Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

General health

Mumsnet doesn't verify the qualifications of users. If you have medical concerns, please consult a healthcare professional.

Advice needed

8 replies

essexgirl58 · 12/04/2022 01:30

I have mild sciatica. I have been seeing a physiotherapist. The physio tests me at each session. I am asked to bend and touch toes then lay down on the bed and lift legs up and then down again and then the physio takes each leg and asks me to swiel from side to side whilst laying down. When i do these things I am asked if any of these things are painful to do and I say no Then I am asked to walk up and down whih I do like anyone else without sciatica does. Then I am asked to stand on one leg an then the other which again I do with no pain.

The conclusion is that I am in a very goo way because all these things cause me no pain. However I do get a flare up every now an again. The physiotherapist does not see me when I get a flare up. For example when I firsyt get out of bed, I have a flare up and am limping an then after waloing for some time the pain goes away. when I attnd the physiothereapy sessions I walk there and the walk eases any pain I may hae had beorehan so when I get there I am fine. Also too much walking in inottry footwear can cause a flare up so although I can wear heels, it can only be for a short period. If I need to do a lot of walking I have to wear either trainers or flat shoes and then its ok.

I hae exercises to do at home and I was told that they have to be perormed every two hours. The reason is to stop getting flare ups. I told my physiotherapist that I do not think my scatica will ever completely go because I have bulging discis and the discs bulge and hit the sciatic nere and the only way to shift the iscs abck into proper alighnment and stop them hitting the nerve is with surgery.

My physiotherapist disagrees an says with regular exercise the discs can go backwards which means no more nerve pain. I honestly think this is a dangerous thing to say. The reaity of the situation is that once discs bulge they stay that way and from reading other peoples posts on here who have sciatica, they have had it for years so how dare any physiotherapist tell a patient that it will go away with exercise. I am a realist not a fantacist and the reality of the situation is that my sciatica can be managed ie learning what causes a flare up and knowing what to do to avoicd such a flare up ie no extensive walking in anything other than flat shoes.

I would absolutely love my physioterapist to see me struggling to walk first thing in the morning or at any time when I hae been laying in bed. they only see me for a short half hour session every so often and are fooled into thinking I am doing very well so much so that they have now said they do not think I need to go to any more sessions for a few weeks. I have got this for the rest of my life and try as I may, I cannot get the physiotherapist to think the same way.

Its a good job I have my head screwed on and am not gulible enough to believe whatever rubbish is fed to me. . I know some people might say why am I questioning a trained physio but the fact is it is very dangrous to generalise and some people who maybe have mental health issues who are told oh your sciatica will get better and eventually completely go away can send theri mental health spiriling out of control if what they are told does not happen and it could be a very dangrous outcome

OP posts:
essexgirl58 · 12/04/2022 01:42

My physio said book another appointment if you need to. What is the point? if and when I do I will be told oh you will eventually be completely better. Also I have never heard of anyone being told to exercise every couple of hours. I honestly think it is a waste of time and too often. Most people are told to exercise two or three times a day.

OP posts:
essexgirl58 · 12/04/2022 01:47

Keeping your back strong and healthy with exercise helps ward off sciatica pain, but it’s not a guarantee. Sometimes, overuse from exercise may exacerbate sciatica issues. And, while exercise and stretching is often prescribed as part of a comprehensive sciatica treatment plan, it’s not always a cure for the pain.

I got this online. This proves my physiotherapist is talking rubbish

OP posts:
alexdgr8 · 12/04/2022 01:49

well, you could try to get another physio, or complain to this one's employer and/or governing body.
i wouldn't waste time or energy trying to convince them of anything about your condition.
good luck.

essexgirl58 · 12/04/2022 03:14

@alexdgr8

well, you could try to get another physio, or complain to this one's employer and/or governing body. i wouldn't waste time or energy trying to convince them of anything about your condition. good luck.
why woul I want to complain? I thought this person was good. I had someone previoiusly who was terrible and when I foun this one things seemed better. I wil admit though my sciatica is mil compared to other peoples.

My only point is that this will not go away and I have told the physiotherapist but it falls on deaf ears; How can they be sure it will completely go? They are not God

OP posts:
essexgirl58 · 12/04/2022 03:20

I was tod I am able to ride a bycicle and run for public transport (not running as in jogging) and my previous physiotherapist said no way do you run for public transport so when I mentioned this I was told but at that time you must have been worse for them to say that. The previous thereapist was conerned that running would make me worse but the current person said running is perfectly acceptable and that I should lead a normal life

No two medics wil give the same answers or reasonings and they will all have different views as to what is right or wrong so who the hell do you believe

OP posts:
essexgirl58 · 12/04/2022 03:35

Also my previoius therapist gave me a couple of sessions of accupuncture. My current person said accupuncture would do me no good whatsoever and a complete waste of time.

OP posts:
alexdgr8 · 12/04/2022 17:57

your whole thread is a complaint about your pphysio.
but we can't do anything to resolve it, so that is why i suggested you make aformal complaint.
if you are not satisfied with your physio, try to get a different one, o maybe an oesteopath ?
but.never.go.near.chiropractor.
as for who you believe, well that is a matter of your own judgement. you obviously seem i
unhappy with present physio, but seem to be wasting time and attention in trying to argue with them.
just change. start again.
do you see a doctor/consultant for your condition.
there are many sites for sufferers of various conditions.
you might get some useful insight from one of them.
good luck.

essexgirl58 · 12/04/2022 18:37

I woul have thought someone on here might have said exercises every two hours is too much or its ok. Also I would have expected someone to say accupuncture is good and your physio is wrong to say its not or you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread