Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

General health

Mumsnet doesn't verify the qualifications of users. If you have medical concerns, please consult a healthcare professional.

Can an optician legally withhold my prescription?!

12 replies

TwoDrifters2 · 27/02/2023 09:37

First of all, apologies for the length of this post but I’ll try to include all relevant info!

I had a contact lens check-up 3 weeks ago. The optician at the time noted that I’ve never ordered lenses through them and I explained that I get them online because I don’t wear them every day, a pack of 30 can last me anything up to 3-4 months and I just find it easier and cheaper to order them myself as and when I need them.

He went on to give me a long speech about how people ordering online is wrecking his business and how it actually costs him money to give contact lens checkups, and how he understands there is a cost of living crisis but that he needs to make a living himself somehow etc. and I ended up feeling really guilty and ordered my next contact lenses with him there and then (even whilst feeling slightly manipulated at the time!)

When I told him the price of the lenses I usually get, he said he couldn’t match that but we agreed to try some different and slightly cheaper lenses to see whether I got on with them.

I life rurally so instead of just having them sail through my door like normal, I’ll have to drive 15 minutes to go and collect them, but I thought at least I’d try them.

3 weeks later and I’ve heard nothing. I‘ve used up my old lenses and I have an event this weekend that I’d really like not to wear glasses to. So I called to see whether my lenses had come in yet.

The very friendly girl in the optician’s answered and told me no, they’re still not here and they are having supply issues due to COVID and Brexit etc etc.

I understand that, and said no worries, and asked if I could please get a copy of my prescription. My thinking being, that I will still pay for and try these new lenses as and when they arrive, but that in the meantime I can order new lenses online that will be here in a couple of days and I can wear them at the weekend.

I was told I couldn’t have my contact lens prescription as the optician himself would have to “sign that off” and that there would be a £40 charge for this.

I was astonished to hear this, I’ve never had an issue getting my prescription from another optician and I already paid £35 for the test when I had it done 3 weeks ago!

I queried this, as surely I should be able to have access to my own private medical information?! She remained adamant that she couldn’t give it to me and that I’d have to make another appointment for the optician to sign off on this and pay £40 for the privilege.

Does anyone know whether this is legal?! I’ve never heard of this before. But having gone to a local reputable optician, and having paid to have my eyes tested, surely I have the right to the results of that test?

OP posts:
Eryr22 · 27/02/2023 09:44

Optician here, you're definitely entitled to your prescription free of charge. Was one not given to you after your appointment? It's a legal obligation. She is correct that an optician will need to sign it before it's given to you though.

SaltyGod · 27/02/2023 09:54

I had something similar, an optician at a well known high street firm was very short with me, almost aggressive, when I said I didn't want to order lenses through him or switch to his suggested brand.

It might be that he has to 'sign off' your current lenses as suitable perhaps

Mine said it was 'unethical' for me to ask
him to provide my lense prescription when I was going to buy them online (I had no issues with current well known brand, I was wearing them at the time and he could see that they were decent)

Eryr22 · 27/02/2023 10:50

Ah after reading your post again I'm wondering if it's a case of what @SaltyGod said. If you're trying a new contact lens and haven't been seen for an end of trial you can't be signed off on it yet. However, if the check was done on the contact lenses you buy online, then yes you should be entitled to it!

TwoDrifters2 · 27/02/2023 11:00

So when the new lenses are here and I go to get them “fitted”, I should then be able to walk away with a copy of my prescription free of charge?

OP posts:
WeAreTheHeroes · 27/02/2023 11:06

Yes. The one thing I have found is that on glasses prescriptions the optician won't note the pupillary distance which you usually do need for new glasses. Obviously that doesn't apply to contact lenses. I've also not had a problem obtaining new glasses via Glasses Direct without this. I'm not going to pay the high price my optician wants for glasses I pretty much only wear going to and from the bathroom to put my lenses in and take them out or wear for a couple of hours on a weekend morning.

AnnotherReader · 27/02/2023 11:09

I get my lenses online from lenstore who have links with vision express so I can have a free eye test and contact lens check up at vision express.
Does the site you use not offer anything similar?

TwoDrifters2 · 27/02/2023 11:21

AnnotherReader · 27/02/2023 11:09

I get my lenses online from lenstore who have links with vision express so I can have a free eye test and contact lens check up at vision express.
Does the site you use not offer anything similar?

That’s such a great idea! I use Vision Direct and I don’t think they have anything like that but I’ll check!

OP posts:
HelloDear11 · 21/01/2025 11:43

I work at an eye clinic alongside my boss / Optometrist and owner. Throughout the five years that I've been employed I've learned alot. Of course, each office / clinic operates differently and have different processes when it comes to their contact lens fitting / eye exams protocols / procedures.

By law, upon completion of an eye examination (comprehensive which in insurance terms is the same as a routine eye exam) you are to be given a copy of your spectacle Rx. This Rx is only for eyeglasses whether or not you ask for it. However, its NOT unusual, that the Optometrist or / Opthalmologist may hold off on finalizing a patient's Rx if he/she discovers or suspects a patient may have something such as an underlining health issue... corneal abrasions, chronic dry eyes, retinal detachment, corneal ulcer/scarring, uncontrolled diabetes, high cholesterol, etc. If so, the doctor will share these findings with the patient, the risks and educate... then make recommendations. Depending on the findings, risk, condition, the doctor may refer a patient out to see a Specialist for further evaluation... most times, the doctor will recommend a treatment plan... order the patient to follow it for a specific duration of time and then have the patient schedule a follow up appointment to come back. At that time the doctor will conduct another examination. Most times, the doctor will finalize the Rx... given that there are no other issues etc.

