughed as Gaga made her grand entrance at home - how would strangers react on the street? Instead, we explained again and again that different people like different things and tried to build up his glimmering armour.

When it became clear that our boy's passion for tutus, high heels and dresses wasn't just a brief phase, we agreed that he could wear some stuff outside the house - hair-clips, jewellery, and the more practical accessories - but by that point, he'd already decided that he didn't want to. He'd received too many questioning stares from his reception classmates when he'd tried to dress up in the princess costumes at break-time, or wear the paper flowers in his hair at craft-time.

A year on, our diva is stronger than ever. We've learnt to fully embrace and be proud of our boy's inner and outer Gaga. Her full glory may still just exist inside our house (our boy's choice, not ours), but her influence extends way beyond that. Put simply, she makes our bejewelled boy happy - and he can kick some serious arse on any dancefloor. He invites his trusted friends to Gaga's exclusive shows and has even accepted a couple of them as 'backing dancers'. Superhero toys are now stowed in our daughter's room (she's two and her favourite word is 'Batman'), replaced by many, grin-inducing Barbies.

I recently read something interesting: when Barbie was first released in 1959, guess who begged to be bought this gloriously shimmery vision in pink? Boys. Way more boys than girls. So, G.I. Joe was born. The boys still wanted Barbies, but they were bought the Macho Man instead. I wonder how many other young boys are struggling with what they 'should' be doing, wearing or being. As parents, all we can do is support them - and try and make life easier for these courageous non-conformists by helping them to choose for themselves.

OP posts:
Woozlebear · 08/04/2015 14:15

I'm really uncomfortable that the op says she and the father decided the girls clothes should be worn inside the house only, and then say it's her ds's choice a year later to only behave like this at home. Of course has has- because his parents basically told him it was something to be ashamed of.

Ditto other posts re diva behaviour and the op reading too much into this being a trans thing.

Woozlebear · 08/04/2015 14:15

I'm really uncomfortable that the op says she and the father decided the girls clothes should be worn inside the house only, and then say it's her ds's choice a year later to only behave like this at home. Of course has has- because his parents basically told him it was something to be ashamed of.

Ditto other posts re diva behaviour and the op reading too much into this being a trans thing.

babybelling · 08/04/2015 14:21

This is about the BLO - the Barbie Liberation Organisation - that swapped voiceboxes between GI Joe and Teen Talk Barbie, and then put them back on the shelves:

wannaBe · 08/04/2015 14:26

where do mn find these people? Hmm sometimes I wonder if these 'guest posts' are deliberately invented to spark a debate....

Waking the household with demands at 6 AM wouldn't be tolerated in my house, regardless of what the demand was for. I suspect that if people start to distance themselves it won't be because he's dressing up as lady gaga it will be because you are bringing him up to be a demanding spoiled brat.

and lady gaga is not appropriate viewing for a five year old. And no, I would be a bit Hmm at a five year old girl plastered in eye shaddow and four inch heels as well.

HairyPottyMouth · 08/04/2015 14:36

Maybe Gaga is calling herself SHE? He is pretending to be a girl. He's playing a character. If it turns out he is a heterosexual male, fine, if he turns out to be trans, fine. Who gives a fuck? My 3 yo boy has worn make up, wants to be a mummy and loves his 'children' and makes dresses out of blankets. He's walked round in my heels and Daddy's shoes. Kids like playing. As for 6.40 am concerts, sod that!

almondcakes · 08/04/2015 14:37

Jeanne, I have never seen a girl dressed in the way the OP describes.

I do think MN puts up blog posts like this to cause controversy. The blog is linked to, and I can't see this in any context other than the info about the interactions between the son and daughter, yet he is 'she.'

I really question MN setting up threads about blogs. There has to be a dividing line somewhere over personal info about an individual andtheir kids.

OneHappyBunny · 08/04/2015 14:37

but isn't the OP's point that plenty of parents would let little girls dress up like this and no-one bats an eyelid?

I've never seen a little girl dressed up like that.

JeanneDeMontbaston · 08/04/2015 14:39

Crikey. I must live somewhere odd, then. Though, I admit, the glitter platforms sound naff as fuck, I have seen babies in heels, let alone five year olds.

I'm not defending it (obviously). I am just trying to understand the OP's post, because I am guessing she isn't a regular MNer and may not have expected the responses to centre on telling her she's a bad mother for letting her child wear heels.

JeanneDeMontbaston · 08/04/2015 14:43

Btw, I don't know if it matters, but I remember MNHQ explaining one time that bloggers' guest posts are sometimes written in advance and then put up, so the OP of this one may not even have seen that this is being discussed yet.

I guess that is why I feel a bit defensive of her. I do get what people are saying, too.

OneHappyBunny · 08/04/2015 14:49

Babies in heels? Oh that's sad.

I think the 'she' in the Lady Gaga is stylistic, on third reading.

OP's blog is quite sad. Her DS has apparently been waking up at 5.30 for 6 months and The thing is, he really is an arsehole most of the time. He cannot take ‘no’ for an answer; his response is to kick, bite, scratch, punch HARD and then laugh at any response I give him.

:(

almondcakes · 08/04/2015 14:49

I think the blogger in question is very vulnerable, which I hadn't realised when I first posted on here. I do question the wisdom of linking to blog without speaking to the blogger first.

wannaBe · 08/04/2015 14:50

not sure that anyone has suggested she's a bad mother for letting her child wear heels, tbh I think it's a lot more Hmm that she is advocating allowing her child to demand to give performances whenever he wants including at the crack of dawn. he sounds as if he will be labelled as a demanding brat before too long while his mother sits back and smiles at his spiritedness. Wink

babybelling · 08/04/2015 14:53

I have seen babies in heels

God, Jeanne, how depressing.

JeanneDeMontbaston · 08/04/2015 14:54

Ah, fair enough, wannabe, I read it differently.

almond, thanks for the heads up. I hope she's ok.

whitecandles · 08/04/2015 14:54

I've worked in reception and year one and a lot of boys wore princess stuff during dress up and no one noticed or cared.

These were majority muslim schools in deprived areas as well.

CallMeMaybe · 08/04/2015 14:54

well then perhaps the op needs to be seeking some parenting advice to deal with his behavior because it really will only get worse.

n
And yes, mn hq need to think about who they put up as guest bloggers, and why they think it's appropriate to put someone's life on quite such public display. Don't get me wrong I am well aware that the internet is a public platform, and that if the op is part of the mn bloggers network she most likely has her blog available to be read by the public, but that's a different situation from taking a specific blog post, posting it on mn's front page for everyone to read, and comment on at will..

And the term "guest blogger" gives the impression that the blogger has been asked to write this blog post specifically for the guest blog spot, whereas it appears that some guest bloggers might not even be aware that they have been guested until they are torn to shreds on here and sometimes even on social media.

Crossfitmyarse · 08/04/2015 15:02

My little boy when he was around 5 used to dress up as various Disney heroines as well. I was tasked with finding the appropriate items to replicate the outfits to his exacting standards from my own wardrobe.

It didn't last long and I always thought it was quite sweet.

I ma not sure that Lady Gaga, wonderful though she is, is an entirely appropriate role model for a 5 year old though? Regardless of his gender? It's all a bit much at that age, don't you think, all that gyrating and the Danny La Rue double entendre schtick?

OneHappyBunny · 08/04/2015 15:02

The original post was dated 1st April on the blog.

babybelling · 08/04/2015 15:07

I don't think it's an April Fool though, OneHappy. (Or if it is, it's not a very good one.)

wannaBe · 08/04/2015 15:07

have just noticed that. and have just read through the blog, and can't see the post referenced above? Confused but I suspect that perhaps it wasn't meant as a serious post anyway (april fool anyone?) and mn have just been fooled. Grin

MummyIsMyFavouriteName · 08/04/2015 15:09

Wow, these comments are depressing to read!

Yes, waking them up at 6:30 may seem like being a "spoiled brat" as so many of you called her DC but my DD wakes me up every morning and I probably woke my DPs up at a time they thought was stupidly early when I was 5. You all probably did it too!

The post was not about your opinions on her parenting style. In fact, it's not even about your opinions on her son dressing like a girl at home. It's her writing a blog post about her son. For all you know, he asked them to call her "she" and you can't tell her that watching Lady Gaga is inappropriate, she is on the radio all the time and on the music video channels. Maybe he loves her music so that's why they call him that...

Having eye shadow and heels is not a big deal. I had make up and heels at five (designed for children I would like to point out before you all start slating my mother) so I don't see anything wrong with it!

None of you know the full story of this little boy. She said she didn't let him dress like a girl out of the house because she wanted to protect him from judgemental people, not because they wanted him to know he should be ashamed of it and to keep it secret.

Maybe instead of focusing on what you all perceive to be bad parenting, concentrate on the message she is trying to put across. Her son may well be transgender, he may not. The point is to embrace your child no matter what and to show them you accept them and love them unconditionally for who they are.

wannaBe · 08/04/2015 15:16

mummy have you read the rest of her blog? and the fact that this post was posted on april fools day?

Even if this was a serious post, while waking up your parents at 6:30 is one thing we have probably all been through, it's the pandering to this and the rushing out of bed to the demands of needing to witness a performance which will ensure that this child grows up to exhibit brattish behavior. Children need to learn that their behavior isn't always cute or endearing, and while most might give in to a performance during the day, I doubt many would consider it cute at 6:30 in the morning.

babybelling · 08/04/2015 15:19

Have you read our posts, MummyIs? Many of us have said how normal this experimenting with dress is, and nobody here has suggested that the guest blogger try and make this boy conform to any gender stereotypes. Some have suggested that he be persuaded to behave with more consideration in the very early mornings, but this is MN, after all. (And I agree with them.)

If you start a separate thread on "should tiny children be allowed to wear makeup and high heels?", you will get a lot of responses, not all of whom will be in agreement with you. Same on this thread. And that's fine.

emotionsecho · 08/04/2015 15:34

I'm with other posters thinking this could be an April Fool.

Also agree that eye-shadow, six spangling earrings and vertiginous high heeled shoes are inappropriate for a child of 5 irrespective of whether they are a boy or a girl. It's all rather depressingly like those child pageants in USA where very young children are made up to within an inch of their lives.

Demanding the audience sit through three performances a day with at least five costume changes per 'show', hmm.

wannaBe · 08/04/2015 15:40

if this is an april fool then mn need to pull it asap. There is a link to the op's blog on here, with references to the hard time she has gone through with her dc, references to her netmums username, essentially her online identity is on that blog, and presumably if mn have decided of their own acord which posts are guest blog posts then the poster is unaware that far more people than usual will have had an insight into her life, even if the post above was meant to be a joke.