Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

General health

Mumsnet doesn't verify the qualifications of users. If you have medical concerns, please consult a healthcare professional.

Any RECURRENT cystitis sufferers? Or interstitial cystitis sufferers? And/or medics/microbiologists who have suffered and/or have and interest in these things?

67 replies

isitabiofilm · 09/10/2013 14:43

Hi,

I am part of a closed Facebook group trying to build discussion about new research on diagnosis and treatment of recurrent and interstitial cystitis. We are really interested to find medics (clinicians AND researchers) and cellular biologists (research and path lab practioners) who have some experience of recurrent UTIs and Interstitial Cystitis. If you would like more information about the FB group, please PM me and I will send you the link, or indeed post it here if people are keen.

We would also invite other women who are suffering to come and join us for a conversation there. We have created this group because we are a small but distinctive group who are persuaded by new and emerging research that recurrent and interstitial cystitis may well be caused by bacterial biofilm in the bladder. But standard NHS diagnosis and treatment does not currently recognise this science, as it seems not to have caught up with microbiological research in this developing field. We are trying to collaborate as patients to help women who are suffering ongoing pain, invasive surgical treatments, and are faced with a lack of understanding and diagnostic options.

For example, I have suffered from recurrent cystitis for nearly 30 years, pretty much every time I have sex. I have suffered GPs, nurses and even MN telling me I must be not clean enough, or that I must be 'wiping badly'. I have had practice staff telling me there can't possibly be an infection because the dipstick showed nothing, despite the agonising pain, incontinence, cloudy red urine from all the blood, visible lumps of pus and the fact if they do give anti-biotics, instant relief occurs.

Gradually though, the bouts have begun to join together to create ongoing pain in between serious bouts, faster onset of a serious bout, and resistance (I assume) to standard antibiotics such as cephalexin.

I found some help and advice via the Cystitis and Overactive Bladder foundation, but there is a LOT of vested interest and resistance to the idea that recurrent/interstitial cystitis might be different versions of the same thing, and the Urology community has a typical profile of diagnosis and treatment that has decided (because typical urine testing shows up certain results) that bacteria is NOT involved in IC.

Some scientists and a tiny number of clinicians disagree, and a body of work is emerging on the increasing role of biofilm in infective illness. We have links to a wide range of published academic sources on our FB page outlining this, as well as some simpler explanations: in essence, the idea is that multiple types of bacteria build 'communities' within the cells of the bladder wall, that are then protected by various architectures and chemical barriers. They form 'pod-like' groups, which then effectively spread outwards. All the while, very FEW planktonic bacteria (ie those free floating in the urine) are detectable.

Alongside this, standard UTI and IC testing is based on a 48 hour agar plate, which is simply not long enough for some volumes of this planktonic bacteria to show up: which is hypothesised as the reason why many women with UTI or IC symptoms show up as having insufficient infective material in their urine.

Also, this is compounded by the working assumptions of path labs, which assume that small numbers of other bacteria that show up (eg alongside the usual culprit which is e.coli) are there by accident, ie. a contaminated sample or jar etc.. Some scientists are proposing that the numbers of certain virulent and AB resistant bacteria (in particular, for example in my case, Enterococcus Faecalis) need to be re-assessed downwards in terms of numbers needed, and better culturing techniques are needed to identify them.

There's a lot more to say, and I'm no scientist/clinician, so apologies if the terminology is all wrong, but a few international women with a very strong desire to crack this debilitating condition are gathering to try to share information and perhaps build a campaign, or at least better access to treatment. We would love to hear from you, especially if you're a science/medical professional who can help us translate the science, or help with trying to develop treatment options, or writing summaries for both patient and primary care people. It's all very amateur right now, but since we know there are millions and millions of women suffering IC and recurrent UTIs with very little chance of relief, we hope you'll help us.

And if you're a sufferer and wish to try out the evidence about whether treatment of IC as a bacterial disease might help, please come and talk to us.

We already know there is lots of controversy about this, lots of natural health people who hate ABs, and lots of people worried about AB over-use and resistance. Our group is for mutual support and information sharing about this very particular approach; there are plenty of others for you if you want to find an alternative therapeutic approach. In other words, please just don't tell us we need to wash better, or that all our problems will be solved by cranberry juice or drinking more water: if there's an alternative therapy around we've tried it, and if there's a view that antibiotics are the work of the devil, we've already heard it!

Thanks...

OP posts:
eggyweggies · 11/10/2013 22:31

I'm definitely prone to them. I get them a lot when sexually active, and even when I'm not, when I get a little bit dehydrated the symptoms are suddenly back.

Apologies for this question. But does anyone get smelly wee with it?

isitabiofilm · 13/10/2013 13:06

Vivalethrustbadger, do come and talk to us on FB. There are people it's loads of experience and advice. And there's a couple of medics in the UK who take a different approach to recurrent UTI and interstitial cystitis. You might even be able to persuade your own GP to take a new approach...

OP posts:
isitabiofilm · 13/10/2013 13:06

With. Not its...

OP posts:
isitabiofilm · 13/10/2013 13:07

Eggyweggies I don't get psrticularly smelly wee but I can understand why it would be if you were either dehydrated or there was some infection.

OP posts:
idlevice · 13/10/2013 22:59

I think I had a "physiology" issue that caused my recurrent cystitis over about 6yrs, usually precipitated by sex & despite all the washing, drinking, etc After a few years of it I had a fibroid diagnosed which grew in time & my gynae said it was like being pregnant, ie when the uterus size is slightly bigger than usual like early pregnancy (or having a smallish fibroid) the uterus/bladder position can be troublesome, but later on the uterus expands more upwards so the uterus/bladder relationship is not so bad. So although the cystitis seemed to disappear I've had larger fibroids to contend with. Obviously I don't know if there genuinely was a link but it seemed to fit.

My sympathies for anyone afflicted, it really is crippling. I spent one Glastonbury virtually confined to my tent with it and during another bout I had to miss my nana's funeral Sad

YoniMitchel · 15/10/2013 21:13

I suffered for years too, found great relief taking Waterfall D Mannose made by Sweet Cures of York, interestingly I haven't had any symptoms since I had DC either. I think my cystitis was caused by stress, I'm a teacher and never had it over the summer holidays.

AngelDog · 16/10/2013 21:16

Some cases of IC are caused/exacerbated by something called oxalate, which is a naturally occurring chemical in plant foods. Many people's symptoms have improved with reducing dietary oxalate.

lowoxalate.info/index.html

AgathaPinchBottom · 16/10/2013 22:18

I suffered for ten years... Now Use an antibiotic after sex to control it... But had the camera etc etc and years of agony. Nitrafurantoin really helps me and I want to recommend an Amazing urologist called professor Malone-lee, (at Whittington hospital, archway) an amazing man who really takes it seriously and studies each urine sample himself and has a rather maverick but results driven approach.he saved me. Good luck to everyone.

isitabiofilm · 16/10/2013 22:24

Agatha, yes he's one of the two UK medics people on FB have contacted. The other is a Dr in Staffordshire. Visit the page or PM me for details. We have collated a whole load of links to academic data on IC and recurrent BC and the jury is still out but treating IC as an embedded biofilm with long term ABs works well for some people.

OP posts:
AgathaPinchBottom · 16/10/2013 22:39

Oh brilliant! Yes will do! Thanks isit

MarshmallowRoot · 26/10/2013 00:24

I am being investigated for IC, after years and years of bladder pain and recurrent infections. My bladder and urethra feel "raw" if that makes sense.

Both times after my pregnancies I have been fine for 1-3 years and then a UTI (E Coli in my case) , "sets it off" again, and even though no infection cultures after treatment, I still believe it's bacterial because the 3 times it started (was only ever 'stopped' by pregnancy / childbirth) were all TRIGGERED by a bout of cystitis / UTI.

I have all sorts of upsetting and painful bladder symptoms, and I too have been fobbed off and told I have Overactive Bladder when I know this is NOT the case , I cannot physically go more than say 4-5 times a day (normal frequency), yet the pain and feeling of needing is always there.

I am finally seeing a specialist who knows what to look for and treats IC , after years of no luck with doctors, so hopefully I will know soon.

I have made a request to join the FB group x

VeryNotNormal · 27/10/2013 07:19

I've suffered with recurrent cystitis for 12 years and have been on antibiotics (Nitrofurantoin) for the last 5 years which I take after sex and which prevent an infection. Sex is the trigger for me, I'd never had cystitis before I became sexually active.

The most recent consultant I saw said he suspected it might be IC, but surely that can't be the case if the ABs are working? He wants to put a camera up my urethra and take a biopsy and pictures of my bladder but I'm not convinced that won't make my problem worse in the long run... It sounds v invasive.

At the moment the ABs are working so I'm just working with those for now. I am frustrated though, because I don't think there is enough research in this area. I've seen several consultants and they seem clueless.

If I go back to my consultant again (I'm paying privately) then I have a list of questions to ask him which might be of interest:

  • Do recurrent, long term infections cause IC and/or damage to bladder lining?
  • What makes me different?
  • How many women do have this as severely?
  • What could the cystoscopy and biopsy show? Deep-seated bladder infection? Strep? What else?
  • Can you repair my bladder lining? Damaged due to multiple infections?
  • Allergic reaction (e.g. bladder lining irritated as a result of eating something)?
  • Mycobacteria?
  • Kink in the urethra?
  • Urethra collapsing after sex?
  • If it isn't IC, what could it be?
  • Could it be related to hormones (e.g. hormone deficiency)? If so, should the combined pill have improved matters?
  • Bacterial biofilm in the bladder?
  • Avoiding sugar and processed, high GI food helps with the intensity of pain when I get an infection presumably because these things cause inflammation?
  • Is IC just a low-level bacterial infection that isn't being picked up by standard tests?
  • What is IC? Is it what they label me when they don't know what the cause is?

I've requested to join the FB group you posted, thanks.

VeryNotNormal · 27/10/2013 07:36

eggyweggies - yes, smelly wee is normal if you have an infection. I went to see a nurse once with a sample who commented on how much it stank! Embarrassing.com.

Occasionally when I get v dehydrated (e.g. when I've been in the recording studio all day) I can get an infection.

I take D-Mannose daily (two in the morning) and I find this helps to avoid the dehydration-related incidents.

FizzyFeet · 27/10/2013 07:52

Hi all - apologies if many of you know this or it's been discussed before, but I was really interested when I heard it as it goes against standard advice for cystitis. A pharmacist once recommended - totally off the record - that after a day or so of taking antibiotics, you should hold on as long as possible before peeing, rather than the standard advice of emptying your bladder as soon as you need to. The theory is that bacteria can get trapped in the little crinkles of your urethra, and that 'holding on' helps straighten the structure out, thus getting to the bacteria hiding in the crinkles. This approach worked for me (cystitis triggered by sex as an adult; long history of urinary probs as a child). Worth further investigation as a theory?

cathw15 · 27/10/2013 10:21

This is a really important area which is seriously under researched. Lots of links to interstitial cystitis - the diagnosis you are given when you have ongoing bladder pain and they can't find the cause. Really pleased you have taken then the initiative and will do anything to help. Having being told by a urologist that I should just go away and put up with my 'women's problems' ( yes - he actually said that!!!), it is also an area where some education is required for clinicians as very few take this problem seriously.

isitabiofilm · 27/10/2013 17:24

VeryNotNormal, do come and join us on FB as there are lots of women who know what questions to prioritise with your Uro consultant. We have lots of links to the latest science on biofilms (intracellular bacterial communities as they are officially called) and the problems with current diagnostic techniques. As our group understands it, IC is a syndrome which exists because Doctors don't know how to classify or cure it. It is a collection of symptoms but they still don't know what causes it, or how to treat it successfully. This is controversial among those diagnosed with IC or chronic cystitis since having a diagnosis is sometimes helpful to those women in various ways. But there are lots of IC groups which pursue the orthodox medical line; we are trying to explore where those orthodoxies need to be challenged by the newest scientific opinion, even if this makes it hard to get acceptance by clinicians. Eventually we think new diagnostics and treatments will come, in the meantime, there are a couple of clinicians in the UK who think differently...

OP posts:
isitabiofilm · 27/10/2013 17:28

Cathw, absolutely. There is so much vested interest in this area, and so much of the old women's health politics. We are fortunate that some scientists are exploring new options.

But the NHS really needs to start taking note and this is where women need to shout louder. We have lots of evidence that the standard 'urine is sterile' and 'your urine has no bugs' response that we always get when dipsticks or cultured, is just plain WRONG!

OP posts:
isitabiofilm · 27/10/2013 17:30

Ah see some of you have asked to join already. Word is getting out and the organiser is a bit overwhelmed by requests, so please bear with her!

OP posts:
AnnaFiveTowns · 04/01/2014 08:31

Hi - I realise I've come a bit late to the thread - but as a sufferer of recurrent cystitis for 25 years, I am desperate to find a decent urologist. Could anyone please inbox me the name of the Staffordshire doctor as I'm based nearby. I am sick of being told "your urine's clear" when I know I have an infection. I have also requested to join the Facebook group.

amberstatt2 · 31/07/2014 06:38

Can I have the Facebook page please? ???

Ilovefluffysheep · 31/07/2014 18:46

And me please.

FishWithABicycle · 31/07/2014 18:55

This is a zombie thread last active over 6 months ago. I'd be interested too but I suspect the OP may not be around on MN any more.

lmfarre01 · 08/09/2014 22:44

Prof. Malone-Lee is one of the few doctors in the UK treating chronic bladder infections which are left undetected by regular GP urine testing.

I have had chronic and constant symptoms of a UTI for over 7 years, feeling pain and urgency when I need to urinate yet very little urine coming out, and waking up between 3 and 5 times every night with pain in my bladder, back and legs which is only relieved by urinating.

I have been told numerous times by my GP that nothing is wrong with me and was once told to "just try holding it in." I was then wrongly diagnosed with Overactive Bladder and put on medication which had no effect for 2 years. I've been sent to bladder retraining clinics and told it need to cut out all alcohol, caffeine and citrus from my diet. None of this made a difference.

After finally putting my foot down and insisting on seeing the best doctor possible I was referred to Prof. Malone-Lee who immediately found a chronic infection within the walls of my bladder which is finally treated me with a long course of antibiotics.

For the first time in 7 years I can feel my symptoms easing off and have some hope that I will be able to lead a normal life again.

Loucat01 · 30/09/2014 13:48

Is this face book page still work. I believe this is the route I need to go down as well. I was diagnosed with IC in July, suffered for almost a year after last baby was born by c section.

Nicki86 · 23/10/2014 09:39

Hello, is this group still available on Facebook? I believe I have it since giving birth last year, I find the doctors very unhelpful. I believe bacteria is the main cause of this horrible illness and I really want to start this antibiotic therapy. Help needed please. Thank you

Swipe left for the next trending thread