That is the FIRST part of an eye examination. If a patient wants a cl Rx, he/she will need to be fitted for contact lenses... which is the second part of an eye examination and can be done together... The cost of the contact lens fitting is NOT included with an eye examination. There is a separate fee...fees will vary and your out of pocket cost will depend i.e., new wearer / new patient vs. established patient / experienced wearer, the complexity of your prescription, the type of lenses, whether you have, will be using your vision insurance benefits. Vision insurance if in network with the clinic/doctor rendering the fitting... have a negotiated contract. The amount you pay for the cl fitting, if using your vision insurance cl benefits is the amount set by your plan.

Also, you as the patient have a right to inform or share with the doctor the contact lenses you've worn in the past, currently wearing or would like to get fitted for. HOWEVER, YOU ARE NOT THE DOCTOR AND ARE NOT LICENSED... understand that eyes DO change... a cl fitting is tailored to YOU. Just because you've always worn a specific line or type of cls from a brand, DOES NOT mean that they will always be it. Hence, this is why its called a "cls fitting". The doctor is the one with the professional experience and license to practice and will determine which contact lenses may be the better or best option based off of measurements obtained from the exam, your lifestyle, your preference in wear schedule, etc. New patients who have never worn cls before ARE REQUIRED to go through training with an experienced staff member... who will go over the risks, benefits, how to properly clean, insert, remove, handle/care for and store cls. Patients must be able to demonstrate ability safely and properly remove and insert the trial lenses / pass training before being given the opportunity to take them home to try out during the trial period... return for a followup... upon a satisfactory visual evaulation by the doctor and patient reports no issues during take home trial period... the doctor will then finalize the cl Rx and MUST give the patient a copy of it... UNDER THE EXCEPTION, the patient have paid the fitting fee(s) in full. If a patient is noncompliant, did not complete the fitting (didnt come back for follow up appointments) etc...Rx will most likely not be finalized and may have to pay additional fees, etc.

Lastly, the clinic/dr must provide patients who pay out of pocket for the contact lens fitting... complete the fitting their Cls prescriptions once finalized. They cannot withhold it from patients REGARDLESS if the patients decide to purchase through them or elsewhere. HOWEVER, if a patient uses his/her vision insurance benefits... some plans like Davis Vision CLEARLY STATE something along the lines of "A contact lens fitting is not a separate component of the contact lens benefit, a claim must include the contact lens fitting in conjuction with a purchase of contact lenses for reimbursement or payment to be considered. "

Yeah. In a case like that... the plan may indicate the cl fitting to be collected as $20. However, if a patient pays $20 for the fitting, but, does not complete the fitting / or do not purchase contact lenses through the clinic... Davis Vision (that specific) plan will NOT reimburse or pay the doctor/clinic the remainder of the cls fitting up to the allowed or contracted amt. If this is the case, the patient will need to cough up the amount of the cl fitting fee less any copay already collected or must purchase cls directly from the clinic before the clinic will release the final Rx.

P.S. Most offices DO NOT include PD measurements when they give patients their prescriptions... because:

  1. PD measurements are taken upon ordering and purchase of eyeglasses. If you only want the Rx but didnt make a purchase, your PD measurements were not taken. If you've purchased eyeglasses from that particular office/clinic/provider before... they may give it you if you ask; however, because changes in your eyes do occur overtime; some patients experience gradual changes over time, while others may experience drastic changes in a short period... PD measurements are customised and can change too and it depends on who takes your PD measurements. The measurements may differ in a situation such as: an inexperienced optical staff vs. trained and experienced optician, Optometrist, etc.

Its usually not a big problem if a patient has a mild or low single vision Rx. These patients can usually order just about any type of frames, whether fitted or oversized and might not run into issues... however, for those patients who have higher prescriptions, high astigmatism, presbyopia, etc. Many patients 38 years old and older who use to see just fine with single vision lenses begin to notice their Rx changing, having more trouble seeing or focusing on distant words or things... as well as having a bit of an issue reading a book or viewing text messages... calling for a different type of lens... like Antifatigue/sync lenses... as their vision continues to change they will eventually benefit from either lined bifocal lenses or no line bifocal aka progressive lenses which allows them to see near, intermediate and distant... for those type of lenses... accurate measurements (pd, segment height, and or optical center height, and the fit / size of the frames are all important!!!). Oversized frames can cause distortions and movements that make it very difficult for a person to wear or see... thus, causing headaches, blurred visual acuity, etc. Thats why PROFESSIONAL Optometrists, Opthalmologists, and experienced Opticians/Assistants, etc. who have the best interest of their patients at heart will NEVER encourage their patients or any patients who need lined bifocal / progressive and computer lenses to order online!!!! Its recommended to go into an actual optical store or office to purchase glasses in person... so measurements are done in person by a person and not by guess like online retailers do.

Whyherewego · 21/01/2025 11:44

TwoDrifters2 · 27/02/2023 11:00

So when the new lenses are here and I go to get them “fitted”, I should then be able to walk away with a copy of my prescription free of charge?

You can just copy the prescription off the boxes. If they are delayed then just ask them to give you a trial pair for your event

PrincessAnne4Eva · 21/01/2025 11:45

ZOMBIE THREAD!

Chemenger · 21/01/2025 11:46

Since the OP was posting almost two years ago the chances are she’s got her lenses now.

Whyherewego · 21/01/2025 11:46

Or ask them for a copy.of the order they've placed. That should give the prescription !

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread